Dueling Wishes

Previously published on The Overflowing Bra. Edited to comply with Literotica site standards.

All characters in this story in erotic situations are 18 years or older.

Prologue: Before the Wishes

Caleb

Caleb had only one problem in his life: his dick was too big. "The Dragon," as he called it, was 11" long and 2.5" wide, and made dating hell. He'd never had trouble getting dates as he was tall and not ugly. Unfortunately, when things got hot and heavy and he brought out The Dragon, most of his dates refused immediately. One or two let him try to put it inside, but gave up quickly. He learned how to eat a girl out like a champ, but thought he would die a virgin.

That was until he met Paige. He had no idea why she asked him out, as they were polar opposites. She was a cheerleader at their high school and was extremely popular. She had a lot of friends in the sports and cheerleader crowd, while he had a few close friends from the anime club. He just knew that one day she approached him and asked him out. He thought it might have been his height; he was one of the tallest guys in school at 6'4" while she was only 5'. He was skinny and unathletic while she was curvy but toned from cheerleading, with perky B-cup breasts, a tight ass, and firm, muscular thighs. Their contrast sometimes attracted stares. They didn't have much in common, but to his surprise, they still got along. She was bright and cheerful, and listened intently to him talk about his interests. In return, he let her lecture him about cheerleading competitions, and was amazed that she could make it sound interesting.

She also conquered The Dragon. The first time they'd done it, he was terrified that she would reject him like the others. He started by eating her out, which rewarded him with her muscular thighs gripping his head. He could tell when she came in his mouth, which made him harder than he'd ever been. She told him to take his pants off and said to put it in her. He sighed and stripped, expecting instant rejection, like so many times before. Instead her eyes widened and she reached forward and gripped it with dainty fingers that couldn't wrap all the way around it. She tried to suck on it, but couldn't hold it in her mouth for very long before her jaw seized up. "It's huge," she whispered. "How have you fit it in anyone?"

"I haven't," he answered. "It doesn't fit."

She looked at him with her big eyes, gave him a grin, and said "oh, we'll see about that. I'm not a quitter." She positioned her feet on either side of his hips and got in a squatting position. She positioned the head of his member by her opening, which he noticed was glistening.

"Wait!" He said, "you don't have to do this if it's too much."

"But I want to," she replied, and lowered herself. He saw and felt the head disappear. "Oh!" she said, her eyes wide.

"Are you okay?" He asked.

"I'm, uh, fine," she grunted, breathing heavily. "I can do this." She lowered herself, her face contorted. "Let me do this for you," she managed through gritted teeth.

Caleb didn't know if he was more amazed when he entered her, or when she bottomed out on him, gasping. He knew from the way she was breathing and the way her face contorted that she had to be in a lot of pain. He also knew that it felt really good, like nothing he'd ever felt. She lifted up a bit and dropped. He felt her shivering and wondered how long she would be able to keep it up. Fortunately, he didn't last long. He felt it coming and gripped her hips as he exploded inside her. He thought he saw stars.

Paige

Paige only had one problem in her life: her pussy was too big. She knew she was hot. She was a popular cheerleader, 5 feet tall with perky B-cup breasts and tight, muscular ass and thighs. She had plenty of prospects among the athletes, but none of them could get her off. All of them felt to her, to use a crude expression, "like throwing a hot dog down a hallway." She thought she would never get off during sex. She bought the largest dildos she could find and tried to be content.

That was until she heard about Caleb. All the girls would gossip in the locker room, and occasionally the talk would turn to the boys they dated and the sizes of their respective equipment. She knew how big a few guys were and could contribute, but then she heard about a boy at their school with a monster. Supposedly none of the girls he dated could fit it. One of the girls there had tried as a challenge, but quickly gave up, and tried to dissuade the others from trying.

Paige asked him out the next day. She knew him as that tall skinny guy in history class. He wasn't bad looking, and figured it was worth a shot. They got ice cream together and talked. He was awkward and nerdy, but was also polite, courteous, and listened to her. She'd worn a low-cut top and a push-up bra to get him in the mood, but he stubbornly looked her in the eyes. That won him some points.

It took almost two months for her to get him into bed. The night of senior prom, she told her parents she was staying at a friend's house, but got a hotel room just for her and Caleb. He seemed hesitant about going all the way at first, but when he ate her out, she had to bite her lip to keep from screaming. 'Where did he learn to do THAT!?' she wondered to herself. 'Oh, and THAT! And what the FFFFFUUUUUUU......' until her mind went white.

When she came to herself and caught her breath, she said "take those pants off, I want you in me." He complied and there it was, the monster she had heard so much about, all eleven glorious inches. She couldn't even get her hands around it! "It's huge!" she whispered. She needed it. She positioned herself on top of him and stuck it inside. She gasped. It was better than she imagined. He tried to talk her out of it, but she was determined. She slowly lowered herself onto it; she knew if she went any faster she would scream in pleasure (not that her parents would mind, they were out of town, but she was sure the neighbors would hear and call the cops, the damn busybodies).

When she bottomed out, she was certain she would scream if she unclenched her jaw. No one had filled her like this before, and it was a boy she actually liked. Amazingly, it still didn't fill her completely. How deep was she? But it was better than any dick she'd taken before. Still, she wished he were bigger. She felt self-conscious about her huge pussy again. She moved herself up and down, gripping as hard as she could. Although there was still room, it was the best sex she'd ever had. She orgasmed several times and had to scrunch up her face to keep quiet. Finally, she heard him gasp and shudder and explode inside of her. She crawled up his body and felt his softening member pull out of her before plopping on his belly.

"Thank you," he gasped.

She smiled and kissed him on the lips before curling up next to him, her head on his chest. She knew she should go to the bathroom and clean up, but she wanted to enjoy this for a moment. Just a moment. Just a...

The Wish

In the morning, after a shared shower (and a generous tip for the maid), they went to the mall. Both were glowing and grinning ear to ear. They looked around the various shops, and after visiting the ones they already knew, found one they didn't know. It was an antique shop of some kind, full of old artifacts of brass, iron, and glass.

"How new is this shop?" Paige asked. "I don't think I've seen it before."

"Me either," Caleb replied. "I don't think I saw it when I picked up Smash Bros from GameStop yesterday."

She gripped his hand harder. "Caleb," she whispered, "do you think this could be one of those wandering shops?"

"The magic ones? Seems unlikely."

"But what if it is? How cool would that be?"

"Can I help you?" asked the man behind the counter, whom they had not seen before. He had a vaguely Eastern-European accent that neither of them could place.

Paige gave a small, startled yelp.

"Just looking," answered Caleb. He looked down at Paige, her huge eyes looking back up at him. He felt the same butterflies he felt every time she looked at him. 'Well, it's worth a try,' he thought. "Actually, do you have any recommendations?"

The little old man smiled. "Very wise, to ask for help. I get a lot of people in here who don't know what they want, but insist they do. It never works out for them." He gazed at them, adjusting his spectacles. "Let me see, you two seem very close to each other, I can see this going well." The two blushed and looked away from each other, but kept holding hands. "But there is an insecurity. There's something about you that you hate, and everything would be perfect if that one thing were fixed."

"How did you know?" both Caleb and Paige asked in unison.

The old man chuckled. He came around the counter and started hunting among the shelves. "I've been serving customers longer than both of you have been alive, and I know how to read people." He pulled a brass goblet off the shelf. Caleb thought it looked like the Holy Grail from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade. "I don't have anything to change one's self at the moment, but I can see the way you feel about each other, and if you trust each other, this can solve your problem." He poured some wood shavings into the goblet, then reached under the table and pulled out a small, flat box. He opened the box and pulled out two quill pens, an inkwell, and a small piece of what looked like yellowed paper. "Drat," he said, "I thought I had more of the sacred papyrus. Well, I don't think you'll need to change too much."

He cut the papyrus in half with a pair of scissors and put a piece in front of each of them. Each piece was about the size of a business card. "Each of you take a quill and write what you would change about the other. Don't tell each other, and then put the papyrus in the chalice. You need not worry; the spell will make any changes necessary to ensure your health and comfort."

Caleb and Paige looked at each other. "Do you trust me?" Caleb asked.

Paige stretched her hand up and cupped his cheek. "You've never given me a reason not to," she said. "Do you trust me?"

"After last night, I do." He nodded his head. "Let's do this." They each grabbed a quill.

Caleb thought hard. He just wanted a smaller dick. How could he change Paige to fix that? Were there any changes she would even want? It occurred to him that if she were taller, his dick could fit in her perfectly. She often complained about reaching stuff on high shelves. "Paige will grow taller until I'm satisfied that she's comfortable with my penis in her." There was still room. Maybe one for himself? "Paige's breasts will grow bigger and more sensitive until I can tit-fuck her." She didn't seem to feel anything when he sucked on her. She'd probably enjoy the sensitivity. He placed the papyrus card in the chalice.

Paige thought hard. If only she could shrink her pussy, but she could only change Caleb. But what if he were bigger? "Caleb's reproductive organs" that should cover the balls, too, "will grow bigger until they fit me for maximum pleasure." Guys like having bigger dicks, right? There was still room. Maybe one more for them both? "Caleb will grow strong enough to carry me like a princess without getting tired." She wasn't big, but he was so skinny he couldn't even lift her. Being able to carry her would be romantic and hot. And he'd enjoy the muscles. She placed the card in the chalice.

"All done?" the old man asked. They both nodded. He spoke a few words in a language neither of them had heard before, and dropped a match into the chalice. The wood shavings and papyrus cards burned up quickly.

"One more thing," he said, " the changes are going to happen slowly, and only the writer of the charm will notice any changes made. Everyone else, even the one changing, will believe that things have always been this way. If you choose to tell each other, then you'll notice. Do you understand?" They nodded. "Now, it's a beautiful day, and you lovebirds shouldn't spend it all in a dusty old shop." He shooed them out.

Caleb turned around to say that they hadn't paid, but there was no door, and the shop was gone.

They stood there, stunned. "You were right, that was a wandering shop," Caleb said.

"Yep. Now what?"

"I guess we wait. Do you want to say what you wrote? I'll tell if you do, but I trust you, and while I think you'll like it, it's kind of embarrassing."

"Same here," she said. "Let's just wait and see.

1 Year After the Wishes

Caleb

Caleb had only one problem in his life: his dick was too big. It was about 14 inches long and a little over 3 inches wide. It was bigger soft than most guys were erect! His balls were larger than jumbo chicken eggs! He'd thought he was going to die a virgin until he met his girlfriend, Paige. Somehow, she'd managed to fit him inside of her, despite her obvious pain (she was only five feet tall, after all), and didn't immediately break up with him. The next day, they'd happened upon a wandering shop, and Caleb wished for Paige to grow taller so she could fit him without hurting (and that her boobs would grow). He still hadn't figured out what she'd chosen to change. Other than his dick problem, his life was pretty good. He was a starter on his community college basketball team. Besides his height, he had wiry muscles which he toned for athletics. He also did well academically.

The last year had been especially awesome because he got to see the results of his wish on Paige. True to the shopkeeper's words, the changes happened slowly, and Caleb was the only one who seemed to notice. Every month she added over an inch in height and almost a whole cup size. She continued cheerleading in college, and when she started, she was one of the "flyers," that is the cheerleaders who got tossed in the air, which suited her small size. Half a year in, he noticed that she was talking about being the a "base," one of the cheerleaders who throws the fliers. He asked her if she ever thought of being a flier, and she said no, she was too tall at 5' 7" and, she admitted with a blush, her F-cup boobs were too bouncy for tumbling.

A year after the wish, and she was 6' 2", one of the tallest girls at their college, and almost as tall as Caleb. According to Caleb's new memories, she'd had to quit cheerleading in the middle of high school when her boobs got too big for tumbling. She was now a star on the college volleyball team, despite having J-cups now. He'd have thought the bouncing would be painful, but the wish took care of that, apparently. No one gave the dating volleyball player and the basketball player a second glance, unless they were leering at some of the largest tits they'd ever seen. If Caleb wore tight pants, sometimes they'd leer at him, too.

After a year, he still didn't know why she insisted on sleeping with him. She still looked like she was in pain every time. He also couldn't figure out where his cock was fitting inside of her. When they went at it, his chicken egg sized balls slapped against her while she squirmed and scrunched her face up. Sometimes she even had tears in her eyes. He wished she wouldn't try so hard just to please him, but she insisted it would get better. He wondered how big she would have to get before she was comfortable with his dick. He was twice as long as the next longest guy on the basketball team. Was she going to have to get twice as tall as him? A small part of him wouldn't mind that.

Her boobs were awesome, though. He'd only ever seen larger ones on morbidly obese women. She now seemed to enjoy it when he sucked on them, and the tit jobs were phenomenal.

Paige

Paige had only one problem in her life: her pussy was too big. She'd never been able to cum with a guy in her until she met Caleb, and even then, he was looser than she'd prefer. It was exciting, watching him grow from 11" to 14" over the past year. It was longer than her forearm now! And those balls! She felt like it took her an hour to drip out their load. Still, she felt like it just wasn't big enough. How much space was inside of her? That would be filled in time. For now, he was still good enough at sucking on her pussy and nipples with his mouth to make her have to bite her lip not to scream. She wished she didn't cry sometimes while cumming. That was super embarrassing!

She'd also enjoyed watching him bulk up. He used to be a skinny anime geek, and while he was still trim, over the last year she'd seen him grow corded muscles that, as far as he knew, he'd always had. He was finally strong enough to pick her up and carry her, and her favorite sex position was him holding her up against the wall while they did it.

She sometimes wondered what Caleb had wished for her. Probably the boobs. They were statistically unlikely to be natural. The only problem she had with them was having to get her bras custom made. At least she didn't suffer any back pain from them, and they felt really good when Caleb sucked on them.

2 Years After the Wishes

Caleb

Caleb had just one problem in his life: his dick was too big. It was over 17 inches long, almost a foot and a half, and almost 4 inches wide. The head was larger than a baseball and stuck out just past his knees! It was over 8 inches when flaccid, bigger than anyone else on the football team. His balls were the size of the apples he always looked like he was smuggling in his pants, and he'd had several extremely embarrassing encounters with store security who thought he was shoplifting. Sometimes he felt like every loss prevention agent across the whole state knew how big his junk was. He couldn't even masturbate properly with how huge it was.

But that was his only real problem. His life was pretty sweet. His muscles, which seemed to grow naturally, had earned him a football scholarship to a state university as a running back. In the two years since they'd made that wish in the wandering shop, he'd watched Paige grow from a tiny five feet tall, to a towering 7-foot-4-inches. She was now the tallest living woman in the world. Sometimes people who were shorter than him called him "shorty" when he walked with her. He didn't mind. Secretly, he'd had a giantess fetish ever since he realized that no normal woman would be able to fit him. He'd seen porn online, almost always drawn, of huge women getting satisfied by guys with enormous dicks. He'd wished that could happen to him. She still looked in pain when they had sex, so he thought she still had growing to do, and the thought excited him.

With her height, Paige could have received a basketball scholarship to any university in the country, but she chose to stay stateside with him. She was mesmerizing to watch run up and down the court, her boobs now the size of basketballs themselves. Even if they didn't hurt her, he wondered how they didn't get in the way. Though she often seemed to just stand by the basket and wait for a team mate to throw it to her so she could dunk it.

She wouldn't be playing any more this season, though. Turns out, they don't make condoms for 17 inch dicks, and calculating birth control dosages for the tallest woman in the world was harder than they thought. She was now 6 months pregnant with twins, which according to ultrasounds were taking after their mother in size. Her boobs had swelled even bigger in anticipation. She told Caleb she had passed out of the alphabet sizes. They were perfect to him. Each was as large as her pregnant belly, and more sensitive than ever. Just sucking milk out of them was enough to bring her to orgasm. While there wasn't enough room in her pussy for normal sex, she seemed to enjoy giving him boobjobs.

Paige

Paige had just one problem in her life. Her, well, everything was too big. She was too tall, her boobs were competing with her pregnant belly for size, and next to them all her pussy was the biggest, in comparison. She'd had to have all her clothes custom made since she was a freshman. She was still amazed that Caleb had agreed to go out with her in high school. Even though she had the biggest boobs, most guys didn't want to date a girl taller than them. She was thankful, though, since even novelty horse cock dildos weren't big enough to get her off. He could, though. Not that she could fit one inside of her now, being as pregnant as she was. At least he could still eat her out well enough to make her scream. She wished her mouth were big enough to suck him off, but he seemed to enjoy her boob jobs. She'd always enjoyed them, too, almost as much as normal sex. The pregnancy had swelled her tits big enough to hide his whole cock while she bounced them up and down on him, licking at the baseball sized head until he came hard enough to cover her whole face in his cum.