[Part 2 of a 5-part story.]
I felt a hand squeezing my cock and a tongue teasing my ear. "Wake up, Ben," she whispered. It was Kris. I opened my eyes and I could see it was getting lighter, like a new dawn beginning. "Let's get in the shower before the others wake up."
I turned my head to kiss her. The first kiss was quick. The second one was nice. Her lips were soft and sweet and warm. When she pulled away I immediately craved them again. But she let go of my cock to sit up, then she pulled on my arm to get me to stand with her. I did. She held her finger up to her lips so I'd keep quiet and then led me, as we stepped gingerly around the other girls, away from the camp and toward the waterfall. Her face was full of fun at our little secret adventure.
She led me out into the pool. The water was cool, not cold, not warm, but pleasant and slightly cool. She stepped under the waterfall with delight as she felt it cascading all around her, instantly drenching her strawberry blonde curls flat against her head and down around her breasts. She smiled and pulled me in with her. She turned my head so it partially blocked the flow, and then she leaned in and up to kiss me, making a private space for just our lips as the water fell all around us.
She was throwing everything into that kiss, and I was only too happy to respond. She was beautiful, she was sweet, and she really wanted me. How could I not want her? It was perfect. She was perfect. I held her body tightly against me and felt my cock grow harder. My cock and our mouths were the only hot spots amidst all the cool water.
Kris wrapped her arms tighter around my neck and started to lift herself up on me. I knew what she wanted. I wanted it too, and slid my hands down over her smooth ass to lift her up higher. I could easily handle her weight. She leaned back, and dropped one hand down to guide me to where we both wanted it. Her eyes got wide as she felt the heat and the sensation of it slowly sinking in. She wrapped her legs around me and I found the best position to support her as we quickly fell into a rhythm and started to fuck.
It wasn't the easiest position but the spontaneity of the moment helped a lot. "Maybe they won't hear us over the water," Kris said. We were starting to get into it and I was thinking about finding someplace to lay her down and do this right, but her wish for privacy kept me going.
"Hey you two." It was Syd. She was standing right behind me. Her voice was friendly, teasing, but the sudden surprise of it led me to let Kris down off me, and my cock slipped out of her. "Don't let me stop you."
I could tell Kris was surprised too, and disappointed, at least in the moment. Our private reverie had been interrupted.
"Oh hi, Syd. Sorry. I didn't mean to hog him to myself. The moment just kind of got the best of me is all."
"Relax. I'm sure we all want a little private time with Ben, and we'll all get it too, won't we Ben?"
"Yes. I'm looking forward to getting to know everyone a little better."
"Good. And we'll all try our best not to get too jealous, won't we Kris?"
"I'll try."
"I know it's not always going to be easy, for you too, Ben. But it won't take too much to turn pussy paradise into a catfight hellhole. And none of us wants that."
"No we don't." I could see she was right, of course, and Kris knew it too.
"Ben, like with the game last night, we'll try to keep everyone involved, and then if you trust me, we can carve out a little one-on-one time for you with each girl, but we've got to keep it fair."
"Sorry, Syd."
"No worries." Then Syd turned and shouted, "Hey girls, look! It's a man in our shower!" There was more light now. The "sun" was out.
I turned and grabbed Kris's hand and gave it a little squeeze. I thought she might need some reassurance. She smiled back at me. It felt like we were okay.
Syd pushed me back into the stream of falling water, kissed me once, and started to run her hands all around my chest. Kris rubbed my shoulders and kissed the back of my neck. Soon the other girls were there too, laughing and giggling as hands felt all over my body, arms and legs, back and abs, chest and shoulders, ass and cock. There were kisses too, all over. I'm sure every girl kissed my lips, and my cock. Everyone was covered with glistening drops of spray from the falling water. It was kind of overwhelming, but it was wonderful too. I resolved to try really hard not to fuck this up, to keep the good feelings going.
"Okay break!" said Syd, sounding like a team captain breaking the timeout huddle before heading back out onto the court. And the girls all responded like that too. Everyone released me, and we stood around in a circle a few steps away from the waterfall. Syd was closest to the side of the pool. She bent over and pulled out a reed that was growing there. Everyone watched her. "We're going to draw straws to see who gets Ben next. Elena, you and I have already had our turns. So this is between Jade, Kari, and Kris."
I looked at Elena, who looked a little deflated, but she did not object. I supported the fairness of this plan, but I was secretly hoping Kris and I would get a chance to finish what we'd started. All standing there naked in the pool, hair matted down, glowing with droplets of water, they all seemed stunningly gorgeous. My cock was hard. I was ready for any one of them.
Syd broke the reed into three pieces, and showed how one was longer than the other two. "Long straw gets the cock," she said, and the others all smiled. Then she turned away to mix them up, and turned back to us with all three in her hand. She held it out. Jade picked first, then Kari, then Kris. Kari held the long straw.
"We're going to give you two some one-on-one time. So go have fun. Don't worry. We'll save your breakfast for you. Take your time."
"Have fun, Kari," said Kris.
"Don't do anything I wouldn't do," added Elena. The others laughed and headed back towards camp.
Kari looked at me with soft eyes. They sparkled like she was eager to show me something. "I know just the place." She reached out to take my hand. "Follow me."
We walked in the opposite direction from the camp. The island was not large, but it did hold a few surprises, little areas where things looked different. Not far from the shore on the other side of the island Kari ducked between two bushes off the path and suddenly we were in a space totally surrounded by foliage, with a soft carpet of moss, and just big enough for two people to lie down. Even most of the space above us was grown over. It was almost like a canopy bed. She turned to face me. "Hello, Ben," she purred.
"Hello, Kari." We kissed. First the small space surrounding us, and then our lips, both took us into intimacy surprisingly quickly. Kari, the quiet one, the mysterious one, was finally free to reveal herself to me. Her body flowed into mine completely naturally, with a dancer's grace. I knew the least about her, but somehow I instantly felt like I knew her the best, or maybe it was that it seemed like she knew me. We sat down on the soft moss.
"I'm really glad we can have time for just us. I know we all have to share, and the group stuff can be fun, but at heart I'm a one-man sort of girl."
"I confess I don't really have any experience with more than one girl at a time, at least not until yesterday, anyway."
"It's really not natural. I mean it's been easier than I thought it would be, and it's not all bad. Don't get me wrong. We're all very different girls, thrown together in this prison. It really is like a prison. And we've tried to make the best of it almost the only way we could, by getting each other off as much as we can. It's been the only thing that gets us through the day. So you're like the biggest thing that's happened to us, ever."
"Yeah I could kind of tell. I mean I figured reality was going to kick in at some point."
