And that was when she gave me a look that electrified me. It was a look of discovery, surprise and decision all rolled into one, and I didn’t know whether it was all over between us or whether we were just beginning . . . .
Sarah and I had been going out for just over a month when it happened. We’d met at a bar when she was there with a group of other women and I was there with a couple of friends. John knew one of the other women and we sat down at the table next to theirs. Sarah was the one with the dimples and the short, wavy hair. Very petite, but her lips were full and a smile hovered about her eyes. I wasn’t even sitting next to her, but I liked the way she made sure everybody knew each others’ names and cracked some jokes that put us all at ease. She was so cute that I’d have put up with any personality, but she seemed full of fun and I was completely taken with her.
Nothing happened that night, but the women left a little early and on their way out I was able to ask for her last name and where she lived, and she seemed quite happy for me to know. We went out twice in the next week, and after the third time she invited me in when I took her home. She was very affectionate and when we’d been kissing for a while her breath got a very sexy smell to it. That’s when I thought I could start unbuttoning her shirt and she’d be ready to have my hand caress her breasts. I was wrong, though, and that night I never did get her top off. But while she made it clear that her breasts were off limits, she didn’t show any desire to stop kissing, and she hugged me very tight and seemed completely turned on.
Eventually, I tried putting my hand on her backside and she didn’t mind that. Then I pulled her to me by pressing on the back of her leg and she let it slip up over my lap. I thought she must be able to feel my hardness against her thigh, but she didn’t pull back, and she didn’t seem to mind when I moved around a little. She also didn’t seem to mind when my hand moved back up toward her ass. It was curled around her leg, so pretty soon I was teasing very close to her pussy and she was giving every sign of getting more and more turned on.
When I was just beginning to worry that I would lose something in my pants, she put her hand down there where her leg had been. At the same time, she rolled back and a little away, so that I could no longer reach all the way around her and my hand moved toward her front side. She didn’t stop moving until her legs were apart and the way she’d moved left my hand just about on top of her pussy. We still had our pants on and she was moving her hand on my erection. I returned the favor, and she accepted my pressure between her legs with a deeply satisfying moan.
“Sarah,” I whispered, “I can’t take too much more of this. Will you take me out?” My answer was her hand undoing my belt and tugging at my zipper. I stopped caressing her long enough to help free my throbbing penis, and then felt her hand stroking lightly on its tender surface. I reached over to her side, opened her zipper and slid my hand down under her panties. I felt her bush and fingered my way down to her clitoris. It was a little dry, so I went further until I felt her wetness, and then a little further still. She was flowing copiously and I spread her juices up and down her cleft until her clitoral button felt silky smooth under my fingers. As her excitement mounted, I settled into a rhythm that matched the pace of her squirming.
When she came, she stopped stroking me as if her whole self had disappeared into the warmth of her own feeling. But as soon as she had calmed down, she looked up at me with the most endearing smile of grateful happiness and softly cooed, “Now you.” She pulled gently down on my erection, let her fingers caress my balls, and then moved back up to my tip. I too was flowing by now, and as she tugged up and down I became thoroughly lubricated. She gradually increased her pace, but always seemed just a little slower than I wanted. When I was about to come, she slowed down ever so little for a while and then gradually increased her stroking again. Just when I thought I could stand it no longer, my member seemed to take over and swell up even more all by itself. This time, Sarah kept her pace, and I delivered my fluid over the dainty hand that still caressed it.
Two weeks later I found out why she had not let me take her top off that night, or for several times afterward. It turned out that she was shy about her tits, thinking that they were too small to be attractive. The truth was that her breasts were not large, but she was very firm and had very hard little nipples. When she finally let me see her fully naked, I discovered that what she did have jutted straight out from her body like two giant Hershey’s kisses. The natural thing to do was to kiss and lick those little mounds, first one and then the other, and everywhere in between, and she loved that, especially when I would swirl my tongue around her nipples.
I soon discovered that she liked having her hairy pussy licked too, and I would regularly get her in a frenzy by burying my face in her snatch and flicking my tongue back and forth over her love button. It would not be long before she would have a little orgasm and then she would push me away so she could start on me. She would always begin by just barely touching my member with the tips of her fingers. She would tease it all the way down to the bottom of my scrotum and then touch her way back up. She seemed to know just when to make her hand tighter and then she would put her little mouth over the head of my member and give it a slow but firm sucking. By that time, we’d both be out of our minds ready and I would slide between her thighs in a mutual humping that left us exhausted.