Author's Note: this story contains cuckolding, humiliation, homosexuality, and forced/non-consensual sex.
***
After my prom night, my wish came true - I spent the rest of the school year receiving texts of pics and videos showing Jeff fucking one or both of the girls, and on lucky days he would invite me over to watch, even sometimes letting me suck his dick or lick his cum off the girls. Jeff had awakened something inside me that needed to submit to this superior stud, and I had come to accept and enjoy it. Jenny was still kind of treating me as her boyfriend in a teasing kind of way - having me take her out on dates, giving me pecks on the cheek, that kind of thing - but obviously not letting me have sex with her anymore.
Through the rumor mill, the whole school came to learn what a sissy loser I was, and I would hear their giggles and whispers when I walked down the hall. Even our teacher, Mr. Davis, seemed to have found out about it - one day, I was struggling to do a math problem on the board, and he interrupted me, saying, "Lucas, maybe we should let Jeff come up here and show you how it's done - he seems to be good at that." I couldn't believe what I was hearing, but as the whole class burst out laughing, I looked at Mr. Davis, who was kind of smirking at me, and saw his bulge twitch in his pants. I had to cover up my own boner as I scurried back to my seat, to the class's continued laughter.
Finally, graduation came and we were free for the summer. The first weekend of our summer vacation, Jeff invited me out to dinner at a local diner with Jenny and Emily. Jeff had me drive around to pick everybody up in my car. The three of them sat in the back seat and made out together as I drove. When we got to the diner, Jeff sat in a booth in a tight-fitting tank-top that showed off his muscular physique, and Emily sat next to him, while Jenny and I sat on the other side. The girls were of course wearing skimpy clothing that showed off their amazing, young bodies.
Jeff put his arm around Emily and let us know that his parents had just flown out of town for the week for a romantic getaway. Jenny and Emily exchanged a look, knowing this meant a week of enjoying Jeff's big dick whenever they wanted. My own erection swelled, hoping he would let me participate in some of the action.
"So I was thinking we could all head over to my place after this," Jeff said. "Lucas, I wanna make this a long night, so you can come too. I'm gonna need you to be my fluffer."
The girls laughed, and I smiled and agreed eagerly, "Okay, thanks, Jeff."
Just then, the door to the diner opened and in walked our old teacher, Mr. Davis, wearing a sweat-stained, tight-fitting t-shirt and running shorts. It looked like he had just gone on a run. "Oh my god, guys, look who's here," I said. Emily and Jeff turned around to see Mr. Davis walking to a seat at the counter.
"Oh my god, he's sooooo hot," Jenny said. "Umm, look at his..."
None of us needed her to finish her sentence. Mr. Davis's shorts barely contained a huge bulge. It was clear he was not wearing any underwear, as we could all see his huge dick just flopping around freely as he walked to his seat. "Oh, wow," Emily said, staring. Then she nudged Jeff with a smile. "Looks like you might have some competition, baby."
Jeff just laughed. "You two are such size queens," he said. Then he looked at me. "Getting a good look, Lucas?"
I felt myself blushing and just smiled sheepishly, biting my lower lip.
"Hmmm," Jenny said thoughtfully. "Maybe we could make our threesome into a...foursome?" I clearly wasn't even being included in her headcount.
Jeff grinned, glanced back over at Mr. Davis, then looked at Jenny and shrugged. "Fine with me. You two sluts are a lot to handle by myself anyway, and this little wimp sure isn't able to help me out," Jeff said. "If you can convince him to join us, I don't mind sharing."
Jenny smiled mischievously, clearly up to the challenge. She scooted out of the booth we were sitting in, and we watched her walk over to Mr. Davis at the counter, her round little butt swaying back and forth in a pair of cut-off denim shorts. We couldn't make out what she was saying, but Mr. Davis's face lit up with surprise when he saw her, and he made no attempt to hide that he was looking her body up and down. She quickly moved in for a hug, and I saw Mr. Davis's strong arms bring her in for a tight squeeze against his muscular body. Even when they separated, he kept a hand on her bare waist, lightly rubbing her skin with his fingers.
We continued to watch as Jenny giggled at something Mr. Davis said and put a hand on his chest. Then Jenny pointed over at our booth in the corner, and he waved at the three of us. We all waved back. Jenny took his hand and started pulling him out of his seat to bring him over to us. He didn't seem very reluctant to follow.
"Shit, he's actually coming over," Jeff said.
When he got to our table, I couldn't help but notice that his shorts were ever-so-slightly beginning to tent up. I saw Emily and Jenny staring as well.
"Hey, guys," Mr. Davis said confidently. "Good to see you all again."
"You too, Mr. Davis," Emily said, still staring at his crotch. "Um, why don't you sit down with us? Lucas can squeeze in, can't you, Lucas?"
"Um, yeah, sure," I said compliantly, scooting against the wall to make room for Mr. Davis and Jenny. As Mr. Davis squeezed in, I felt his warm, sweaty body pressing against me. He casually put an arm around Jenny.
Mr. Davis was probably in his late 40s or early 50s, but he clearly stayed extremely fit. He had dark, salt-and-pepper hair and had grown out a thick layer of stubble in the week since school had ended. "You all having a good summer so far?" he asked. "I'm sure you've been enjoying yourself with these two beautiful young women around, Jeff."
Jeff laughed. "Oh, for sure, Mr. Davis," he said, "we've been having a lot of fun together."
He turned to me. "How about you, Lucas? I'll be honest, I've overheard some of the gossip around the school before graduation."
"You...you have?" I asked shyly.
"Teachers hear it all," Mr. Davis said. "Sounds like you're lucky to have a best friend who finds a way to keep you included."
I didn't know what to say at first. I just blushed, looked down, and nodded. I heard Emily and Jenny both giggling.
Mr. Davis chuckled a little bit too. "Jeff here knows how to keep a boy like you in his place, doesn't he?"
The girls gasped a little. Again, I didn't know what to say. I glanced over at Jeff, who was grinning. "Well? Answer the man," Jeff told me.
I turned back to my former teacher. "Um, yes, Mr. Davis," I said softly.
Mr. Davis laughed. "And you girls?" he asked Jenny and Emily. "You two been enjoying yourselves?"
"Mmm, yes, very much," Emily said, putting a hand on Jeff's chest and leaning closer to him.
"Definitely, Mr. Davis," Jenny said. "Although, Jeff was just saying that the two of us are a lot for him to handle by himself, and, well, Lucas obviously isn't much help."
"Hmm, is that right?" Mr. Davis asked, pulling Jenny closer to him.
"Yes," Emily said sexily. "And, um, Jeff was just inviting us over to his place for a little get-together, so...maybe you'd like to come too?"
He laughed again. "Ya know, you high school grads find a way to hit on me every summer."
"They do?" Emily asked.
"Summer's my favorite time of year," he said with a grin. "Fresh 18-year-old girls who are no longer my students, throwing themselves at the teacher they had a crush on the whole year? Always a good time."
"Wow," Jenny said, a little amazed at his swagger.
"We'd love it if you could join us, Mr. Davis," Emily said, rubbing a hand up and down Jeff's muscular chest. "You're right...Jenny and I have always had a crush on you."