I had never really been fussed about sex. I was 21 and hadn't even kissed another guy. I wasn't in any rush to, either. It'll happen when it happens, I thought. Besides, I was a student living at home and I wasn't out of the closet, so I couldn't bring the sort of guys I liked home.
My first sexual encounter happened when my dad went overseas for a month and a half. After a week or two of sitting on the fence, I jumped on Craigslist. I wasn't new to Craigslist; I had been on the site before, browsing the personals section and reading the casual encounter ads. Another man's horniness always made me horny.
I quickly found an ad posted by a 25 year old cub that lived close by, looking to get his dick sucked and more. I had seen this guy's ad before, and his cock photos looked amazing. More girth than length in a bed of brown pubes, a mouthful of head tucked under foreskin, and with an ample hairy belly hanging overhead. I responded late at night, and the next morning received his reply. We exchanged information, and he came over.
I was waiting in the garage, pacing back and forth endlessly.
'I'm here', he texted me, and my heart was in my mouth. I opened the garage door and watched the letterboxes where I had told him to go. A tall, broad shouldered bear of a young man waved at me as he climbed the short flight of stairs and lumbered over. He wore a blue singlet; I could see his muscled arms and heavy-set body, tanned from hours spent shirtless in the sun; a real football player's build. He had a broad, chubby face, slightly unshaven, and stood half a head taller than me.
"Hey," he nodded brusquely, with a strong Australian accent. His eyes raked my body, and mine his.
"Come in. I hope this is okay," I said, waving to the makeshift mattress I had set up.
"Yeah, it's fine," he assured me, stepping in and peering around. I closed and locked the door behind him. Off went his singlet, quickly followed by his board shorts and then his boxer-briefs. I quickly undressed, but my eyes were glued to his bearish body. His cock was still thick when it was soft; it rested on his hairy nut sack. I ran my hands down his fuzzy arms, nervous. I had never gotten this far with another guy. Here we were, naked side by side, with nothing in interrupt us. He was probably going to be the first guy inside me.
The next thing I knew, he had reclined back on the mattress, and I was on my hands and knees with my head between his thighs and his flaccid cock waiting under my lips. It smelt faintly of the soap he had used when he showered earlier. Gently with my fingers, I stood his member up, pulled the foreskin back and put it in my mouth without hesitation.
"Ohhh, yeah," he moaned, hips bucking a little. His cock swelled in my mouth, thickening at an alarming rate. It surprised me that he could get so much pleasure before I felt I had even started. I swirled my tongue around the head as it grew firm, and tasted the salty-slimy precum.
I began to bob my head up and down while my hand rubbed his hairy stomach and legs. He was fully erect by now, and I was having trouble fitting him in my mouth. "You're clean, right?" I said between gulping down his meat and licking his soft, hairy balls.
"Yeah, I'm clean," he said, and placed a hand behind my head, forcing me down his shaft. When I buried my nose in his pubes, his throbbing cock made me gag. I retched and pulled up."Fuck yeah," he murmured, grabbed my head and slowly fucked my mouth for a bit. I closed my eyes, focused on breathing around his girth, and let it wash over me. This was what I had been secretly looking forward to all my life, and I loved it.
He pulled me off his cock. Spit ran down my chin and down his shaft which stood straight up. I wrapped my hand around his cock to stroke it, and could barely get my hand around it. How was that in my mouth just now?
"Let me suck yours for a bit?" He rolled off the mattress and I took his place; he spread my legs and got right up between them. I was rock hard already. He took my cock full in his mouth; warmth and wetness enveloped it, and he made moaned in approval as he devoured my cock. His hands groped at my chest, squeezing and rubbing me while his excitement escalated until his head was bouncing up and down between my legs. "Mmmrphm, so good," he gasped when he surfaced for air, before stuffing me back into his mouth again.
"Do you want to fuck me?" I offered all of a sudden. I had planned on letting him fuck me after a bit more sucking, but I couldn't wait any more. I wanted to feel his cock up my ass right now. This young, hairy bear with the beer-can cock... I wanted him to break me in for the first time.
He paused to look at me, perhaps to see if I was serious. His hands continued to slide up and down my cock, lubricated by his spit and my precum. "Yeah, I do," he admitted, and then continuing to suck my cock. "What, now?"
I nodded, and got up to grab the lube and condoms. "You can fuck me bareback if you're clean."
"I'm clean," he assured me again, and took the lube I offered. I shouldn't have done that, especially being my first time. But thankfully, he really was clean.
He pointed to the mattress and set the tube of lubricant on the ground. "Get on all fours, doggy style. I want to see your ass."
I did as I was told and stuck my ass in the air. This is it, I thought. I'm about to finally get fucked. I can't believe this is happening. A chubby guy with a big dick -- a man straight from my fantasies, and he was getting ready to fuck me. He spat on his finger and fingered my ass for a few seconds, and the mattress shook as he dropped to his knees behind me.
"Fuck, that's a nice, tight hole," he growled, spreading my ass cheeks apart to run his tongue up and down my crack. His tongue was warm and wet, and for a while, pleasant, before he started worming it into my ass. It felt like a finger and thicker than I thought it would have been.
I shifted my ass to make his tongue go up and down over my hole again. The mattress shook again as he straightened and slapped his rock-hard cock over my ass-crack. He squeezed lube onto his cock, then leaned back to apply a few cold drops over my hole.
"It's my first time, go slow," I pleaded, but I don't think he heard me; his cock was rubbing hard against my crack, and making brief jabs at my entrance as his hips started to rock back and forth out of habit. I wonder how many other guys and girls this man had slept with, and knew I was simply another conquest in a long line of his bed partners, and I was okay with that. In fact, it excited me.
His thrusting slowed. He began to push his cock up into my virgin hole in earnest. It was warm... so warm, and so thick. It felt like he was trying to push a beer can through me, and my hole wasn't budging. He relented for half a heartbeat, took one hand off my hip to grasp his shaft, before trying to push his cock in me again, and this time he managed to force the head in. I cried out, or swore, or moaned -- I can't remember exactly what crude sound I made as he proceeded to bear down on me, relentlessly shoving his manhood deeper and deeper inside me.