I am more than a little bit phobic about sex. I blame it on my Catholic upbringing. I’ve never had sex without throwing up afterward. I’m scared of getting pregnant; terrified of catching a disease; but mostly just creeped out by the idea of another person touching my privates. It really makes my skin crawl.
I don’t want you to get the impression that I’m a prude. Throughout high school I masturbated all the time, raiding my brothers under-the bed porn stash for inspiration. When I was 18, I bought my first vibrator.
Oh I lost my virginity, and it did little to increase my enthusiasm for the forbidden act. In my second year of college, I hooked up with a guy I thought was cute at a party. We were both a little drunk, and it was clumsy, awkward, uncomfortable, and over mercifully fast. At least I made sure he used a condom. The next month was torture. I got an AIDS test, I made a gynecologist appointment; I fretted and worried and counted the days till my period. The relief I felt when the test came back negative, and my period came on schedule didn’t encourage me to go out and have sex again.
For the next two years, I studied hard, and got good grades. I didn’t exactly have to fight off the guys; I am exceptionally tall, I don’t have big boobs, and I wear glasses. In the mean time, my pent up lust increased to the point of bursting. I remember masturbating in my dorm room, my ear pressed against the wall, listening to my neighbor fuck her boyfriend, tears running down my cheeks in frustration. My sex toy collection steadily increased.
In my senior year, I started dating Charlie. He wasn’t a ‘nice’ boy; he had a pierced tongue, and played in a band, and smoked pot, and most importantly, he didn’t pressure me to have sex with him. He was a hell of a kisser though, and eventually I worked up the nerve to ask him if he would like to watch me masturbate.
I liked watching him stroke himself with his eyes glued to my spread pussy, a slick purple vibrator sliding in and out. It was really only the second time I had seen a penis in real life. I liked the way his come shot out the end of it (safely away from me), and the noise he made when he came. It was really pornographic. My clit twitching, I had an amazing orgasm as he watched.
Needless to say, it quickly became a habit. I loved watching him get off, and he got off watching me. Overnight, I had an amazing sex life. One time he asked if I would use my hand on him, and to my surprise, I didn’t mind. I wore a latex glove, and pumped his penis until he cried aloud and his sperm splashed all over his sexy smooth chest. I liked how hard and smooth his penis felt, and how tight I could squeeze it. I like varying the rhythms, slower then faster until his balls contracted and the head turned bright purple. And I loved making him come.
So that’s the way it was. We’d watch porn together and masturbate; or he’d jack off while I toyed for him; or I’d put on a glove and lube up his stiff cock and give him a hand job. Life was good.
I could tell he was nervous. We were hanging out in my apartment, we had just had a couple beers, and this was the time of night when we would usually get naked and watch each other get off. He was being quiet, and I could tell something was on his mind. I was afraid that he was going to ruin everything and ask me to have sex with him. When he finally asked, I nearly laughed aloud. “Would I like to fuck him in the ass?” I’d love to! My cunt was dripping just thinking about it.
I let him pick out the toy. He chose one of my smaller dildos, a blue silicone one that looked like a mermaid. I was wet just thinking about it. He asked me to be gentle. “I’m a virgin at this”, he said.
He got on his hands and knees, his rump thrust obscenely into the air. His cock swayed rigidly between his legs, his balls were tight. A clear drop of precome leaking from the swollen purple tip of his cock got stuck to his belly and hung there in a shimmering arc like a sticky thread of spider web.
He looked back at me, eyes glazed over with lust. “Please fuck me, Andrea.”
I put on my latex gloves and started applying lube. He moaned and his little asshole winked as I dripped cool lube onto his anus. We were both incredibly excited.
I was gentle, and I took it slow, but he was so relaxed that it slipped right in. Before we knew it, the toy was buried to the hilt in my boyfriend’s tight ass.
“How does it feel?” I asked.
“It feels great” he whispered “now try fucking me.”
Gingerly at first, then harder and harder as he encouraged me, I started sliding the dildo in and out. I would withdraw it almost all the way out, then slide it back in. He would hump back against me, fucking back against my thrusts. I twisted the toy inside him, and he moaned satisfyingly. I was amazed at how wet I was, my juices were literally running down my thighs onto the sheets. I stopped holding back, and fucked him with a vengeance, ramming the dildo up his ass until my arm was sore and my shoulder ached. He was jerking off now, in time to my thrusts, and when he came, he arched his back and shouted, and the jet of semen hit him in the chin.
I couldn’t wait to get off. Leaving the blue cock inside him, I physically rolled him over and squatted over his face to give him a prime view. It took about two seconds of tugging on my clit before the orgasm started. I felt my toes curl and my pussy spasm, and I just let the waves roll over me again and again until I was done.
“That was amazing” I said, and he agreed.
“Let’s do that again.”
We did do it again. And again and again. Fucking his ass became a regular part of our sex life. I had no idea what I had done to make me so lucky.
Eventually it was over. He met another girl, one who liked normal sex, one who would touch his penis without needing to wear gloves. I don’t know if she fucks his ass, and I don’t ask. We stayed friends; we write Christmas cards and call each other on our birthdays. I guess that’s about the most one could ask.
After I graduated, I moved to New York. Do you have any idea how hard it is to date boys in New York when you aren’t really into the bar and club scene, and when you let the occasional guy who does ask you out know up front that you don’t put out? My love life was completely nonexistent.
After six months of frustration and jilling off to memories of fucking Charlie from behind, I decided that desperate times called for desperate measures. I placed an ad in the Village Voice.
“Tall, slim twenty something female seeks cute guy. I’m not a prude but I don’t like sex. Maybe we can have some fun together.”
I got a lot of responses. They were all from guys who were out to convince me that they were the one who was going to teach me to love sex. I didn’t get a single message that warranted a callback. Disgusted, I fell back on my two favorite indulgence; porn and dildos.