He sanded the wood, blew a little on the surface, and contemplated the winding path of darkness on the tawny wood of the keel. Definitely a crack, but the nature-or-nurture question remained. If the crack was at the surface level, he could fill it with epoxy and sand it. If the crack ran through the board, that meant the wood was just bad wood, and he would have to rebuild the boat to replace the doomed piece.
Richard Thomas looked back to the warm buttery glow of the house lights a hundred yards away as darkness began to infuse the air around him. Having put it off as long as he could, he started the trudge back to his joyless household.
Once upon a time, things had been more promising.
He married Karen Johnson, his high school sweetheart, shortly after college. She would not have even talked to a guy like him who came from a broken home, but she met him at a mixer at their church, which preached free markets and social justice.
"Be nice to the broken home kids," said her father, a psychologist. "They're more like feral animals because life has abused them. Don't expect them to care about helping others, only me-firsting." Karen steered away from most of them, but when staring out into space, accidentally locked eyes with Richard.
"Hey," he said to her in passing. She saw a reasonably muscular boy with bright blue eyes and honey-colored hair, reasonably handsome, and slightly above average height at an inch short of six feet. She knew him to be a bit of a crack-up in class who still got fairly good grades and had made himself some kind of boat that won an award. He scared her because his father was an oil company executive, and those were evil people according to her parents, and she knew Richard as a blunt, outspoken guy who often left hurt feelings in his wake.
"Hey yourself," she said with typical teenage irreverence. He saw a slender girl with an innocent face, unreadable grey eyes, and and bright auburn hair. She carried herself elegantly, like a dancer, and had some muscle from playing field hockey, and he knew she got high grades but was quiet in class, as if waiting for some reason to step out of her shell. An inch short of his height, she seemed lively but unwilling to offer much of herself to the world, although he suspected that if she ever got confident enough to have her own opinions she would have much insight.
They talked for the rest of the night, covering every random topic possible interwoven with the predictable getting-to-know-you ones. Karen went home that night in a state of sublime confusion.
Like most of her generation, Karen had no idea what "love" was or its relationship to attraction and lust. She got one vision from the classic books they read at school, another from Hollywood and popular music, and still another from the church and her parents.
In movies, the handsome man and beautiful woman met in some awkward situation, then started arguing in what her aunt the psychologist called a "co-dependent relationship," but eventually tumbled into bed together and in the morning, discovered they were in love. The books she was assigned in school praised the men and women who shrugged off social pressures to remain virtuous, then met their true love and companion in the midst of doing something selfless. Her parents emphasized finding a man with a good career who would not break up the family but also refused to treat her unequally.
She had never seen Richard as anything but one of the kids who she would leave behind with the rest of high school, but she felt something that might be a desire to make him like her, approve of her, even desire her. Karen and Richard ended up dating during the last year of high school, that bittersweet time when people know that imminent adulthood would split up old friendships and loves.
She knew that Richard scared her too. Once in history class, the teacher noticed that most students were catatonic or asleep, and rounded on Richard with a question about Hitler and Stalin.
"Tyrants mistake what they are for who they could have been," said Richard. "Stalin, a former bank robber, confused power with being important and turned his country into a bureaucratic dictatorship that killed thirty million of its people through sheer incompetence. Hitler, an artist, confused his popularity with being morally right, and started a war that devastated his country. A good leader rules for the sake of his people, not for the sake of his own power or self-image."
The teacher wrinkled his brow. Half of the class had perked up. "But what about the war crimes, the genocides, and the oppression?"
Richard chuckled. "History is written in blood, cruelty, and extermination because these are the only signals that wake people up. Otherwise, they just follow their own inertia. Hitler was like Robespierre, a 'true believer' who ended up executing everyone who disagreed because he needed to believe his ideology was true. Stalin was more like Genghis Khan, a glorified criminal or third world warlord who knew his ideology was nonsense and was able to survive it as a result, mostly by sacrificing others. They're almost as bad as our current leaders, who are doing the same to us, just more slowly."
Karen realized in that moment that there was something about Richard which she could not tame. She liked domesticated men like her father who followed the rules: when her mother had needs, he met them, and if he disagreed, he bit his lip and grudgingly carried it out. Her two parents were equals and discussed every decision together. Richard in comparison looked like some kind of feral animal which acted purely from its gut instinct and heart, and she knew this could not be controlled, but she also knew in her gut that he was the only man she could ever truly love.
"You need to date other boys," said her mother, Beverly. "You can't go through your life having bonded with only one man. That will always be an unequal relationship with him having the upper hand. He needs to know that there are absolute rules that he cannot break. A marriage is just like a small social group, where unless you stake out power for yourself, you will be forced to conform to what others want."
And so Karen found herself putting her name out there and dating other boys. She never got further than heavy petting and oral sex, having learned early on that the best way to end a date without getting naked was to affectionately slurp on a penis. This made her moderately more popular, and she finished high school on a high note. If Richard noticed her skills improving, he never questioned why or at least, never said anything.
Richard got a full scholarship to the same local university she was attending, but Karen's mother decided to experience a wider range of sexual partners. No one was fooled by her "working late" or "girls' night out." The marriage disintegrated like a sparrow hit by a space shuttle, scattering Karen and her brothers to to different apartments on either end of the city with varying degrees of not enough money.
Finally she understood what Richard had endured, except that since his father was an executive for one of the big oil companies, they had possessed more money than her parents, a school psychologist and middle school history teacher. She escaped the genteel middle class poverty and disorder of her home life into marriage with Richard. He got his first major job, and the children started coming: Daniel when Richard was still at entry-level, and Kaya, Robert, and Suzanne after each time he got promoted. Soon they had a nice house in a decent suburb.
"Are you content?" Richard asked Karen one night.
"I think so," she said. "I'm not sure that's the question. Are you happy?"
"Happy..." he said. "I don't believe in it." He read to her from the book he was reading, an old favorite of his that she never really liked:
"You're a rotten driver," I protested. "Either you ought to be more careful, or you oughtn't to drive at all."
"I am careful."
"No, you're not."
"Well, other people are," she said lightly.
"What's that got to do with it?"
"They'll keep out of my way," she insisted. "It takes two to make an accident."
"Suppose you met somebody just as careless as yourself."
"I hope I never will," she answered. "I hate careless people. That's why I like you."
"We are each responsible for our own happiness," said Richard. "It's about being responsible to your own true self. You have to make yourself good so that you can like yourself, and only then can you appreciate what life is really about."
She looked at this man as if she barely knew him. "Seems joyless."
"Not at all, just a realistic outlook," said Richard, lighting his pipe. "
What
you are, your job and how others see you, is not
who
you are. You choose to become who you are. Even love is a choice. As Siddhartha would say, external events are neither happy nor sad, but thinking makes it so."