I know you can't please everyone. But let's see if I can piss everyone off! I've decided release three parallel "next chapters" simultaneously... three alternative futures for our heroine and heroes. Hopefully they'll all pop up on Literotica at the same time. I've labeled them Blue, Orange, and Purple -- no significance other than being the opposites of Red, Yellow and Green on the color wheel. So, they're not safe words.
Some of you may well read all three of them. Just remember... whichever one you read first, that's what really happened! [Shocked face emoji!] The other two are just Ryan's future daydreams and nightmares of relief or regret...
So, choose wisely. Because Ryan can't.
We drove home on Sunday, not speaking much. We listened to the music on the MP3 player, and she laced her fingers through mine and stared off through her sunglasses, through the windshield at the interstate before us.
I wondered what was going on in her mind, but I didn't pry. It would make sense that she might be feeling a bit sad. Her time with my dad had been a crazy, intense little fling, a game that she had played for my twisted benefit. But I knew there was something more there. I was sure there was, from my father's point of view. Probably, to some degree, for her, too.
There certainly was for me.
And then, there was the exciting, maddening thought in my mind that she might already be carrying his child. That he had achieved the ultimate goal that was nature's intent for what they had been doing. My cock ached all the way home. I was still wearing the cage. We hadn't discussed that, either.
She left the key on my nightstand after unpacking. I unlocked myself and put the cage in my top dresser drawer. No unveiling ceremony, no teasing that maybe I ought to leave it on for a while longer.
That night, when she came out of the bathroom in an emerald green satin nightshirt -- one that I had never seen before -- I had no trouble becoming instantly hard. She smelled good, too, I noted as she straddled me. A new perfume. Baby-making perfume, I thought. To go with new baby-making lingerie.
Or maybe it wasn't new. Maybe it was just something she had bought for him, one more thing for him to enjoy while I was denied.
If she got pregnant tonight, or this coming week -- if she missed her next period -- I wouldn't know for sure if the baby was mine. The thought just made me harder.
She reached down to grasp me and seated herself on top of me. The pleasure was glorious. So, too was my orgasm, eventually. I felt pleased with myself that I lasted long enough for her to cum, too. Evidently, she was aroused as I was.
We made love every night for the next week and a half, and several mornings. Every time, I imagined that she was already pregnant with his child. Every time, my orgasm was intense. But I never admitted to her why.
Two weeks later she informed me that her period had started.
"It's okay," she told me. "I really didn't expect to get pregnant the first month off the pill."
You didn't? I thought. You were that sure? Sure enough to spend one last night in my father's bed, giving him the
prima nocta
, the first chance to have unprotected sex with her, to be the one who planted his offspring in her fertile womb if she was wrong?
But I didn't say that. I didn't say anything. I just held her and kissed the top of her head. And felt a certain sense of disappointment.
Of course, this meant that if she got pregnant now --
when
she got pregnant now -- there would be no doubt that the baby was mine. Ours, of course. But not my father's. I should feel an overwhelming sense of relief. Instead, I felt like something that had become a part of me was suddenly missing.
***
When I turned off the TV and came to bed that night, she was sitting up in bed reading. We wouldn't be having sex tonight; she never feels like it at the start of her period. So my brain wasn't clouded with lust already when she brought up the subject.
"So, congratulations," she said.
"For what?" I asked.
"For holding out," she continued, setting aside her book. "For taking my best shot, without breaking."
I grinned. I figured I knew what she was talking about now, but I didn't want to interrupt her.
"Honestly," she said. "That went a lot farther than I ever imagined. I figured you would have used your safe word."
"Yeah," I admitted. "It was amazing."
Then I realized that she wasn't in a teasing mood.
"You let me sleep with another man when you knew I had gone off the pill." Then she drove home the point. "Your
father
."
"As I recall," I responded, gingerly, "That was your choice, too."