Paige showed me the text and we both looked at each other with big eyes wondering if she had seen us at the dance club or somehow knew that Paige was across the hall last night. Paige set up to meet her in the afternoon for coffee. Just about that time Blake opened the door and plopped down on the couch right next to Paige. Paige grabbed his knee and gave it a squeeze and shocked me by saying.
"Thanks for keeping us up last night! How much did you have to pay that girl to exaggerate about how BIG your cock is?"
At first the always witty, talkative, and outgoing Blake was caught wide eyed and speechless. He had to have known we heard what went on last night but I think he was shocked to hear Paige confront him and even more shocked to hear her joke about his cock. However, he came back to himself and retorted:
"Oh Paige. I would show you that there was no exaggeration on her part right now but James and I are best friends and I wouldn't want to make him feel bad or you get embarrassed."
She punched him in the arm and they both laughed before the banter continued.
"I will say that James and I enjoyed the performance you guys put on."
Blake countered, "Probably not as much as Greg and Matt enjoyed the show you two put on last night on the couch! I hear you look pretty hot on all fours."
I looked to my girlfriend afraid that he had taken it too far. Greg and Matt were friends of ours that often hung out in Blake's room with us. I feared that she would never be able to face them again. Again she stunned me:
"I'm glad they enjoyed. I bet you wish you could have been there to watch too."
Blake responded, "Of course I do. Who wouldn't want to see you like that? We all talk about how lucky James is and how he better not screw up."
I know I should have stopped the banter but for some reason it was turning me on to listen to them. They both laughed and we went on like nothing ever happened. As Blake got up to head to the shower Paige asked him:
"Hey I think I know the girl that you came home with last night. Did my name ever come up in conversation?
"No. Why?" He asked puzzled.
"Because she texted me out of the blue this morning and wanted to meet me for coffee and ask a favor. Just wondering if last night has anything to do with it."
In typical Blake fashion he exited by saying,
"Hmm. I don't know. Maybe she liked my cock so much she wants to share it with you?"
As he shut the door Paige turned back to me. An awkward silence fell over us as we both took in the fact that two of our friends spied on us fucking last night. In addition, Paige just flirted with my best friend about how big his cock was and how much all my friends talked about wanting to fuck her. I was conflicted with feelings from embarrassment to excitement. Paige came to me and kissed me passionately before saying:
"I love you James. I am finding that the more we explore sexually the more I love you and want you. I hope you don't mind me being a little naughty but I wouldn't ever do anything more than flirt unless you wanted me to. I'll text you once I meet with Lindsay and let you know if we have trouble."
She gave me one last kiss, ran her hand down my body and felt my cock aroused, and winked at me as she left the room. My Paige was turning into a new sexual being right before my eyes. I kept replaying the words in my head "unless you wanted me to". I was nervous, excited, and confused as I wondered what things she wanted to do with my permission.
A group of us went to the gym to play basketball that afternoon as I anticipated Paige's recap of her visit with Lindsay. Blake and I were heading back from the gym together when he said:
"Hey man I'm sorry if I stepped over the line with Paige this morning. I feel like she's one of my best friends so I got carried away teasing her. Obviously she's hot as hell but I was just playing around. We good?"
I hesitated for a minute. Blake was never one to be serious so obviously this had been eating at him since this morning. I lightened the mood,
"Of course. She's way out of you league anyway. Even with that elephant cock you would have no chance with her. It not the size but how you use it!"
Blake put his arm around me and said, "Keep telling yourself that little man. I could have her if I wanted. Especially now that the cat's out of the bag on my package size."
We laughed and went on as normal back to the house. As we arrived back I heard my phone buzz and I looked down to find a text from Paige.