fool-me-once-fool-with-me-more
GROUP SEX STORIES

Fool Me Once Fool With Me More

Fool Me Once Fool With Me More

by laraynsystrom
19 min read
4.47 (9600 views)
adultfiction
🎧

Audio Coming Soon

Audio being prepared

β–Ά
--:--
πŸ”‡ Not Available
Check Back Soon

"Man, I hate Beatrice," Mandy said, a cock in her hand, working it up from the floppy five inches she was used to seeing dangling around. "I gotta find a way to get back at her for inviting my parents over on April Fool's."

"Yeah, that was very funny," Vinny said, as her hand stopped stroking his cock already semi-hard. "Sorry, I meant 'traumatic'." The stroking resumed. She added her mouth to the mix, spitting on the head so she could drive the point home, rubbing it into the length now easily eight inches.

"They saw all the sex toys strewn about our place," she said. "We didn't have time to prepare for them. They even saw your silicone wall pussy in the bathroom."

"Yeah, I could have gone my whole life without the image of my father-in-law sticking fingers inside the silicone pussy I fuck sometimes."

"Exactly!" Mandy said, then dove back down to slip his cock into her mouth and suck. Her tongue circled a little bit around the top, then formed a little point and started massaging the bit of skin under the head, sometimes dancing inside the dickhead where tiny spurts of precum were already eeking out. Her head came up again, rubbing the underside of Vinny's cock with a thumb in a circular motion. "We gotta get back at them this year."

"I'm gonna--!" Vinny said, which prompted her to dive back down and throat the length as he blew his load inside. Her fingers juggled his nutsack as the spurts of cum came out, gathering over his cock inside the back of her mouth. She didn't swallow it, only mixed it with her spit and let the mixture drip down the length like a warm creampie slipping past her teeth and lips, still leaving a taste, but not the bulk of cum. "I love your finish, Mandy. It makes my head feel like it's in your pussy."

"Get that bad boy hard again, and he can visit," she said, smirking. "Unless it's my turn to ride."

"It might be that kind of night, hon," Vinny said, sliding down on the couch to position his mouth into the right spot so that she could lower herself over him, pussy suffocating him for a few seconds before slipping out his nose into the pubes for that life-saving inhale. He could do nothing else now but make his tongue as hard as possible, and turn the TV volume up to cover her sounds of moaning as she started slicking her crotch over his face.

"I have an idea!" Mandy burst out right after showering Vinny with her orgasm not twenty minutes later of grinding his face against the couch cushions. Mandy slipped off his face and kissed his lips which were bound to be a bit sore from the friction. He shook awake, and slipped his tongue into her mouth while grabbing her back into a cuddle on the couch.

"Do share," he said, resting his head on her chest, squishing into a comfortable position.

"We do a fake kidnapping, and have you record me all chained up for ransom, and deliver the video to Beatrice and Tim's place for them to figure out."

"They'll just call the cops and it'll be a whole thing, Mandy," Vinny said. "April Fool's jokes have to be lighthearted."

"My dad stuck his fingers in your shower pussy!" Mandy said again. "And I eat that thing out sometimes, too!"

"Huh?" Vinny asked. "You eat out my pussy?"

"I was just curious the first time," she said. "Then it became a whole thing. Sometimes I finger her just for fun to make sure it's cleaned out for you to enjoy yourself."

"Aww, Mandy," Vinny said. "I would very much like to see you eat her out sometime. That's why I got the one that has the silicone thighs with pussy and ass together."

"You could just eat me out in the shower," she said.

"Or even better, I could eat you out, as you eat the silicone pussy out," he said. "That would be so hot. Oh, damn, now I've got an idea, but you're not gonna like it."

"Do share," she said, mimicking his tone of mischief.

"We record them some home movie, that then slowly turns sexual and by the end is just the two of us fucking on camera. That'll probably embarrass them."

"Us more though!"

"You think?" Vinny asked. "You're hot as fuck, though. I bet they would be a lot more embarrassed then the two of us, and since we're trying for a baby, we can go raw the whole video. It would take some doing, but I think we have enough time before April Fools rolls around."

"I don't know," Mandy said.

"Want me to get the cameras and see how we feel about it when they're set up? If we decide against it, we could always just keep the videos to ourselves and get off to us getting off. Especially if we record some special stuff we don't do every day, like that time with the banana your pussy ate."

"Ugh, don't remind me," Mandy said. "It was such a stupid idea."

"But so hot," Vinny said, smiling, then digging his forehead in her chest as she petted his short black hair. "I'll get the cameras, and then you can see if you can get behind this idea. If not, at least we'll get some fun footage to play around with, maybe even become internet famous on some amateur porn sites."

"Fine, fine," Mandy said, but still worried about showing too much of herself to those two. They weren't too friendly, but seeing as the gated community exposed everyone to each other, there was bound to be some people who disliked each other. Beatrice and Tim Haltz have been living across the street from them for a few years now, and every holiday, no matter how small, their lawn would turn to the theme. They even put pranks around their sidewalk on April Fool's, and watched as the other neighbors fell for new small pranks on that one day of pranking.

πŸ“– Related Group Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

They also did some more serious pranks, such as inviting Mandy's parents over when her house was in a sexual disarray of busy schedules that seldom found time for full on sexual encounters. Vinny also said that he sometimes preferred to go solo with some porn, or in the shower, rather than having to hold himself back for half an hour to what could have been a two minute cum-and-done.

Their visit also prompted the talk on babies, and that Mandy's parents wanted a grandkid. This turned to less condoms, and more raw cum flying about the place, which made Vinny happier, but also worried Mandy that she was being brainwashed by her parents into wanting kids when she was perfectly enjoying just having sex in many fun ways, when time allowed. She shook her head out of the idea to find Vinny already asleep on her tits.

When the cameras came in, Vinny was in full-on techgeek mode, outfitting their guest bedroom with as many cameras as he ordered. Mandy didn't even know how many there were, but he said it would be essential to have different angles and high quality night-vision to capture every little nook and cranny.

"I'm not intending to spread my pussy in front of the camera," she said, which prompted him to eat her out until she changed her mind.

"We can keep those parts for ourselves," Vinny said. "I'll edit down what we make into something you'll be ok with, yeah?"

"That sounds good," Mandy said. "But the guest bedroom though?"

"Imagine?" Vinny asked, grinning. "If someone ever visits, we could get some fun voyeur stuff."

"That's not..." Mandy started, then thought back to when her old lesbian friend stopped by with her girlfriend at the time. Mandy heard them fucking in the guest bedroom one night, but didn't want to interrupt. It got her wet, and Vinny ate her out under the covers that night to the sounds of Flo and Reema going at it. "Fine, fine."

Mandy left her tech genius hubby to work on the cameras, while psyching herself up for the recording. She was a bit scared that she would start acting badly for the camera, moaning excessively, and doing stuff that didn't make her feel good but looked hot. It all melted away when Vinny came up behind her to embrace her in the guest bedroom.

Mandy felt his hands glide up and down her body, stroking the surface slower than normal that felt kinda hot. He was playacting a bit too, and it was fine. He was typically the fast and hard sort, but this was... this was an interesting sort of twist. Mandy lingered on the word twist, as he gently pinched her nipple and turned it so slightly that it didn't hurt, but sent an electric sort of tingle down her spine like a doorbell to the pussy to start making the wet stuff. Mandy bit her lip, as his hands slipped slowly down to then ascend up her shirt and softly embrace her right breast, then harder, as his other hand pushed at her back against the commode, ass out, feeling his hard cock already trying to vault his pants.

When it was out, buried in the groove of her buttocks in yoga pants, his fingers were both under the hoodie Mandy was wearing. He squeezed both breasts gently, while pushing himself against her ass, cock shoving itself into her crack like a hotdog into a groove of the bun. Mandy felt the first internal drip from that feeling, and gasped in surprise as the tickle of moisture intensified with him lifting the hoodie off her in one swift motion. She was topless now, being recorded from every angle, watched. There was a strange wildness to that knowledge.

"I'm taking them down," Vinny whispered in her ear, training his fingers on the edge of the yoga pants Mandy was sure had a moist spot already. The cock left the bun perch, as his nose glided down her back and into that same groove with a sniff as her pants slipped down to a cool breeze of the room. Vinny helped her take off the pants from the legs, as his nose was firmly buried in her asshole. This was probably a part that she would want removed from the recording, but she decided to get more lost in the moment rather than think of the cameras.

As he came up, Mandy felt his cock slam up against her pussy, sliding on the slick surface with the groove of his circumcised dickhead and did a little hop of surprise as the tightness of it tried to lift her up, only to slide to the back along her gap ceiling. It kept sliding until it made it to the top of the groove where it rested before, and rested there again, this time resting the dickhead on the base of her spine.

"I'm gonna come on your back," Vinny said, sliding his cock in the groove while holding his hand over the cock to make a slot he could slide in. Mandy was not about to let him just do it that way, instead grabbing his cock from the back and changing the angle to crouch so she could take him in her mouth. He didn't wait for any queues, slamming himself down her throat as she worked to get him wet so he could slide easier. Mandy's back was far too dry to get him off, but now she kinda wanted him to jerk off onto it at the end.

Once he was good and wet, Mandy leaned forward to tap her knees on the floor while looking up at him with his cock in her mouth. His eyes went wild, but he held himself back from finishing. Instead, he lifted her head as the cock slipped out of her mouth, then helped her up. He kissed her, sinking his tongue over the precum that coated the inside of her mouth, then smiled. His hands grabbed onto her ass, hard, then lifted her up against his body. Mandy could only wrap her legs around his waist to prevent herself from falling off, and he used that moment to slip inside her already soaking pussy.

Mandy felt the poke, sliding fast into her with a gasp of surprise. Vinny held her against him, smothering his face in her tits with his tongue out to make them wet. She lifted her ass a bit away, and felt his cock slip out, but he thumbed it back in on his first try. She lifted her ass again, but this time his hand was ready for it. As the head threatened to escape, his hand forced it to hover in the opening. Mandy slammed her hips down, as his dick slid back inside.

When he started to lose steam, Mandy decided to slip off back to her feet, and lay down in bed. His expression was thankful, as he started really thrusting now, pounding against her with a loud slapping sound, getting faster and faster.

"Oh, fuck, I'm coming inside!" He burst out, then buried his face in her tits for one second more before lifting his head up to the ceiling as hot cum spilled out inside her pussy. His grunt was louder than normal, and he shook a bit more over her than normal as the cum spurted out, but this was a standard climax for him. He would then slop over, pulling his cock out all soppy wet and breathe hot air into her ear as thank you. This did not happen.

Mandy found herself suspended by the legs on her upper back as if doing the candle pose. The only difference was that his face was between her legs, sucking on her pussy lips with intensity. Mandy was surprised, but he did just cum inside, so he wanted his sperm to find an egg. Unfortunately for his simple guy brain, she wasn't ovulating that night, so he was trying for nothing, but he did slurp a good amount of his own creampie.

Once he was done, Mandy sat on the edge of the bed to dispense the rest, or the few bits of it that were left inside, onto the floor beside the bed. She wasn't sure how much of it got recorded, but still did not climax, so she was about to finger herself off, but noticed a camera looking right at her pussy as she spread her lips to rub on the clit, only to let go, and stand up.

"I didn't come," she said, proudly requesting this be remedied.

"Fingers or face?" Vinny asked.

"Fingers," Mandy said, as he licked his index and middle fingers of the right hand while she sat on the edge of the bed. He made it his mission to get her off as she laid back down, sometimes feeling his lips suck at her clit as he pumped his two fingers inside her. When his tongue started circling her labia, Mandy was losing patience as the feeble attempt was failing to get her off, and added her own fingers to rub her clit to release herself over his face. That would no doubt look horrible on cameras, and Mandy grimaced feeling she let her audience down, before realizing she had no audience to let down.

"Hmm," Vinny said. "Sorry. I should have held out a bit more, but I got so excited we were recording it."

"Next time let's get some jelly involved," Mandy said. "Just so we feel a bit more, you know?"

"Did I mess up that bad?"

"No, it's ok, you did great," Mandy said, and felt stupid for patronizing. "You lifted me up, but I'm not ovulating."

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

"Ah, really screwed the pooch there, huh?"

"Definitely edit that part out," she said.

"Oh, care for another round?"

"You'll have a headache, Vin," she said, knowing that he had a limit in his late thirties, and if he tried to push past it, there would be consequences.

"I'll take it," he said, slapping his semi-erection against her thigh. "Where do you want it, miss?"

"Backshots," Mandy said, with renewed enthusiasm and a smile. "Get a good angle, too. Position me right over so I can see the cum landing on my back later."

"Oh, hell yeah," Vinny said, hardening full in her hand. He stood up and lifted Mandy by the ass, positioning her right over a camera in the ground, and right under one on the wall that would capture her back getting bathed in cum. With her in place, Vinny grabbed her waist and squished into her pussy once more, getting wet on the first pass from the residuals from before.

"Ass in play tonight?" He asked, slamming his hips against the butcheeks a few times as his cock slipped in and out of her pussy.

"Not fully. You stick a finger in," Mandy said. "But get it wet first."

"Copy!" Vinny said, and kept slamming, making a good pace while holding himself back from getting off too fast. He held a thumb under her dripping pussy to get the best lube at the source, and circled it on the sphincter, then spat on it to make it even easier to penetrate. The spit dripped down to her pussy, and joined the slapping sounds as he started feeling the taint tickle of building climax.

When Vinny stuck his finger in, Mandy's asshole tightened in surprise, and so did her pussy. He grit his teeth against getting off in that moment, as she rubbed herself off right over a camera, no doubt getting it wet with splashes and ruining the shot, but fuck was it hot inside her. Vinny grit his teeth, and then pulled free to slide his cock against the groove of her buttocks where his finger in her ass helped him aim his shots as they spurted out, choking up his lungs at each drop landing on her back.

Mandy kept rubbing away wildly as Vinny dug his finger in her ass, and his dick dripped the last of the cum out into the groove of her lower spine. When he started rubbing the cum over the skin in the groove, she arched back suddenly, having the cum on her back run down slightly over her sweaty skin. Vinny held her in place with his other hand at her neck, as she wriggled a bit from her own expert stimulation, and his finger in her ass. When she was about done, he pulled the finger out of her ass to get a good moan in soundoff. She collapsed over the camera under her. It was just his luck that the camera was actually between her legs, and her pussy was right in view of the high definition. Vinny wanted to see it right away, but felt the headache already coming on. He needed sugar and carbs right away.

He found himself dripping cum as he walked down the hall to the kitchen and came back to stand in front of the camera he set up with a smile while eating the second devil cake of the pack. He nudged his head at the camera and winked with a smile, hoping to keep that shot in the final edit, where his cock was out and wet, dripping cum as he inhaled devil cakes in the nude. Mandy was out like a light, and Vinny put her to bed, after cleaning up some of the cum off her back. He wanted to go edit the cameras right away, but slipped in beside Mandy and kissed the little cum drip he missed on her shoulder before getting some rest.

In the morning, Vinny fucked his shower asshole and came inside, finding it way too soft to be a real asshole. Mandy's ass was so much tighter, but he did not get to fuck it.

"I left a load in the asshole," he said. "So careful if you're eating her out."

"Why didn't you clean it out?" Mandy asked.

"I might want to use it later when it has my cum still in there."

"Won't it ruin the silicone?"

"Ah, fuck, youre proably right," Vinny said, slipping in beside Mandy already in the shower. She watched as he stuck his thumb in the asshole just like last night and pushed the cum to spill out into the drain. "You're clear."

"Thanks, hon," she said, then slapped the silicone ass with an open hand. Vinny felt left out, so he stuck out his ass, and received an equally loud slap on his asscheek as well.

"Love ya, hon!" He said, leaving her to get cleaned up while he was itching to get started editing the recordings.

By the time Mandy got washed and made herself some breakfast, Vinny had his cock out watching her jerking her clit off in high definition. Mandy walked in on him stroking off to it, and walked around to see what was on the screen.

"What the fuck?!" She burst out. "That's like right next to my pussy! That's not getting put into the video."

"But fuck if it's not hot, right?" Vinny asked, pumping himself in his seat. "Wanna help?"

"Not really, I just got cleaned up," she said. "But I'll watch you do it."

The shot changed to Mandy collapsing in front of the camera, which still showed her pussy against the ground, dripping juice over the lips. Vinny felt his ass tighten, and balls built a small amount of cum into a shot that found its way in the direction of Mandy on accident, laying down a line of cum over her face as she closed her eyes with mouth open.

"You're such an asshole, Vin!" She said, "At least my hair was in a towel, but how the hell did you manage that shot when you barely spurted out drops on my back last night?"

"Yesterday was the second time in a row," Vinny said. "And this facial was an accident. You got too close and saw how the cookies were made, my love."

"There is no way you're putting close-ups of my pussy in the video."

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like