Thank you to an anonymous comment on chapter 2 for inspiring this chapter!
All characters are above the age of 18.
*
The guys came over to my place for lunch one day. We ate hot pot stickers. We had never made them before, but Elijah thought it could be fun since the co-op had a giant kitchen and everything available. We definitely burned half of them, but they were still edible!
We ate at one of the outdoor picnic tables in the yard, and- Omg! It was Gale. He had muscles on muscles and the most charming smile. I saw him come over to our co-op house a couple times over the semester with his friends, and I had a mini, okay, huge crush on him. I'd never talked to him, so my crush was pretty much purely physical. He looked like walking sex.
He looked up at me, and I flitted my eyes away, trying to seem like I was just looking around, and not staring at him again. It was kind of weird that Patt and Elijah were with me right now, but also not, because we were best friends before their gay curious expolrations started. I promised myself I wouldn't get weird about it and be fine when they were done exploring. We'd still always be friends. But it wasn't fair to me to just wait around to be their sex toy when they were likely still hooking up with girls, though they hadn't mentioned anyone in a while... They were probably trying to be nice by not bringing it up. Whatever, this guy was seriously hot and actually gay.
I got up to get seconds of dessert, ugh, I kept thinking of the other day when Patt and Elijah, no no no, don't think anout it.
Smack, I just ran into someone! Someone's very hard very firm and big chest. "Whoops! Sorry, I wasn't paying attention." I looked up. It's Gale! "Oh!" I blushed. He's even hotter upclose.
He was smiling his big charming smile. He leaned down close to my ear and whispered, "Aren't you cute?"
I blushed, said, "Thanks!" and ran away! Why did I walk away instead of starting a conversation with him? Ugh.
When I got back to the table, Elijah turned to Patt, "See there's other straight dudes here, and they get close to Brycen, too." Patt shrugged and kept eating.
"Wow, you guys have the worst gay-dar ever. He's totally gay." I peaked over, and he smiled at me again! "And I think he's going to come over to our table."
Elijah's jaw actually dropped. "He's gay?"
At the same time, Patt's eyes narrowed, "Mhmm."
The guys are obviously not homophobic. Why did they react that way?
We finished up our meal and chatted, sipping on some sodas. A little while later, just as I predicted and hoped, Gale strode back over. He gave a 'sup nod to Elijah and Patt and leaned against my side of the table. When he lifted a hand to brush a strand of hair out of my eyes, Patt beat him to it. What what that? Elijah switched seats to my side of the table, completely unneccessarily, moving himself between me and Gale.
"Wow, you have two body guards with you, huh?" Gale joked.
"Uhh... these are my best friends. They can be a little overprotective. Cut it out, guys."
"No worries, cutie. See you around," he smiled and walked away. I just stared at his back.
"Guuyyyys!! Why did you cock-block me? He was soooo hot. I've wanted him to talk to me all semester!"
"All?" Elijah emphasized.
"Semester?" Patt asked.
Why were they so in synch? Usually I was the tie-breaker. They both seemed upset. Angry and a little sad? Disappointed? Were they... jealous right now? No, that couldn't be.
We ate the rest of our food in a tense silence, until Elijah lightened the mood, and we continued on as usual.
......
Gale came over to the house again the following week and asked me out! I dressed nicely, but not too eagerly.
Gale had wanted to pick me up, but I was adament anout meeting him there. For some reason, I felt like Patt or Elijah might see if he picked me up, and after their weird reactions the other day, I didn't want them to ruin anything. And, to be honest, I didn't want to keep thinking about them, like now. My goal was to try to focus just on Gale, the super hot gay guy who is actually interested in me that way.
I was about to head into the Italian restaurant when Patt showed up, out of nowhere, walking on the street! Do we have some sort of magnetic pulling tether between us or what.
"Brycen, hey! You look nice in this pink shirt." He fingered my shirt collar. "Are the twinks meeting for dinner or something?"
I'd be offended if that wasn't something we actually did.
"Um, no, uh sort of? Not really... I'm meeting a friend!"
We both looked to the restaurant where through the door's window, we could see a side profile of Gale.
Patt lifted his cellphone, pushed speaker, and calling someone. "Guess who I found on a date at the Italian restaurant with that guy from the co-op the other day?"
Elijah replied blandly, "The one trying to grope Brycen and eating him up with his eyes?"
I squeeked! "Guysss!"
"I'll be right there," Elijah replied, not missing a beat."
"Don't embarass me!"
I walked away, trying to ignore what just happened. Gale looked towards the door when he heard me enter.
Wow, he looked good dressed up in tight fitting black jeans and a crisp white collared shirt and jacket.
"Hey, Cutie!" He greeted me with a hug and bent down for a kiss to the cheek.
"You smell really good," I said against his neck. I felt him shiver slightly.
"Glad you like it," he replied confidently and winked! He walked us to our table and pulled out my chair. Elijah and Patt have never pulled out a chair for me... Our table was really pretty by a window. He must have actually made reservations well in advance. The guys always only took me out to last minute dinners... focus!
I tried to relax. We chatted away. The conversation came easily. Gale was friendly and gave me lots of compliments, which I ate up.
10 or 15 minutes later, Elijah arrived and joined Patt, sitting at a table across from me. They were behind Gale, so he didn't notice, but every time I looked at Gale, I saw Elijah and Patt watching me over his shoulder! This was stressful. I couldn't concentrate on my conversation with Gale.
I couldn't take it anymore. I needed a break and excused myself to use the restroom. I held up a stop hand signal towards the guys when walking past them. I just needed a few minutes alone to gather my thoughts.
They didn't immediately follow. The restroom was empty when I walked in. I washed my face and was drying off, when someone leaned from behind me and bluntly asked against my ear, "Are you going to let him fuck you?" Elijah.
He startled me! I tried to move away, but he gripped my waist tightly. I swiveled my head, and Patt moved to the largest stall and held it open. Elijah picked me up and walked us over to it, Patt locking it behind us.
"Guys!" I laughed and tried to push away, but Elijah held my hands in a firm grip.
"Are you going to kiss him?" Patt growled. Before I could answer, he covered my mouth with his and plastered his body against mine.
"Hmmm!"
Elijah held steady behind me. I was sandwiched so tightly and so deliciously between them!
Patt pulled back, "Answer me."
They held me tightly between them. My head swam. "Probably?" He bit my lip!
Elijah sucked on my neck.
"Wait, stop! I'm on a date with a guy. A gay guy, who... who can have feelings for me."
He sucked harder. I was able to move my hand again, and while I meant to push him away, I pulled him closer against me. He grunted.
"He's going to see a hickey!" I was held so tightly between them, all I could manage was to wiggle against both their - Oh! Their hard cocks! I moaned.
Elijah popped off. "You hoping for more than a kiss from him? Maybe he would've licked up your neck." That's what Elijah did. I was panting. "But does he know your sweet spots like we do?" He sucked my sensitive ear!
Little gasps left my mouth. Patt covered my mouth with his hand as Elijah continued to lick and suck my ear. He briefly brought my hand to his mouth to suck my fingers. My head fell back against his shoulder. Then he focused on my other ear. I was so hard! My body was melting against them, but I was also wound tight.
Patt's other hand traveled under my shirt and started fondling my nipple. "Were you hoping he'd play with your pretty pink nipples?" He rolled it between his fingers soooo good.
"Yeaahhh."
He pinched. My hips jerked. He did it again and again.
Elijah shoved his fingers in my mouth. I sucked thoroughly. Elijah backed up a step and brought his slicked fingers under my waist band and skimmed down my crack, until he found my hole.
"Were you hoping he'd play with your tight little hole?" He rubbed against it deliciously.
