Let's start this story with a little back round, my wife Kayla and I have been in the "hotwife" lifestyle for a little over a year now. I am not a cuck, but I enjoy watching my wife fuck other guys in front of me, and then my favorite part is getting to reclaim her. It took years for Kayla to agree, and she did only because the circumstances were perfect. Since the first time we have found only three guys that met Kayla and I's standards that we ended up meeting with. One ended up being married himself and couldn't perform because of the guilt we think when the time came. Those two other guys were internet finds and ended up fucking my sweet wife. It is the most erotic thing to me and she really is liking it too.
So, about a two months ago, I suggested to her that since she really liked the hooking up with a guy that she may want to try multiple guys at the same time. Kayla asked "a gangbang? I doubt I could handle that; I can barely handle you and one other guy". I gently reassured her that she could handle anything and that she may end up loving it. She kept disagreeing but in a teasingly way. Every time we made love, I would mention a gangbang and how much I would love having her pussy soaked in multiple men's come. She noticed that it made me come even faster than the one random guy fantasy.
Kayla and I met a new guy online that wanted to meet up and have dinner. Usually, I have the guy we are meeting buy us dinner and make sure that he is respectful to me but also especially Kayla. I don't want someone who is a dick getting a piece of my wife. Kayla also has to agree that the guy is nice and respectful before we move things forward. Anyway, we scheduled dinner a week out due to some scheduling conflicts and I booked a room at a nearby hotel for the "after party".
Kayla and I met John online together, but John and I did some side talking. John mentioned that he had been a part of a gangbang a few years ago and liked it. It was an adult birthday party that had gone further than expected and the birthday girl got banged instead of spanked, I guess. I asked John if he was against trying one for Kayla and he agreed to try. He said he would still pay for dinner if he got to go first. I laughed and agreed as long as he kept the gangbang a secret. I had a lot of work to do in the next week.
I went online and checked the criteria for gangbang under our profile. A ton of people came up and I started searching. I ended up finding four more guys who agreed to be there that night and seemed like nice and respectful enough that I would let have a piece of Kayla. Tom, Nick, Anthony and Steve were the guys and I ended up meeting them in person. I asked for them to have medical screens done so that they didn't have to wear condoms. They emailed me the medical paperwork the night before and I told them to get to the room about 30 minutes before we did. I told them that it was a surprise and I wasn't sure if it was a sure thing. They agreed and wanted to roll the dice.
On, date night as we called it, Kayla was dressed super sexy. She was almost falling out of her dress which got us extra attention from our waiter. She was being more flirtatious than usual and was really taking a liking to John. He was a very respectful guy and seemed to genuinely like us. He didn't ignore me either which was important to me. John went to the bathroom before dessert came and Kayla and I agreed that John was a good guy and Kayla wanted to go the distance with him. When John got back, he got the check and we headed to the hotel. My phone was blowing up during dinner with the guys getting impatient. Can't blame them after seeing Kayla's picture. All the guys but Tom were there. He ended up ghosting us and I never heard from him again. Come to find out these things are common when organizing gangbangs.
The three other guys were waiting in a separate room next to us that connected. The plan was I was going to text them when we were ready, and they were going to come in quietly until I told them otherwise. John and I convinced Kayla that she should be blindfolded once the sex began so it would "enhance the senses".