Garys Fantasy Goes Awry

Kathy was in a blissful state. The sexy redhead lay exhausted in bed with her legs splayed open and her battered, gaping cum-filled pussy fully exposed. She just had her most incredible sexual experience, and her body was still tingling.

Her husband Gary was sitting in a chair near the bed and staring at her with a look of envy and disbelief. Another man had given his wife the fucking of her lifetime, satisfying her in a way he never could imagine. It wasn't supposed to be this way. It was meant to be an experience the two of them shared and enjoyed together.

Gary suffered the humiliation of not only seeing his wife so thoroughly pleased by another man, this other man had taunted and physically punished him. And Gary didn't, actually couldn't do anything about it. Moreover, finding himself in this predicament was his own doing. He had held this fantasy of seeing his wife with another man.

Kathy was 5-foot-8 and had a body women envied and men lusted after. She had 38D breasts, a 25-inch waist and a shapely, hard ass. Why any man would want to share her with another was beyond belief. But it was something Gary wanted, and you know what they say, be careful what you wish for.

Here's how it all started:

After a strenuous workout at the gym, Gary hopped in the shower and was bathing himself when he saw a man he'd never seen at the gym before step into the shower. What struck Gary was the sheer size of this black man. Gary was not a small man, as he was 6-1 and weighed 190 pounds. But the dark-skinned man dwarfed him as he stood 6-foot-7, and was very fit. He looked as if he could be a small forward on a pro basketball team. When Gary took a look at the man's crotch area, he saw a dangling, thick monster of a penis. It had to be at least eight inches long, and it was in a flaccid state.

Gary couldn't stop stealing glances at the man's penis, and embarrassingly, he found his own dick getting hard. Gary tried to hide his 5-inch erection from the man, but was unsuccessful in doing so. The man saw Gary's aroused state and started chuckling before stepping out of the shower.

Gary eventually finished his shower and was putting on his clothes. The other man was getting dressed three lockers down. He looked over at Gary and asked him, "You get that thing to go down yet?"

"What?" Gary asked.

The man laughed and said, "Man, I saw you checking my stuff out. You probably ain't never seen anything like it and you got excited. You ain't the first man who's had that reaction, and you won't be the last. Just admit it."

Gary, stumbling for a response, said, "I'm not gay, if that's what you're thinking."

The man responded, "Never said you were. You just saw my dick and a lot of thoughts and fantasies immediately went through your head, right?"

Gary dipped his head and didn't say a word.

The man extended his hand to Gary and introduced himself as Dave. After the handshake, Dave laughed triumphantly and left the locker room. Gary was humbled, knowing Dave had seen right through him so quickly and easily.

The gym incident was stuck in Gary's mind on his drive home and throughout dinner with Kathy that evening. What struck Gary was how Dave didn't come off as arrogant or, no pun intended, cocky when he laid out the facts to him. Dave's matter-of-fact tone had Gary wondering just how many times Dave had this conversation with other men.

That night, while making love with Kathy, thoughts of Dave fucking his wife began flashing into Gary's head. He became more vigorous and forceful with Kathy. Not that she was complaining, but Kathy noticed how Gary was more aroused than usual and asked what had gotten into him. Gary played dumb and said he just felt more energetic tonight.

Two days later, Gary again saw Dave in the gym, and they both showered at the same time. Again, Gary got aroused. This time, Dave didn't say a word about it and went about his business. Later that night, Gary was thinking about Dave's cock while having sex with Kathy.

Kathy again told Gary how much more amorous he had been. She said she liked how more aggressive he's been in bed lately, and wondered what was on his mind. She asked if he was thinking of another woman.

"Oh no, no, not another woman," he said, quickly shooting down that notion.

"OK, so what's got you so excited lately?" she asked. "Be honest."

Gary stumbled and searched for the right words. He felt whatever came out of his mouth might strip him of his masculinity in his wife's mind.

"Well, um, when I was taking a shower at the gym, this black dude walked in and let me tell you, he was big all over," Gary said softly.

"Big all over, huh," Kathy quipped. "You mean, he has a big..."

"That's exactly what I'm saying," Gary interrupted. "This guy is a lot bigger soft than I am when I'm hard. He caught me looking at it, and he saw my dick get hard. And then when we were dressing he talked to me about it, telling me how he knew erotic thoughts and fantasies were in my head when I looked at it. That was fucking embarrassing. But he was right."

Kathy laughed softly, which drew a nasty look from Gary.

"Since we're being very truthful, exactly what were you thinking about when we were fucking?" Kathy asked.

"I was pretending to be him when I fucked you," he shot back. "I got images in my head of him giving it to you like you'd never had it before."

"Oh...wow...um...I had no idea," Kathy stammered. "That's quite a fantasy I must say. Is that the first time you've ever thought of me with another man?"

"It is," he replied. "I've thought about you doing it with another woman lots of times, but never with another guy, let alone a black man."

"I wonder if you'd have the same feelings if the man with the big penis was white," Kathy pondered. "Is it simply the stereotype of the black man with a big cock that gets to you?"

Then, with a slight chuckle, she quipped, "Maybe you just have big penis envy."

"Whatever," Gary said before rolling over to go to sleep.

When he woke up the next morning, Gary wondered if his admission had changed the way his wife sees him. Did she respect him a little less, he worried.

"Morning babe," Kathy said before giving him a kiss. "It was an interesting night, I'd say. How ya feeling?"

"I'm good...I guess I got a lot off my chest," Gary said. "You OK?"

She nodded her head and shot him a smile. As they were leaving for work, Kathy got in a little dig at Gary, "Don't forget to hit the gym today." Gary rolled his eyes and headed out.

As the weeks went by Dave and Gary became friendlier toward each other. They'd spot each other when lifting free weights. Dave would give Gary tips about how strenuous he should be on particular machines. They got to the point to where they'd go out for the occasional beer after working out.

Gary learned that Dave, who was 31, made his living as a newspaper reporter and that he'd read several of his stories in the local press. Gary, 37, was an engineer for the city government. Dave was single but didn't lack for female company. He had action all over town but was very discreet. When the two would be out for a beer, Gary noticed how woman of all races gravitated toward Dave.

"Damn dude, women always seem to be all over you...you're probably getting too much pussy," Gary joked. "You're one lucky hombre."

"I guess, but I wouldn't mind being with someone on a steady basis," Dave said. "I'm not getting any younger, you know."

"Judging by what I see, you could have your pick," Gary said.

A few weeks later, Gary finally felt comfortable enough to admit to Dave he was right about how thoughts of his cock and certain fantasies flashed into his mind. He said when he's with his wife, he pretends to be Dave and the sex gets better for him.

"That's not unusual...sometimes guys just need a little extra motivation," Dave told Gary. "Some guys do something about fantasies, and some guys just let it stay a fantasy."

"What do you mean when you say do something about it?" Gary asked.

Dave explained how some guys get off on seeing their wives or girlfriends with another man, usually one who's well-endowed and try to convince their wives to go along with it, to fulfill that fantasy.

"And you've been the fantasy man, right," Gary said.

Dave informed him that he has, but he warned that afterward things are never really the same for the man and his wife or girlfriend.

"It's a slippery slope," Dave said. "So if that's something you're considering, think long and hard about it."

Gary and Kathy were in bed one night when he broached the subject. He asked her if she ever fantasized about other men. She said of course she has, but it was famous people like Brad Pitt, Cole Hauser, Tim McGraw and Idris Alba.

Idris Alba was the name that caught his attention.

"Idris Alba? He's black," Gary said.

"True, but he's sexy as fuck...I'll bet every woman has had an Idris Alba fantasy at some point," Kathy said.

"So, you'd be willing to fuck a black guy, huh?" Gary asked.

"That black man, yes, others, probably not," she shot back. "So, where are you going with this?"

He said he's got nothing in mind...he was just curious about what or who she thinks about when she's fantasizing. The wheels were now spinning in his head. He had planted the seed in her mind, now he had to go about convincing her to live out his dream.

Gary invited Dave over one afternoon to watch football. He figured they'd put some burgers on the grill, drink a few beers and enjoy the action. What he really wanted was for Kathy to get her first look at Dave to see if there was an attraction. Kathy had invited her friend Charlotte over that afternoon to do a little gossiping and to enjoy some wine.

Charlotte arrived first. She was a 5-foot-4 blonde whose body was not as voluptuous as Kathy's but she turned a lot of heads when she walked down the street. Today she was rocking a pair of tight yoga pants, a loose-fitting UC Davis t-shirt and a plain white baseball cap. Kathy wore a pair of jeans and a polo shirt, and her long red hair was flowing midway down her back. She and Kathy went to the back patio. Dave came about a half-hour later. Gary called for Kathy to come meet his friend. She and Charlotte came into the living room, and Charlotte squealed, "Oh my god, Dave."

"Charlotte, fancy meeting you here," Dave said, towering over the group. "So you know these two?"

"They've been friends of mine for years," Charlotte said. "I didn't know you knew Gary and Kathy."

"Well, I've only met Gary...I haven't had the pleasure of meeting Kathy yet. Hi, I'm Dave," he said, extending his hand.

"I'm Kathy," she took his hand, amazed at how his large hand engulfed hers, and shook it. "It's very nice to meet you."

Charlotte asked Dave how he met Gary, and he told her they met at the gym and work out together. That's when Kathy put it together that Dave was the man from the gym. A sly smile crossed her face and then she looked Dave's body up and down. She gave an extended look to his crotch area when Dave had his head turned. But his baggy sweat pants hid his cock.

Charlotte and Kathy returned to the back patio, while Dave and Gary planted themselves on the couch in front of the TV.

Kathy asked Charlotte how she knew Dave, and Charlotte told her she works at the same newspaper. Charlotte is head of the advertising department and often feeds Dave story ideas. Charlotte figures that if she can get stories about her clients in the paper, she can increase her advertising dollars.

"So what do you know about him?" Kathy asked Charlotte.

"I know he's single, and a couple women in the office have hooked up with him," Charlotte said.

Kathy asked if Charlotte ever did anything with Dave, to which she said no.

"He's a good-looking man, how is he not taken by now?" Kathy said.

"Why are you so curious about Dave?" Charlotte asked. "You're a happily married woman."

Kathy said Gary would talk about a guy he met at the gym and that he was very well hung. She swore Charlotte to secrecy when she said, "Gary often pretends to be Dave when he's fucking me and it really gets him off. I think he wants Dave to fuck me while he watches."

Charlotte giggled and said, "Are you serious? That's...that's kind of perverted. It's kinky but perverted. I will say that one girl who fucked him said he by far was the biggest man she'd ever been with and that he knows how to use what he's got. She said she came about seven or eight times on his cock."

"Oh my," Kathy responded.

"Are you considering it?" Charlotte inquired.

"No, but it's something Gary thinks about a lot," Kathy said.

While they were watching the game, Gary asked Dave if he had ever done it with Charlotte. Dave said no, but it wasn't from a lack of trying. Charlotte isn't one to mix business with pleasure and that she would only date guys outside the office.

After their guests have left, Gary asked Kathy what she thought of Dave. She told him he seemed nice and that he was very good looking and thought his body was awesome.

"He and Charlotte would look good together, wouldn't they?" he said.

"Maybe, but she said that's not going to happen," Kathy said.

"Too bad, I know he'd give her a really good fuck," Gary said. "That would be something to see."

"Is that really something you'd want to see?" Kathy said with an annoyed tone in her voice.

"It's just an observation," Gary replied.

That night when they were in bed, Gary was exceptionally horny but Kathy was uninterested in having sex. He tried to coax her into it but to no avail. She told him he'd have to take care of himself tonight. So he grabbed his laptop and went to a porn site.

He clicked on to the interracial category. Upon scrolling through various movies, he decided on one that featured Anton Harden and Brandi Love. He had his headphones on so Kathy couldn't hear and began stroking himself while watching the scene.

Kathy, because of Gary's actions, was unable to sleep and peered at his computer. When she saw the size of Anton Harden's cock, she gasped. She saw how Brandi Love was having the time of her life and she started to get excited. She tapped Gary, who then removed his headphones, and asked him if Dave was as big as the man in the movie.

"I've never seen Dave hard, but I think he is bigger than this guy," Gary said.

"Wow, that's massive," Kathy said. "Something that big would hurt. There's no way I could handle that but it's nice to look at."

Gary smiled and thought to himself that he was slowly making progress with his plan. He needed to take it to the next phase, which was getting her to know Dave better and make her more comfortable around him.

Gary invited Kathy out for a Saturday afternoon of beer drinking, but little did she know he had invited Dave as well. They arrived at a local pub and saw Dave sitting alone in a booth.

"Oh, Kathy, I forgot to tell you that I told Dave we'd be here and that he was more than welcome to join us," Gary said.

Kathy was suspicious that Gary was up to something but played along anyway. She planted herself across from Dave and Gary sat next to her. Dave complimented Kathy on her looks. She was wearing a light green pullover dress that showed off every curve of her outstanding body and had her long red hair tied up in a bun. Dave was sporting a tight pair of jeans, a long sleeve t-shirt and black sneakers.

They made nervous small talk at first, but eventually loosened up after a few beers. Kathy was impressed by Dave's deadpan sense of humor. She also complimented him on his looks and asked if he played sports in college, to which he said he played basketball but never made it to the pros.

She started in on Dave's personal life, asking why there was no woman in his life. He told her there were women in his life but nobody serious. He said he'd like to meet someone to be with for the long haul but for now, he's just going to play the field.

"And besides, why buy a book when there's a library?" he joked. Kathy nearly spit out her beer laughing upon hearing that. Gary also burst out in laughter before saying, "I happened to purchase my favorite, limited edition book right here," while putting his arm around his wife.

Gary then got up to fetch another round of beers, leaving Kathy and Dave alone in the booth.

"I need to ask you something and please be honest," Kathy said turning serious. "Do you think Gary has something in mind with me and you?"

"Huh?" Dave replied.

"I know he has this fantasy about seeing me with another man, and I think it's you," Kathy said.

"What makes you think that?" Dave said.

"First off, he told me about seeing you in the shower and how excited he got. He's been more assertive in bed," she said. "He drops hints about me fucking other men, especially black men. And he's been watching quite a bit of interracial porn."

"Well, we have touched on the subject," Dave said. "I know he has fantasies, but I told him to seriously think about it because there will be repercussions. I've done this before and afterward things change and not always for the better."

"You've fucked a man's wife while he watched?" Kathy asked.

"I have, and like I said, it's not for everybody," Dave said.

"Thanks for being truthful," Kathy said with a nervous look on her face.

Right then, Gary returned with beers. This time, Dave got up to hit the bathroom. As he stood, Kathy saw the outline of Dave's cock through his pants and sort of shook her head in disbelief.

"From what I see, you were right about him," Kathy said when Dave got out of earshot.

"What?" Gary said.

"I just took a look at his package, and it looks impressive...that's all," Kathy said.

"Yeah, just imagine that thing going inside of you," Gary said.

That night, Gary and Kathy engaged in a rousing round of sex. They both had their mind on one thing: Dave's massive cock. Kathy asked Gary if he was pretending to be Dave again, and he was. She admitted she fantasized about the feeling of being filled to the max with a cock.

At that point, Gary was determined to make it happen. For the next two weeks, whenever Gary and Kathy were having sex, he would whisper something about Dave's cock in her ear. Things like, "Dave's big cock would get so much deeper in you than mine. I bet he could make you scream and cum harder than you ever have."

Kathy was surprised this kind of talk was actually turning her on.

One night Gary was eating Kathy out and again started talking about Dave. "Um, this pussy tasted so sweet. Don't you wish I was just getting you nice and wet for Dave's huge schlong?"

Kathy responded by grabbing the back of Gary's head and wildly grinding her pussy into his face.

"So, how about it...you want to do it...would you like to fuck Dave?" Gary asked.

"Yes....yes...YES," she said through her heavy breaths.

They agreed on doing it the following Saturday night. They would invite Dave over for dinner and see where the night takes them. Kathy was getting more and more nervous as Saturday night approached. How would she go about seducing him? Would Dave be willing to do it? Could she handle his size? All those thoughts flooded her head.

She figured if it's meant to happen it will happen.

Saturday rolled around, and both Gary and Kathy were anxious. They knew this was going to be a big night in their lives. This would be something they'd remember forever. She wore a revealing short dress that highlighted her toned legs and big tits.

Dave arrived. He had an inkling about what was going to happen and came prepared. He wore a tight pair of white pants with no underwear, leaving nothing to the imagination as to what he was packing. He also had a blue t-shirt.

When Kathy answered the door, her eyes gave Dave the once over. She locked in on his cock and she let out a light sigh. He stepped inside and sat on the couch. Gary offered him a beer and sat in the recliner. Kathy went to the kitchen to put the finishing touches on dinner.