Sue paused for a minute, biting her lip, then looked into my eyes for a few seconds before speaking. "I told him about myself Adam, about the stuff I'd done and my sexual history. I knew I shouldn't, I knew better, but he kept asking..."
I groaned. "Oh Sue, you didn't! That kind of stuff is best left in the past, don't you think?" Sure, here I was, giving her advice like that when I had Kristi doing exactly the same thing for me, at my urging, although it sounded like Kristi's love life may have been pretty tame compared to Sue's.
"I wasn't going to Adam, I never intended to, but he kept bugging me and pestering, practically begging me to tell him about my past sexual partners and experiences. Why do guys do that, anyhow? It seems kind of masochistic to me!"
"I don't know Sue, I guess it's maybe kind of a turn-on, or just a need to compete...hell, I don't know, I'm not into all that psychobabble. Just chalk it up to stupidity. So he didn't take it so well?"
"Ha. No, he took it great, at first. It really turned him on, and we would have this amazing sex afterwards. He really seemed to enjoy hearing about stuff I'd done, which I always thought was strange. But I started out with the pretty tame things, real vanilla, you know?"
"Um, maybe. What do you consider vanilla?"
"Oh, you know, one guy, pussy eating, blow jobs, straight sex, maybe a little anal; real Puritan stuff. He always asked for details like was a guys cock big, or did he cum in me, or in my mouth, or did the guy make me cum."
Sue's definition of Puritan was maybe a little different than Webster's, but I got the gist of it. "And so this eventually started to mess with Rick's head, huh?"
"No, not really, not then. But he kept wanting to know more and more, and he seemed to enjoy it, so I started to tell him about the more, uh, you know, crazy stuff I would sometimes do."
"Like for example?"
"God Adam, I can't believe I'm telling you all this, it's really pretty embarassing to remember how I was. I'm kind of ashamed of it, but I was young and stupid, and incredibly horny."
"We all go through that Sue, but some of us are too shy or introverted to act on it. Whatever else you think, at least you had the guts to do stuff impulsively. A lot of people wish they could be more like that."
She smiled at me, brightening considerably. "Thanks Adam, you always seem to say the right thing. You're pretty easy to talk to. Well, anyway, I told him about the wild shit like threesomes and stuff, fucking one guy while I was blowing another. I did three guys once, spent the night with them. I bet I got fucked 8 or 9 times, I had so much cum on and in me. It was great! And I told Rick that."
"Sue, how come you're not dead from some STD or something?"
She looked taken aback. "Well, that was awfully blunt. And right after I said you always know the right thing to say!"
"Sue, there's no good way to ask that question, is there?"
She shrugged her shoulders, making her breasts move invitingly. "True. Luck Adam, just plain, blind, stupid luck, because I was not being very careful. I never had anything though, ever. Not once, and I know because I got tested for absolutely everything before I got pregnant with Britt." Brittney is her oldest daughter.
"Well, that was smart. You must have had a guardian sex angel or something, huh?"
She laughed. "Guardian sex angels would probably be a good idea, but we'd work them to death. Anyhow, Rick started to get really obsessed with this, with my sex life, and he started to talk about watching me make love to another man. I didn't take him seriously, at first."
"When did you realize he was serious?"
She thought about that for a minute, and I watched a red pickup go by, very similar to the one driven by the guy I'd caught fucking Kristi. I don't think it was him, but maybe. I could faintly hear Sue's two girls laughing and playing in her yard.
She sighed. "After I told him about the basketball player from my school's team, and how much I'd enjoyed his enormous cock. His enormous black cock, Adam." She watched my face to see how I'd react.
I tried not to show my surprise. Sue was turning out to be an absolute enigma, not at all the prim, chaste little housewife I'd always assumed her to be. She really had been a wildcat, apparently, and had given all that up to marry Rick and settle down. I wondered if she was bored.
I cleared my throat so that my voice wouldn't come out as strangled as it felt. "So, he didn't react well to that, huh. Go figure. Is he a little bit racist or something? And how did you wind up doing a black athlete anyhow?"
She answered my second question first. "Well we just kind of got introduced at a party, and he started hitting on me, and I was always curious if the rumors were true, you know, about black men."
"And?"
"They're not true."
I laughed at her. "That's not what I meant Sue, I meant 'And, what happened next?' but now that you're on the subject, I thought you said he was huge, so the rumor is true, right?"
"Oh, it was definitely true for Winston, but I wound up fucking a lot of black guys after that, and they're not all big. Some are, but so are some white guys, right Adam?" She smiled at me. "But those black cocks, and my pale skin, there's just something magic about that, for me anyhow.
"Wait a minute. Winston? Like in Churchill? I don't think I've ever heard of a black guy named Winston." I laughed at the incongruity of this sweet little strawberry blond getting pounded by an enormous cock on a black guy named Winston, it just struck me as funny. And maybe I laughed to cover the embarassing fact that I had a rock hard erection from the idea of Sue fucking the basketball team.
"What's so funny? I didn't name him, Adam, I just fucked him. Do you want to try to focus here, or are you just going to laugh at me?"
I stopped, and apologized. "Sorry, it just seemed so odd, the whole thing. I'm having trouble putting you in this scenario, Sue."
"Well, it's true. And no, Rick didn't go all weird because he's racist, he went weird because he loved the story, and couldn't get enough of me telling him about me and Winston. I told him how beautiful Winston's cock is, so huge and thick and black, with his big thick foreskin for me to play with and everything."
She seemed to shiver a little bit. "It makes me horny just thinking about him. He's even bigger than you Adam, really huge, and I loved the way it felt inside of me. He could fuck me for an hour, I just couldn't get enough. I used to cum so hard!"
"Gosh, I can't imagine why this all messed with Rick's head", I said, a little sarcastically.
"I know, I know, but the more I told him the hornier he got, and then he started asking me to compare his cock to Winston's, and, well, there's just no comparison! But the more I compared and criticized him, and made fun of his penis, the more he liked it, so I kept on, telling him stuff like how tiny his cock is, and how I really wanted a huge cock way inside me again, and how he could never make me cum the way a really big cock did..." her voice trailed off.
"Jesus Sue! What were you thinking?"
"I know Adam, but most of what I said to him wasn't true, I was making it up because he seemed to like it. His cock isn't tiny, it's average, and I've certainly had enough to know. And anyhow, he makes me happy. Well, most of the time." She smiled.
"Do you miss the variety of cocks, the wild life?" This question was for me, for my own benefit in trying to understand Kristi.
"Honestly? Sometimes. There's just no substitute for that rush, that excitement of the first time with somebody new, or even the first few times. The first time I open a man's zipper Adam, well, it's like Christmas morning for me, waiting to see what wonderful surprise I'm going to find inside." She looked down at my crotch as she spoke. "Are you hard Adam?"
"Extremely, Sue. What do you expect, talking about this kind of stuff?"
She shook her head. "Damn, here I am, pouring out my heart to you, and to you it's all just audio porn. God, Adam!"
"C'mon Sue, I can't help it. The reason cocks have a head is because they have a mind of their own, I can never control this thing. No guy can."
"Hmmph. Well, that's certainly true, you guys are pretty helpless if your dick is involved. Anyhow, Rick became absolutely convinced that his 'tiny, pathetic penis', as he calls it, could never satisfy me, and that I deserved a real man, with a big cock, and that he was less than a man, all that crap."
I shook my head. "Oh. So he's pretty fucked up, huh?"
"Yeah, I guess. He started a while ago to really obsess about me fucking another guy, or other guys, so that I could be satisfied, and the more he thought about it, the more detailed his fantasy got."
She and I just looked at each other for several seconds. I think I was really starting to understand how this all came about, not that it didn't still seem very unusual.
"He started taking me out to bars and stuff, encouraging me to dress kind of slutty, practically begging me to pick up guys to fuck, but I just couldn't do it!"
"You didn't want to fuck other guys, huh?"
"No, that's not really it. I'd dance with guys, sometimes, and feel their hard cocks pressing against me, and it made me so horny! But we kept it at that level, just a fantasy, and I'd tell him about the guys rubbing their big, hard cocks against me on the dance floor. He liked that."
"So why change that now?"
"Because his fantasy keeps expanding Adam, he wants more, the real thing, and he wants to be subjugated and humiliated, and he wants to see me fucked by what he calls 'a real man's cock', that's why. And because while he was fantasizing about all these strangers fucking his wife, I started fantasizing about you, Adam."
"Jeez Sue, I'm flattered, but why..."
"Because you're here Adam, and I feel like I know you, and you're safe, you won't hurt us, and you're manly and hung like a fucking horse Adam. Do you need more reasons?"
"Uhh, no, I guess not."
"I have a husband, and a home, and my kids - I have things to lose now Adam, and I'm afraid of strangers. But Rick wants this so bad, and he's talked about it so much that now I really, really want to feel a big man-size cock in me again. I'm really looking forward to tomorrow night Adam, I'm so totally aroused all the time waiting for it, I haven't felt this way in years."