I tried to convince myself that it couldn't be true, that I was imagining things. After all, Sarah wouldn't cheat on me. But the more I looked at things, the more I realized that it had to be, there was no other explanation.
We first met when I was 9 and moved to her neighbourhood where we quickly became friends, part of the neighbourhood gang. But our friendship was stronger than many others. Instinctively we seemed to know when the other was upset or hurting, and quickly became confidants. We knew that we could go to the other and discuss anything, what was happening in our lives, our fears, our hopes or our dreams. As we got older, and started to get interested in the other sex, we would discuss our romances. None of our relationships lasted, probably because we were measuring them up against each other.
I fooled around more than Sarah. With a couple of my girlfriends I was able to grab their breasts under their clothes, and in one case, bare tit under her bra. She was the one who also let me stroke her pussy through her jeans, while she rubbed me through mine. Unfortunately, being a fifteen year old boy at the time, I didn't have much staying power and came in my jeans. What a mess!
Sarah was about five foot five, with gorgeous curly red hair, green eyes and the cutest freckles. Whenever she would blush, the freckles would stand out even more. She was very cute, not glamour pretty, but definitely attractive.
Sarah and I started going out almost out of necessity. I'd broken up with my girlfriend a month and a half before junior prom and Sarah broke up with her boyfriend two weeks before the big event. Rather than miss it, or worse, going stag, we decided to go together. As we danced together that night, especially during the slow ones, we both felt the sparks fly. Despite the fact that Sarah had been vigorously protecting her virginity I knew I could have taken it then. But we didn't fuck each other that night. We were afraid of our new found feelings, and didn't want to risk the friendship we had together.
However, we quickly realized that the feelings were real, and the love we'd discovered, had been there for some time.
It wasn't that long before we did make love. Like a lot of other love struck teenagers it was in the back seat of a car. The sight of her body for the first time was unbelievable. I almost came when I pulled off that lacy bra and saw her breasts, the nipples reaching up for me to devour. When I pulled her panties off and looked at that glistening slit beneath the red curls of her pubic mound, its a wonder I managed to get my cock inside that gorgeous pussy before I came.
She was so tight I was afraid that it wouldn't fit. I still remember pushing the head of my cock in, and reaching the blockage of her hymen. Sarah sensed my hesitation and told me to go ahead and push hard. I was afraid of hurting her, but I followed her instructions, and with a big thrust I was buried deep inside her. Right about then I was feeling pretty good about myself, that is until I started to move. Much to my embarassment, one more good thrust did it and I was cumming. Talk about being mortified.
Instead of laughing at me, Sarah told me how good it felt and set about exploring my penis, causing it to quickly swell up again to full size. Sarah went on about how beautiful it was, and how full she had felt. With that kind of encouragement it was just a few minutes before we were at it again. As I thrust into her, Sarah's hips rose to meet me. This time we built a rythym, her pussy squeezing tightly around my erection, until I felt her spasm beneath me, which caused me to quickly shoot my load up inside of her.
That night was the first time that Sarah told me that she planned on being with me for the rest of our lives.