He broke our kiss and looked me in the eye and I couldn't believe it when I heard him say, "Stud I want you to fuck me!"
"Whoa dude!"
"Listen to me I know this will be hotter than hell. Since Shelly and I have been doing some butt play it drives me crazy, she's used vibrators and such on me, but now I want to see what it feels like to have a real cock inside of me, and after hearing you two last night I know you're the stud I want at the other end of the cock!"
"Aaron..."
"Look bro, I've seen the way you look at me, and other guys have looked at me, I know I've kind of got it going on, and you can't tell me you wouldn't like to let's say...have one up on me!"
"I like you Aaron."
"Good I like you too, but come on stud, I'm the guy everyone loves to hate, but I've come to terms with that, that's why I always try to be fun to be around with, so let's make this really fun, tap this big ass, you'll have one over on me and I'll owe you one!
As he was saying that I realized that I was still stroking his big cock and he was stroking mine, I was hard and horny as hell. My mind couldn't seem to process all this information, it was so far out of my normal thinking.
I'm going to drop down there and get your cock as wet with my spit as I can and then bend over for you to slide it into me. With that Aaron got down on his knees, pulled my cock from my belly and started slurping. It was amazing, I guess it's true that head from another guy is better since he knows what it feels like. I couldn't think about what was going to happen next, I was just reveling in the pleasure.
Aaron had managed to take most of my cock into his mouth and then let it out to slap against my belly again. He wiped the spit from his mouth and rubbed it on his hole. He leaned in and kissed me, deeper this time and said, "Take it easy on me stud, you're getting my cherry here!"
Aaron turned toward the wall and bent over and pushed his ass out. Again I noticed it was a magnificent man's ass. He moved it around a bit, and looked over his shoulder and laughed and said, "I can't believe this is going to happen either, but I'm going to tell you, I've always felt a connection with you, and I'm glad you're going to be my first!"
That kind of made my head swell a bit, hearing that this stud thought I was hot. I moved in closer and took a deep breath and then ran my cock up and down his hairy crack looking for his hole. I have to admit it felt great and we both grunted like animals when the thick head of my cock found his hole.
I immediately recognized the feeling and was hurled back in time to my college days. One young lady I dated for a short time in college suggested a try at butt sex and I remembered the moves. I did now what I had done then and pushed against his hole and then retreated just enough to relieve the pressure, then pushed forward again.
I did that four or five times and only gained a little ground, but I could feel Aaron's tight hole clamped around the head of my cock. I backed out, spit on the head of my cock a couple of times and rubbed it around. In just a few short minutes I had gone from not wanting to do this to being determined to bury my bone in Aaron's 'virgin' butt.
I lined up again and found his hole and pushed again, then relaxed. The next time I pushed Aaron pushed back an about half of my cock shot into his tight hole. Aaron grunted and then let out a long low howl! "Do you want me to pull out?"
"NO, oh fuck that hurts, but no, just don't move, give me a minute to adjust!"
I looked down at my hands clamped on Aaron's waist and my throbbing cock half buried in his hairy butt, and was just amazed. Less than an hour ago, I would have never imagined that I'd be fucking a dude, much less my wife's uber hot cousin, macho, hunter/fisher, jock stud. But here I was.
At that second, I made a resolve. Everything that Aaron did, he did full throttle, sports, work, and life. I was going to prove to him that there were some things I was great at too and sex was one of them. My cock stays hard as steel, I can hold out from cumming for a long time, and once I get wound up I love to power fuck!
I felt Aaron's tight ass squeeze and relax a couple of times and decided to wait until the next time I felt him relax and then I was going to make a move. When it happened, I slid my cock almost out and then slowly slid back in to about the same point. Aaron, winced, grunted and then moaned. I felt him relax so I did it again.
Aaron turned his head toward me and said, "Easy stud, I didn't realize how much thicker you are than what I've had inside me before!"
I smiled at him, slapped his big muscle butt and said, "Shut up bitch, I'm doing the fucking here!"
Aaron kind of laughed and said, "Okay stud, I guess you're in charge."
I slapped his ass again and said, "Yes I am!"
I pulled all the way out and plugged back in, not too hard, but with determination. Aaron grunted.
I did that about five times and then decided it was time that Aaron felt all of my cock. So the sixth time I pulled out, I plunged all the way back in, that made him jump, wince, growl and moan. "Oh fuck, man oh fuck?"
"Does that hurt man?"
Now I'm not evil, but I now wanted to fuck this man, long and hard!
"Yeah, fuck it hurts! But it also feels amazing, it feels weird, kind of scares me and..."
"Okay bitch, then shut the fuck up and take it! You heard the fucking last night and wanted it, now you're going to get it!"
I started out slowly in and out all the way, but then built up speed and was fucking him faster. Aaron started making noises that didn't make any sense, but his ass was coming alive, probably all on its own. I think Aaron was in a state of bliss/shock, and his body and needs had taken over, I know mine certainly had. There was nothing boring in the sex that Carrie and I had, but there was never anything this wild!