Original story by Brian Porter - Edited by Cham Couthe (thanks, mate)
"Is that enough?" Logan asked me as I put a package of corn starch in the basket.
"Dude, there's five pounds here. That's enough for a whole year of fake c--" I stopped myself. It wouldn't be wise to say that out loud. "You know what."
"You're wrong. Think about it. Every time my jizz--"
I shushed him. Logan looked a little annoyed but continued more cautiously.
"Every time it changes flavour, you're gonna need to cook a new batch and the old one goes down the drain. Besides, you're not cooking only one cup of the fake nectar." I don't know why he chose the word 'nectar', but it wasn't as compromising as jizz or cum. "You're making what? A gallon? You're gonna have to drink a lot of this stuff so you can really get used to the taste. Otherwise, you'd never be able to tell the difference. Maybe it's a pinch of sugar extra that will change the whole thing, and we don't want to mess up with this, right?"
Logan then approached me and whispered in my ear. "Think of the chicks saying our jizz tastes better than a milk shake. Dude, think of all the bitches lining up outside our doors just to have a taste of our nectar. They're gonna completely drain us. We'll become legends in our dorm."
I can't deny it--his proposition was just amazing. The very idea of hot chicks lined up and begging for my jizz made me hard like a fucking rock. Logan knew what he was doing. The guy was a genius.
"Ok. Let's get two just in case." I put five more pounds of starch in the basket.
"Atta boy! We're one step closer to becoming legends, my man."
"Can't wait." I was truly happy. I wasn't thinking about what I'd need to go through before getting to that ideal stage of idolization. I only imagined I was a step closer to achieving the ultimate dream of any man.
The shop wasn't too busy, and we could find everything we needed. Well, to put it precisely, the stuff I needed, because Logan didn't ask for anything. I had a short list with a few products I thought were important for our experiment. Stuff that people on the internet said could make cum taste better. It was awkward to make Logan's grocery list since he would be the one eating the stuff I bought, but I thought it wasn't so bad since he'd be paying for that.
"You know what would be nice?" Logan was swapping price tags on the shelves while I looked for a specific brand of natural yogurt.
"What's that?" I asked.
"You could find out how to make something that smells like cum." There was no one around, so I didn't care about his word choice.
"Why?" I still didn't stop to look at him as this all seemed like a natural conversation.
"You know how the smell of dirty jocks makes your willy soft..."
"Oh, c'mon. 'Willy'?" I finally looked at him, but he didn't turn his head to face me.
"What's wrong, dude? It's tiny, isn't it? The faster you get that, the faster you'll get over it. Besides, soon it will be as big or bigger than mine."
"True that." I resumed my searching.
Logan didn't say another word. I knew his silence meant he was probably pissed.
"Go on." I didn't want to provoke him. Logan could be so sensitive sometimes.
"Can I say 'willy' or you'll stop me every time I do?"
"For fuck sake, just go on."
"Anyway, I was thinking that maybe the smell of cum would make your willy soft too."
I found the yogurt I wanted and put it in the basket.
"I bet it would, but we can't make such a thing."
"Course we can." Logan picked up his phone and I soon received a message from him with a link to a page that showed what ingredients were needed to make a legit cum fragrance.
"You can't be serious," I protested.
"It doesn't hurt to give it a try, right? Besides, we can find all this stuff in the cleaning section over there."
"You're nuts," I said before turning away towards the cleaning aisle.
"Fuck, man. You won't believe this..." Logan sounded excited. I looked back at him. He was reading something on his phone with a large smile on his face. Then he moved his eyes from the phone to me and turned serious. "Never mind."
"What is it?"
"I said never mind."
"What the fuck, dude? What is it?" I dropped the basket and threw myself toward Logan who fought to keep his phone away from me. I did my best to get it from him, but he wouldn't let me. This could have gone on until someone kicked us out from the supermarket, but he quit before it happened.
"Okay! Okay!" he said, giving up. "But you won't like it. I just wanted to protect you."
"What won't I like?"
"Fuck, man. I'm sorry, okay? It's just... Sarah texted me to say she wants to meet me again. Sarah and Michelle."
"Wow, that's nice." I smiled. "We're gonna have another date?"
"No, dude. Listen to me. She said they want to meet me. The two of them want to fuck me and only me. Sorry."
Wow, that hurt. I couldn't believe it. For a second, I was so devastated I could cry.
"Why's that?" I did my best to ask him without letting my sadness show.
"Your willy, dude. She said it's too tiny. Then Michelle said she wants to see mine since Sarah's been bragging about it. She said she'd be willing to swallow my nasty jizz if I agree to meet them."
"Good for you." I picked up the basket, thinking I'd drop it somewhere and go back home.
"Hey, wait. I didn't say I'm going, did I?"
I turned around. I wasn't expecting that.
"Ain't you going? Are you mad? Why?"
"Coz we're brothers, right? We do everything together. I'd never do that without you."
That fucking bastard was the best friend someone could have. I dropped the basket again and rushed to give him a bear hug.
"You son of a bitch." I was happy again.
"Let me go. Fuck. People are staring at us."
There was no one around us, but I preferred to be a little less conspicuous.
"I'll tell her we can do that later this month. I'll say I'll have a big surprise for her if she waits."
"And what's the surprise?"
"You! You idiot. When your willy starts to look like a real massive cock, we go and meet them. They'll regret treating you like shit."
"But will one month be enough?"
"Well, we just need to play right and hard like we always do. I'm sure it'll be enough. You just need to do as I say."
"You bet."
"And let's surprise them with our sweet nectar too, eh? And then, once they have it and come back for more, we say that ain't happening. These bitches will be humiliated for life."
I hugged the son of a bitch again.
We headed to the cashier with a full basket. I scanned all the products and showed the screen to Logan.