When we got to the party I was a lot more relaxed than the first time because I felt more experienced with the place and the "routine", and the anonymity offered by the mask was a great security blanket. He disappeared almost immediately, and after a few minutes came back with some drinks. After a little chit chat, a couple drinks and a little flirting, we retired to the alcove we had used before. Jim was on me like a mad man. His hands and fingers explored every part of me as my heart started racing. He slipped his handkerchief under my mask to cover my eyes and at first I was nervous about that, but realized that maybe it was better to not see anything that might be about to happen. Pretty soon Jim had my blouse unbuttoned and was sucking and kissing my now firm nipples, and had my skirt up around my waist rubbing my clit and fingering my vagina. (As the sign outside our local Krispy Kreme donut shop says, I was "Hot and Ready".)
As I heard Jim whisper, "I love you" I felt his cock slide into me. He whispered, "It feels so good inside you". And at that moment I thought that his penis felt different, and then suddenly realized that it wasn't his at all, but someone else's! At first I wondered who it was, but it felt so good I decided I didn't care. All the while Jim was beside me, whispering sweet nothings in my ear, fingering my clit a little, nibbling my nipples a little, and it felt damn good! After a bit of deep pumping, I was approaching an orgasm but I felt my unknown "lover" climax and a few strokes later he withdrew his softening member.
My disappointment was short lived since a moment later a very hard penis replaced it and went deeper inside me than I thought was possible. I realized it was another person. Again, Jim whispered how good it felt, and I exploded into the long awaited mind-blowing orgasm. I thought my heart would stop beating or have a heart attack or something, and meanwhile I couldn't even breathe enough to catch my breath. I tried in vain to get the assault on my insides to stop, but he kept driving harder and deeper and as I thought for sure I would die, I came again and mercifully, so did he. He slowed down and soon withdrew.
Just as I was catching my breath, and counting my blessings for such a good experience and loving husband, I felt myself being entered again. This time it was more broad, but not as long and it felt altogether different. I felt my blood starting to rush again as it again became harder to catch my breath. I came again soon after, and this penis was followed by yet another. I didn't know if it was new or a repeat, but really didn't care much. I knew nothing, cared about nothing, just the wantonness of orgasms coming one after another. For the first time I knew what men meant they said hopefully, "I'm going to fuck your brains out." My brain felt like mush and I cared about nothing except the pleasure.
Soon, thankfully, it was over. There was no one there except Jim telling me he loved me and hugging me. He helped me clean up, removed the eye covering under my mask, and we began to prepare to leave. As we worked our way out, each man I saw, I looked at, wondering if he had been one of them. No one smiled, smirked, winked, or gave any sign that they had fucked me. It was weird!
On the way home, I confessed to Jim how good it had been and what a great gift he had given me. We joked about coming back next Halloween. In the weeks that followed, our sex life improved dramatically as we both thought about and fanaticized about the experience. One night he said, "I can't wait until next Halloween, can you?" I responded that I thought they might have a Mardi Gras party where attendees wore masks also. He laughed and said he'd look into it. Hooray, only two months until Mardi Gras!!