Chapter Five: Prom Night
By: sophie_writes
It was a picture-perfect SoCal Saturday—the time of year when most seniors were looking forward to prom or shopping for a new swimsuit for the summer. Like most of my peers, I'd already taken care of the prom dress situation. The swimsuit would have to wait because right now I was doing a very different kind of shopping with Jocelyn.
"These are cute?" I was holding up a box containing three princess plugs of different colors.
"Cute—but you definitely don't want those!"
"No? Why?"
"Those aren't safe. They really shouldn't even be selling them," Jocelyn explained. "See how the top is only as wide as the middle? You don't want one of those getting lost up in there. And those could."
"Oh!" I had not thought about that at all. "How embarrassing would that be?"
"Very. Also, rubber or glass is better. Look." She picked up a set of rubber ones with t-shaped ends that had the added bonus of being far less expensive. "Also these have a nice taper, and you'll be wearing them for a while at a time if you want to get ready. These'll stay in even if you're being pretty active, but they're easy to take out too."
So good to have expert advice. I had started out the second part of that year as a pretty normal senior and now I was in an adult store with Jocelyn shopping for anal plugs. Life comes at you fast sometimes.
We settled on the rubber ones she'd shown me, and I rummaged around in my purse trying to find the cash I'd withdrawn for this purchase. No way was I risking how this might pop up on my online bank statement. I wasn't trying to have that conversation with my parents anytime between now and basically the end of the world. I found the cash and did my best to complete the transaction without making eye contact with the guy at the register. Jocelyn, as per usual, found my discomfort amusing and gave me shit about it all the way back to her car.
I didn't mind though. The truth was she was being a total lifesaver right now. I would have never been able to work up the courage to make this purchase by myself, for instance. I probably would have been in my room trying to shove vaguely phallic-shaped objects up my ass like an idiot instead if not for her. As crazy as it sounds, I needed someone to mentor me through all this, and she was doing a fantastic job. And she was kind of a pro after all.
"Ok, so I guess I don't need to tell you to start with the small one?" Jocelyn said, laughing.
"No bitch. I figured that part out, thank you."
"Don't be a twat," she told me with her trademark smirk. "So be gentle with yourself. Lots of lube obviously, and just wear it as long as you can when you're not doing anything super athletic."
"I can't believe I am seriously considering wearing one of these to school."
"It's the best way. You can always go take it out."
"I guess I can," I said with a little sigh. What even was my life at this point?
~~~~~~~~~~
If you're wondering about prom, yes I was going, and no Lincoln wasn't taking me. I'm sure he had no interest in that and I wasn't about to ask him. Abbey had this guy from UCLA she'd been hooking up with taking her, and I had agreed to go with a guy in our class that we'd both been friends with forever. He was really sweet but there had never been anything romantic between us, and I think he understood it was going to stay that way. And he really wanted to take me, so I agreed. So we did all the usual dinner, prom stuff, etc. I still have the pictures. Abbey and I are there with our dates, and we both look pretty great I feel like I can say, but all I can ever think about when I see those is that I was standing there with a plug in my ass the whole evening.
Because we were cool seniors, we didn't stay at the actual prom very long. The four of us went to an after-party with some other people from our friend group. I, of course, had been told I had other plans for the rest of that night. I grabbed a drink and talked to some people for a while, and after about half an hour, I texted Lincoln so he could come to get me. That took another thirty minutes or so, and I had a nice little buzz happening by the time he arrived. I grabbed my bag with my change of clothes and stuff in it, thanked my date and told him good night. Abbey came outside with me to say hi to Lincoln. And by hi I mean to flirt with him. They for sure still had their little unspoken thing going, and she was sarcastically telling him not to be too late getting me home.
"There's plenty of room for you too, girl," Lincoln told her. She rolled her eyes at him.
"Oh my god would you two just get a room," I said, hopping in Lincoln's SUV.
"Like I said, we got plenty of room, just ditch that white boy" he told Abbey with a cocky grin.
"Wish I could baby," she flirted back. Lincoln and I were both shaking our heads as we drove away.
"Seriously I'm going to tell her to stop being a cock tease," I said laughing.
"She's fun. I can let it slide," Lincoln replied.
"She just needs to get it out of her system. You should do her solid," I suggested, only about half kidding. Those two really did need to get a room. Lincoln just laughed.
When we got to their place, James was on the couch watching something that looked like a Tom and Jerry cartoon of all things. Lincoln joined him, and I put my bag down, unzipped it to grab what I needed, and headed to the downstairs bath to change. I could hear them saying something about Delvin coming over and I hoped he'd bring Jocelyn with him. I wasn't completely sure what tonight would bring, but I liked the idea of her being around for whatever it was.
As soon as I stepped out of the bathroom, now in shorts and a t-shirt, I realized I'd made a bad mistake. I still had the plug in me. It had been in so long I'd kind of forgotten about it. What the fuck was I supposed to do now? I should have turned around and walked back in of course, but I kind of froze for a second. They both looked up and kind of stared at me for a second.
"Well get over here," Lincoln told me.
Too late now you dumb bitch. Appropriate there's a fucking cartoon to watch because that's about where you are right now. I walked over.
"Yeah—you can tell us about prom night," James added. They were seated far enough apart that there was room for me between them, and it was clear that's where I was expected to go. Lincoln eased his hand up my thigh as soon as I sat down and started kind of teasing at the edge of my panties (I had changed into loose running shorts).
"Did that white boy buy you a nice dinner?" James asked kind of nastily. I could sort of see where this was going but I was going to have to play along. I said yes, and started to tell them about it, but they both started laughing.
"I don't want to hear all that," Lincoln said. "Cool he paid for your dinner though. Nice how you ditched him to come over here and..." I didn't get to hear what I'd come over here to do because he and James both erupted in excitement at a particularly sly series of antics Jerry was executing on TV. This went on for some time, and I have to say it was justified—Tom was getting wrecked. When that finally died down I was told get a fresh round of beers. I took their empties and came back with one for each of us. We watched the rest of the cartoon, Lincoln playing absently with pussy while they both continued to yell instructions at Tom, who was not taking them, as evidenced by Jerry's continued elusiveness.
I went to get them more beers again when a commercial came on (my buzz was back by then) and when I returned and handed them over, James kind of stopped me from sitting down.
"I like a naked white bitch in my house," he stated, kind of looking me up and down. I just stared at him like an idiot.
"You deaf? He's talking to you," Lincoln snapped. "Strip." That snapped me out of my stupor. Oh shit, I thought, this is going to be bad. I pulled my shirt over my head and off.
"Hurry up—don't be blockin' the tv once the commercial ends. Tryn' watch cartoons." I heard James laugh as Lincoln said that. I slid my shorts and panties off together, tossed it all on my bag, and went to sit back down. I thought to myself, you absolute stupid slut you deserve what's coming.
"Oh shit!" Lincoln exclaimed. "Look at this bitch!"
"Oh shit!" James echoed. I honestly don't even remember what all they actually said after that. Hilarity ensued. I know I ended up over Lincoln's knee like an unruly child after a few seconds of that, an even more humiliating situation than what I'd been dreading. He spanked me hard a few times, still talking shit about the plug with James.
"Why'd you put that up your ass girl?" Lincoln asked, clear amusement in his voice. I just kind of hung there, splayed over Lincoln's knee, mortified and silent. James had put his hand under my chin, forcing me to look up at him. "Answer him girl," James snapped, as Lincoln smacked my ass really hard again. So humiliating.
"I thought that...I thought that I needed it," I stammered.
"You thought you needed it?" Lincoln was laughing again. "Why?"