When this happened, my girlfriend, Sheila, and I had been going out for about three years.
We met on the job, both of us recently out of school. We did the normal stuff and always had great sex. We were committed to each other enough to move in together, but being young, just didn't want to get married right away.
We ended up living beside an interesting couple, Mike and Anne. He was in his mid 30's and she was a few years younger. He was an engineer and Army Reservist and she worked in some administrative capacity at a local university. It turns out he'd been in the Army full time, but after a couple of tours they wanted to dial it down and so he went into the reserves.
We ended up spending many evenings with them, getting tipsy and sharing stories. His were interesting, mine, not so much. Anne and Sheila became very good friends. One day they went to a spa and in the steam room Anne told Sheila that Mike wanted her to sleep with other men. The whole conversation came up because she invited Sheila to "go dancing" the following weekend, girls only. It turned out Mike would be gone for a weekend drill and he didn't mind if she hit the town. We were pretty naive then and thought the whole idea sounded "odd".
Needless to say, I found it exciting. I encouraged her to go, but in a way that made it seem as if it was a joke. In truth a big part of me was thrilled. Since we'd become serious, the idea of her going to a bar was absurd unless we went together and even then, it was to meet friends. Long story short, we made it happen. That evening Anne came over and I was a little shocked. She was HOT. Don't get me wrong, I knew she was pretty, but she was dressed to kill. Both of them left. That night I did chores and contemplated what was happening. I felt jealous but aroused.
Nothing actually happened, but the weeks turned into months and Anne would update Sheila on her progress. The "breakthrough" occurred when she confessed that Mike had driven her to a swinger club in the city, as a surprise, and she ended up fucking another man. Anne said it wasn't horrible, but she really wasn't into it. Both Sheila and I thought that scenario was absurd. As she described Anne's story we looked at each other in disbelief. Were there really people like this?
Keep in mind my hands were all over her Sheila as she filled me in on this latest news. We're on the couch, I'm rubbing her legs, trying to spread them, pulling her close to me. She reached over and felt my hard cock in my jeans. She pulled out my cock and started to stroke it.
Our conversation took a turn I will never forget. It was cat and mouse, hide and seek type conversation. My eyes were in the back of my head as I asked her if she wanted to be like Anne. She said I really wouldn't want that. I told her not to be so sure. She stopped stroking and I gulped as a waited for her response. She go up and pulled up her skirt. I pulled down her panties and inhaled. She told me if she did something like this, there would be no undoing it. I pushed her back onto the couch. I entered her.
I felt 15 again. My cock was extremely sensitive and as hard as it could be. This was the best sex I'd ever had with her. She said she didn't think she could have sex with some stranger from the bar. I understand, I said, somewhat disappointed. Then she added, maybe I wanted to see her with Mike? I immediately pounded her and squirted deep into her. I was almost ashamed of what I'd done. With my balls drained and the orgasm finished, I felt weird. I didn't want Sheila to fuck somebody else! What was I, crazy?
She didn't pick up on this. She was quite happy with the fuck. She got up and got ready for bed and 20 minutes later as we crawled into bed, my little head logic had returned. I was horny.
To tell the truth, at that point I wasn't just aroused at the idea of Sheila with another man. A big part of my thinking was that maybe I could angle this into a situation where if I could fuck Anne. It was funny, because Sheila began to bring up Mike in our sex play, but I was too ashamed to admit I wanted to fuck another woman. Complicated yet stupid, huh?