The drive home was quiet. Jill ran her fingers over my arm as I drove, gazing out the window as the sun set. I could tell she wanted to talk but couldn't find the words. It wasn't an uncomfortable silence, just a peaceful drive together.
"What do you think about meeting up with Eric and Tina tomorrow?" I broke the silence.
"That could be fun, but only if you want to." It was more of a question from Jill than a statement.
Let the fishing begin...
"I mean, today was fun. But if you don't want to go I understand" said Jill.
"Did you not have fun today?" I said. It was my turn to fish some truth out of her.
"Actually, I did. I just wanted to make sure that you had fun too." She replied in another answer/question tone.
We were both looking at each other intently, waiting for the other to blurt out the truth. Neither of us was mad. More like anxious to share our day's adventure with each other but afraid of the result.
"What if they didn't do anything?" I thought to myself. "What if Tina and I were the only ones breaking the rules?"
It felt like Jill was having the same conversation inside her own head also as she studied my face for clues.
I couldn't play this game anymore. I had to know! I was scared and excited to tell and hear the truth, but it was time. If we were going to survive this we had to talk now.
"Sooooo, umm, in the swimming hole back there. I sort of had a reaction to Tina holding on to me in the water." I stumbled awkwardly.
Her eyes zeroed in on mine, staring intently for my next sentence. I froze, unable to continue.
"What kind of reaction?" Jill said, almost with a grin in her voice.
"Well, since she couldn't reach the bottom, she had to hold onto me with her legs while clinging to the tube. Her rubbing against me caused my dick to get hard." I explained hesitantly.
"And?" she said, studying me closely.
I froze again. I wanted to blurt it out but not yet. I had to know more.
"And, well. What about you?" I asked, shifting the ball back into her court.
"It looked like you were in front of Rob also, how did that go?"
I could see the wheels spinning. We knew each other way too well. I know she wanted to tell me everything but was also slow playing this fishing game to see if we were on level ground.
"Well, let's just say I couldn't touch either. And I guess you're not the only one who gets aroused having your best friends wife pressed against you." She said while staring intently at me waiting for the next volley.
"So what did you do?" I asked
"At first nothing, he just pressed his erection tight against my ass. It felt good but also wrong so I was afraid to move. Then I saw Tina swimming towards us so I broke away and came back to you." Her voice sounded nervous, not a scared nervous, more like a slightly aroused nervous.
I could feel the blood rushing to my cock. Replaying the whole scene in my mind was making me crazy.
"It's ok." Jill spoke. "We're all friends and both of them have always enjoyed flirting with us. I guess it's no surprise that could happen in a setting like the river."
I could tell she had more to say but was now waiting for my response. We just stared into each other's eyes. I could barely keep the car on the road.
I had to know more!
"So, when we got to the last swimming spot did he get hard again?" I asked.
"Yes." She looked away as she spoke. "But this time when he pulled me in front of him he had untied his trunks. I could feel his bare cock pushing against my suit." Jill looked back at me slowly, watching closely for my response.
"What did you do?" I asked. My mouth was dry, heart beating while my cock throbbed between my legs.
"At first I just held still. Then I looked over at you and Tina and it looked like she was grinding against your cock. I started to get jealous but that was immediately replaced by lust. The thought of my best friend rubbing her ass against your cock should have made me mad. But it didn't? It was exciting? I didn't feel threatened by her and I know you love me so instead of being insanely jealous, I got really turned on."
I could feel her eyes on me while she continued.