Jens Natural Sperm Donor

Author's Note: This fictional work contains fetish themes that may be off-putting to some readers. If male-male contact, creampie eating, humilation, etc. aren't your thing, please use the back button in your browser rather than down-voting my story. I appreciate your time and hope you enjoy it.

Thanks to CaptionDaddy for his input during the character development stage.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Matthew and Jennifer sat anxiously in front of their laptop computer, listening to their fertility specialist counsel them on the results of their testing via video conference. They'd been trying their best to get pregnant for over a year and a half with no luck. Jen, especially, had spent countless hours online trying to find techniques to improve their chances of conceiving before they consulted Dr. Stephens. Although they feared the results, anything would be better than not knowing.

"So, guys, I've got good news and not-so-good news for you," the doctor began.

Jen was squeezing all the blood out of her husband's hand, waiting for the hammer to drop.

"The good news is that we couldn't find any obvious reason you can't get pregnant, Jennifer. That doesn't rule out every possible barrier, but we didn't find any problems within the scope of our tests, including the ultrasound examination."

Jen exhaled in relief, but wondered what the bad news could be. She had learned about one in five women have problems conceiving, so she had assumed she was the problem.

"Matthew, I don't ever like telling anyone this, but your fertility tests did reveal a problem. I'm very sorry to have to tell you, but our tests show you fall into the category of 'sterile'. You've heard of low sperm count, but our tests showed no viable sperm present. We can do more precise imaging and blood tests to make sure there's not a less obvious reason for this result, but our ultrasound didn't show any abnormal physiology or signs of disease."

The couple was devastated. Jen tried not to lose her composure, but she couldn't help but cry. Matt could never bear to see the love of his life this sad, so he couldn't hold back his tears either.

"I know this is very hard news to handle, but I want you to know there are still options for you to become pregnant, Jennifer. Please don't give up hope. Take all the time you need to digest this information, but please set up another video session with me if you want to discuss additional testing for Matthew and/or other ways to conceive."

"Thank you, Dr. Stephens," responded Matt, as Jen was in no state to speak.

As soon as the video chat ended, Jen ran to their bedroom, crying uncontrollably. Even though it was out of his control, Matt couldn't help but feel deeply guilty. Of all people, how could he be the one to crush one of her biggest dreams. He held her as she cried, but didn't know what to say except, "I'm so sorry." She knew she had to work hard not to cast blame on her husband. He was a good man, and she knew this wasn't his fault.

Over the next few days, the shock wore off and their despair somewhat turned to hope as they educated themselves on other options. They learned that if Matt was indeed sterile, a sperm donor would be required. They even read about how donors are screened by the clinic, how they are chosen anonymously by the recipient and the process of artificial insemination.

Although the procedure was less expensive than in-vitro fertilization, it could still become very expensive if it took several attempts to achieve pregnancy. At this point in their lives, they were both saddled with sizable student loan debt to pay off and had hoped to purchase their own home in a few years. This could easily put them farther in debt than they were comfortable with.

Once they lined up all their questions and were ready to discuss it further, they decided to meet with Dr. Stephens in person.

The more in-depth they discussed the artificial insemination process using frozen sperm from someone they'd never met, the more negative Jen became. She imagined herself as a cow in a head-catch, being bred by a cattle rancher with high-dollar bull semen before being zapped out into the corral with an electric cattle prod until repeating it the next month. It felt cold and inhuman. Matt didn't completely agree, but felt her opinion far outweighed his on this matter.

When the doctor asked what questions or concerns they had, Jen spoke first.

"Doctor, I'm concerned about the cost, but am I the only one who feels this process is very cold and impersonal? I know we don't really have other options, but this just isn't the way I dreamed about our child being conceived."

"So, the simpler issue is the cost. It's mostly dependent on how many attempts it takes to be successful. The best-case scenario is that you conceive on the first attempt, which would keep the total cost around twenty thousand. The more inseminations required, the higher the cost. It would be up to you guys as to how many times you'd want to try if we weren't successful," Dr. Stephens explained. "I've never had anyone spend more than about forty thousand trying."

The couple tried to play it cool upon hearing the cost, but neither had great poker faces. Although they both had decent jobs, Jen would be out of work for at least a few weeks after the delivery and they certainly didn't have that kind of cash saved. They had health insurance, but it didn't cover any portion of these costs beyond their diagnostic tests.

The doctor continued, "And no, you're certainly not the only one who isn't a fan of the process. We actually recommend our patients meet with a mental health counselor before the procedure because of those and many other emotional and ethical concerns. It's not something you should take lightly."

Jennifer continued, "But you're saying that's really our only option if I want to be pregnant, aren't you?"

Dr. Stephens paused momentarily before adding, "Well, it's not the only option, but very few patients opt for the alternative because of the complicated emotional aspects."

The couple looked at her, obviously not sure what she was talking about.

"On a few occasions, I've had clients choose 'natural' insemination by a sperm donor. Two couples chose a brother of the husband, while one turned to a close friend. I'm not saying I recommend it to married couples, but I'd be remiss if I didn't remind you it's an option. We could still provide the same genetic and health screening we use for our anonymous donors if you were to choose that route."

The couple was stunned the doctor said the quiet part out loud. Both of them had secretly thought about it, but didn't dare bring it up to the other.

They almost pretended it wasn't discussed for the remainder of the appointment, but later that night, Matt decided to bring it up.

"Baby, are you willing to talk about the other option Dr. Stephens mentioned, or is that completely off the table for you?" Matt asked hesitantly.

Jen had been thinking about how to respond to this all afternoon in case he asked. She doubted he would. Most men would've probably responded with a definitive "hell no" to any proposal like this, but he wasn't like most men. It was one reason she fell in love with him. He was understanding, logical and rarely put himself first.

"Well, Matt, there are some things I like about the idea and others I don't. It obviously addresses all my issues about artificial insemination we talked about, but I honestly don't know if I could have sex with another man and not feel guilty for the rest of our marriage. I also think I'm like most women in that we have trouble separating sex from the emotions involved. I don't think I'd develop feelings for someone else, but what if I did? And what if you gave me your blessing, then started to resent me after it happened? I couldn't undo it and it would crush me to hurt you."

Matt thought a bit before responding, "I don't think it would be easy for either of us to deal with the emotional aspects, but at this point, I feel like I can't be the barrier to you getting pregnant anymore. If you're really against artificial insemination, then I'll figure out how to deal with my insecurities. I think we need some time to work through the issues before deciding, but I promise you, if I get to the point I give you my blessing, I will never resent you for going through with it. Just promise me you're not considering this because it's a lot cheaper. We can figure out a way to pay for it."

"No, Babe. I wouldn't make this kind of decision just to save money," she responded without hesitation. "But we already have pretty big college loans to pay off and I don't want to get buried in more debt at this point in our lives. I don't like the artificial insemination process, but if that's the route we choose, I think we need to build our savings for a few years before we even consider that."

"Or we could go the natural route and save that money for our child's college expenses or a house with a yard," Matt added. "Whether it's now or in a few years, why would we spend tens of thousands on a procedure you don't really want? And there's no guarantee it would even be successful."

"I know, Babe. I'm just not sure you could handle this either. I can't imagine being okay with it if I were in your position."

Over the next week, Jen and Matt talked about the subject several times. At no time did either of them come up with a reason to rule it out, so in the end, they agreed to give it a try.

At the end of their last discussion, Jen had to ask one last time, "Okay, Babe, once and for all...are you sure you're okay with trying this?"

"Yes. I'm sure...as long as he's not super hot and hung like a horse," Matt joked.

"But Babe...don't you want our child to be beautiful? And if it were a boy, well...you know," Jen pouted, only half-jokingly.

Over the next couple of weeks, they talked about the practical difficulty of finding a suitable donor. Matthew was an only son, so a sibling wasn't an option. Neither of them really wanted their families to know the details anyway. They were also reluctant to ask an ex-boyfriend since it seemed too likely to cause emotional drama or gossip.

Jen had a well-connected friend who she could always trust to be discrete, so she suggested to Matt, "I could talk to Laura and see if she can think of any good candidates."

Matt also knew Laura. He knew she and Jen had been friends since junior high and even attended college together. Their personalities were so similar, they could practically read each other's mind. People often mistook them for sisters. Even their taste in men was similar, both preferring thoughtful, intelligent guys over ones who only got by on their looks. They both met their future husbands within a few months of each other and were married the same year.

Their paths began to diverge soon after marriage, however. Jen's relationship with Matt blossomed while Laura's started going downhill within the first two years. Before her third anniversary, Laura was a single woman again. Admittedly, she went a little wild after her divorce was finalized. Like Jen, she wasn't sexually experienced before getting married, and after years of being all but ignored by her husband, she desperately wanted to be desired.

Laura wasn't looking for another husband, but just wanted to feel wanted. She even ventured outside her "type" and went out with a few guys mostly for their looks. Intellectually, they bored her, but she learned to appreciate the ones who were muscular, good-looking and well hung for how much they turned her on sexually.

Since she and Jen remained close, Laura enjoyed sharing her exploits with her bestie. Jen was surprised by her friend's change of behavior post-divorce, but she understood. Jen often wondered what she might have missed out on by marrying Matt after dating only a couple of other guys, so she enjoyed living vicariously through Laura. She would've never cheated on Matt, but it didn't keep her from fantasizing about it from time to time.

Laura confessed she'd become a bit of a "size queen" after her divorce, a term Jen had never even heard of. Having only slept with two men before Matt, both of whom were on the small side like him, she had no frame of reference to appreciate her friend's stories. She always believed the saying that "size doesn't matter."

When Jen was able to talk with Laura in person, she decided not to beat around the bush and let her know everything she and Matt had discussed. In typical Laura fashion, she was crude and direct.

"Girl! Are you serious? Matt actually agreed to this?"

"Yes, he really did. He feels terrible and just wants me to be happy."

"So, does 'happy' just mean getting pregnant, or are you allowed to be happy with how you get pregnant? Like, do you get to enjoy getting fucked... a lot?"

"Jeez, Laura! That's not what this is about!"

"Obviously, but does Matt require you get pregnant from bad, boring sex to be okay with it? And does it have to be just once or twice?"

Jen admitted, "Well, no. He didn't imply I had to hate it, but we didn't specifically talk about that. I don't want to hurt him though."

"How would it hurt him? He's not going to be watching, is he?"

"No, Laura! He's not going to be watching. That would be super weird."

"Well then, you might as well get your world rocked while you have a free ticket to Poundtown right?"

Jen just rolled her eyes at her friend, not really understanding where this was all coming from.

"But anyway, Laura, I didn't come over here just to tell you about this. I actually need your help. We don't really want to use a guy I dated before or knows our families. We wondered if maybe you could suggest a good candidate."

"Oh, wow. I love matchmaking, but this one is definitely unique," Laura replied with obvious surprise followed by a devious grin.

Although she acted like she was weighing the pros and cons of several different guys, she actually knew within seconds who she was going to recommend. She'd gone out with a guy named Cody several times a few months earlier, and she knew he'd be the perfect guy to bring out Jen's repressed inner slut. She probably wouldn't have recommended him to friends looking for a long-term relationship, but he seemed perfect for this scenario. He was great-looking and an absolute stud. What else was needed?

The main reason she hadn't gone out with him lately was that even though the sex was amazing, he seemed to want it constantly. It was just a lot to deal with. He also seemed to be a lot more into the Dom/sub thing than she was, so it got a little awkward at times. She assumed this wouldn't be an issue if Jen just wanted to get pregnant and move on.

Laura showed her friend a few photos of Cody and told her a bit about him. He was about ten years older, never married and had a good job as a general contractor. She chose not to tell Jen how well hung he was or why she didn't date him anymore, thinking she should find that out on her own. She didn't want to scare her unnecessarily, and maybe it would be exactly the contrast with Matt she needed. The only problem she foresaw with Cody was whether his sexual appetite would be too much for Jen to deal with, or even Matt.

Laura was delighted Jen didn't ask how Cody was in bed, so it would be a surprise. If this all worked out, she couldn't wait to hear the feedback after their first "date." She vividly remembered her shock the first time they made out and she felt his unbelievably large cock. He was at least nine, probably ten inches long, but his girth was truly shocking. This was going to be awesome!

When Cody got a call from Laura, he was understandably shocked when he found out what she was proposing. Once she sent him photos of Jen, he was immediately interested. He found her quite attractive, and the prospect of impregnating another man's wife was admittedly a turn-on. They talked about the details a little, but she told him he'd need to talk to Jen directly to get all his questions answered.

When Jen sat down with Matt later that evening and showed him Laura's recommendation for a "donor", his reaction wasn't quite as positive as Cody's. It wasn't anything he specific he didn't like about Cody, it was just becoming a bit too real now that their potential donor had a name, a handsome face and a real cock to pound his wife. And God only knew how many times they'd have to have sex before she conceived. Why did he have to be so damned good looking?

On the positive side, the baby would have a good chance of being quite attractive.

Jen and Cody spoke on the phone for about twenty minutes to discuss the possible arrangement. They hit it off pretty well and didn't uncover any show-stoppers. Matt had no logical reason to veto her choice either, so everyone pressed forward with the plan.

It took about three weeks for Cody's health and genetic screening and family medical history to be completed, and luckily there were no red flags. In the meantime, they'd been texting and occasionally talking on the phone, but hadn't met in person. It made Jen a little uncomfortable that Cody seemed very flirtatious in most of their conversations, but it was hard to fault him for it. He was single and being offered no-strings-attached sex with a married woman. She knew it was probably harmless, but the flirting seemed as much like cheating to her as the actual sex act she and Matt had agreed to.

Laura invited Jen, Matt and Cody over to her apartment to meet each other as soon as she found out his screening was complete. Although the prospect of seeing him in person was exciting, Jen was extremely nervous. Would he really find her attractive in person or would the screening just be a waste? Matt was probably twice as nervous and embarrassed as his wife. Agreeing to the arrangement in private was one thing, but this felt somewhat like pimping her out.

When they were finally in the same room together, they both found the other very physically attractive. She had Cody's idea of the perfect female body: Short, curvy but not fat, large breasts and a cute face. He thought she was even more gorgeous than her photos, and just hugging her got him a little aroused.

Of course, Jen tried to downplay how hot she thought Cody seemed out of respect for her husband. She was also impressed by his personality as he seemed very at ease talking about any subject and seemed to be a good listener. She also liked his confident, yet not cocky, demeanor. Jen wanted to get used to calming her nerves without using alcohol, so she was thankful he was so easy to talk to. Maybe this wouldn't be as awkward as she had dreaded.

The only thing awkward for both of them was Matt's presence. Cody tried to engage Matt in conversation a few times, not because he really cared to get to know him, but because he knew Matt's approval would make it easier to do whatever he wanted with his wife.

Cody's initial impression of Matt was that he married up. Jen was definitely out of his league in the looks department and he seemed to be the non-athletic, beta type.

Cody understood why Matt had come, but wished he hadn't. He wondered how far he could've gotten with her if she were alone. Laura had told him she was sexually inexperienced, but he enjoyed a challenge. He would enjoy teaching her anything she needed to know.

Matt noticed Cody checking out his wife's body several times, but couldn't blame him. He knew her natural D-cup breasts and perfectly shaped ass would turn on any man. He also couldn't help but notice the contrast in their sizes, as Cody was nearly a foot taller than Jen. He was also very tan, likely from working outdoors, and was quite well built, both things he knew were turn-ons for his wife. He couldn't help but feel a little jealous over how attractive a couple they made.