Of course, there was more. I made it clear to Fay that I was fine with whatever happens between her and John. She knew that I wanted to see it for myself. Hearing about it was great, but I really wanted more. I wanted to see her lips surrounding John's cock.
It was really the perfect situation: John and Judy were trusted friends, but we had no friends in common. Our homes are 400 miles apart. They are happy with their marriage, we are happy with ours. For whatever crazy reasons, none of us are jealous of the other. It couldn't have been more liberating. We had only to explore the possibilities.
True to his word, John volunteered to treat for dinner. The spa restaurant was actually highly rated and we decided to sacrifice the best bottle of wine that we had brought along, a 1990 Bordeaux. Fay decided to dress for the occasion, a real dress over garters, black stockings, no panties, and a bra that totally exposed her nipples. I was excited to see John's reaction, and whatever getup Judy might put together. I wasn't disappointed.
We made up to meet at the restaurant. Fay and I arrived first and had the waiter decant the wine. Fay and I sat on the same side of a large table. We kissed a bit and spoke about how excited we were to finally explore some fantasies. I reached under the table to find that Fay was without panties. I couldn't resist exploring her wet crotch with my fingers, nor smelling them. I'm certain that she was very worked up.
John and Judy arrived and I was stunned by Judy's costume. Her blouse was totally diaphanous and her nipples were at full attention. It was hard to be sure, but it looked like she had rouged her areolas. My dick was near cramp stage, harder than what was comfortable.