There is no BTB in this story. This is just a normal and realistic divorce and its aftermath. I wanted to play with the idea that the cheater accepted the consequences of their actions and that acceptance allowed redemption.
***
I knew she was going to be late coming home. There was nothing nefarious about her lateness, for today, at least, I had put a pause on her lies and infidelity. After twenty years, I knew her well enough to know that she was taking the time to put her thoughts in order before our inevitable confrontation. Twenty years, eighteen of those married, and I never thought of doubting her as my partner. I knew she would take her time coming home. She knew that if I had taken action, I would have considered every possible result before pulling the trigger. She had learned quickly in our relationship that a half-baked argument based on emotions did not affect me. So, she would always take time to calculate her counter position before appearing before me.
Unlike the past two decades of disagreements, I was determined not to let my affection for her cloud my judgment. Our twins, Charlie and Max, were spending the night with their grandparents. I wasn't concerned about them. They were sixteen now, fine young men. I had taken the time to share the truth with them as much as they needed to know. Their mother, Christine, was unfaithful to me, not to them. She was their mother; she adored them. Divorce was unavoidable, but I was aware of how much they cherished her. Everything I was about to do was for my own sake, not theirs. They were old enough to have a say in their futures; they would be off to university before we knew it; if they chose to remain with her, I would support them as I had always done. I would still be their father.
They resisted, arguing that their mother's actions had shattered our family, causing them as much pain as she was causing me. They insisted that she had shown as little concern for them as she had for me. They were right, but so was I. Despite the upheaval that was about to unfold, the only certainty I clung to was that Christine loved the boys more than anything. I held onto that belief as I sat in our living room with an unopened bottle of wine and two glasses on the coffee table, ready to face the storm that was about to descend upon us.
It started about six months ago. I caught on almost immediately. We had been together long enough that I knew her better than I knew myself. I knew when she was lying or hiding something. Shifty behaviour around my birthday meant she was planning a surprise. Then came the conversations about Ben, the new younger man in the office. He was charming and funny, a great co-worker and addition to the team. He had the most adorable young family. Then, after hearing about him two or three times a week, he disappeared. Then came the drinks after work. At first, they were every other week, and she was home maybe a couple of hours later than usual. After a month or so, they became weekly. She was never late.
But, after a few more weeks, the alcohol on her breath was replaced by toothpaste when she kissed me hello. Then the kisses disappeared, and she went straight to shower after barely saying hello to me or the boys. When I would ask her about her evening, she became evasive. I went into my secret account, saving up to take our family on a two-week safari, travelling from the Okavango Delta to Victoria Falls before a few days in Cape Town, and hired a PI. I told him I didn't need details, just proof.
They would leave work a few hours early every Friday and head to a hotel. They would stay there for about three, maybe four hours before separating and heading home. I had pictures of them entering the room, kissing as they left and kissing each other goodbye in the car park. I thanked the PI and gave him a nice bonus. I made extra copies of his report and met his wife, Tracey. She was heartbroken when I gave her the news. I held her as she cried and told her I would be her shoulder to cry on. I explained I would be getting a divorce and would be happy to pay my solicitor to take her case on top of mine. It would be no fault under the new laws in the UK, so it would cost me too much for him to double up on the paperwork.
She thanked me and asked me if I planned to confront them. I told her no, that her husband was her business and that my wife was mine, but that I wouldn't interfere if she went after my wife. I would have the pictures and report delivered to them at work just before they left for their weekly liaison. Tracey listened to me before deciding to use my delivery to confront them together and embarrass them at work. I laughed and wished them well. I would use that time to talk to my boys and her parents. I would be honest and tell the truth; I would not let her turn me into the villain.
I was thinking about everything as I waited, willing myself not to give in and open the wine before Christine came home. I had received some videos from my couriers giving me details on the show that had occurred when Tracey confronted them. Christine had run away while Ben pleaded with his wife that Christine meant nothing to him. I was still thinking about it when I heard the door open. Christine was home. She came into the living room, and she looked sad and defeated. There was a time I would have poured her a glass of wine before pulling her feet onto my lap to give her a massage while she told me her woes, but I didn't move.
She noted the room and my lack of movement towards her. Looking at my face, she realised not only that I knew, but I had also been the one to blow it all up. Her shoulders slumped as she took the seat opposite me. She looked at me again, but on meeting my gaze, she instantly looked away, deciding instead to open the bottle of wine on the table and pour us both a glass. We sat in silence for several minutes before she finally spoke.
"You didn't have to bring his wife into this. She's nice, their kids are young, and his family don't deserve this," she told me quietly.
"Are you suggesting that I'm not nice or that our kids deserve this because they're older?" I asked her in response. "You're right, she is nice. She also deserved to know her husband is unfaithful and make her own decisions."
Christine had the grace to look ashamed momentarily before resuming her defensive. "That's not what I'm saying. Scott, they're young; they don't have the foundation we have to work through this."
"What makes you think we're going to work through this?" I asked her. "This isn't a normal fuck up, Christine! You've been fucking someone else for the last three months at least and lying to me about your relationship with him for who knows how long?"
She flinched at my words before continuing her defence. "Whatever I've been doing, I took nothing away from you!" She replied hotly. "I never neglected you or the boys; I was always here."
"You started neglecting me and the boys when you started lying to us about your actions. You were neglecting us when you chose to fuck him instead of being here with your family," I replied. "And never say you took nothing away from me. You took away twenty years of trust in you. You took that away the second I learned you preferred to sneak off to the Galaxie Hotel instead of coming home."
I knew I had hit a target when she looked away. When she spoke, she was less defensive and quieter, "I'm sorry. I shouldn't have said that. Believe it or not, this wasn't about you. At first, it was just flirting, a break from being your wife and the boys' mother. Then, the sexual tension built, and we agreed to one meeting to get over it, and then we couldn't stop. I never thought about him when I was here with you."
"That's bullshit; you can't say it wasn't about me and then say you did it as a break from me," I told her. "You think I believe you never thought about him while you were here? Try again; what were you thinking about when you stopped saying hello to me and the boys so you could shower to wash him off you? Tell me you weren't thinking about him when you would get ready for work on Friday mornings before your hookups?"
I could see her struggling to maintain control. I had been calm thus far; we both knew losing our tempers was a sign of weakness, and neither of us was afraid of pressing our advantage. She looked at me again.