This is the follow-up to my previous story of the same name.
"Guys...??"
Jack and Dina froze. The doorknob jiggled, thankfully it was locked. They thought.
After fucking Dina so deep that she needed to poop out his cum and her three-day long turds, Jack also covered his sister-in-law's pretty, Hollywood-hoping face with another thick load of his cum. He was sweaty and now frantic.
"What are you doing in there?" It was Heather, Jack's wife. She pushed on the door and, *pop*. It opened.
Standing in the doorway, this is what Heather saw: Crouching on the toilet seat, like a festival girl on day three of Lollapalooza shitting outside, was her older sister. On her older sister's face was a thick smattering of cum. The cum was that of Heather's husband, Jack, whose hard cock is still throbbing from ejaculating not only all over her sister's face, but it also, she could see, was leaking from her sister's now poop-dirty butthole. In the toilet, Heather could barely see the thick semen strands because her sister's thick turds were obscuring it. The smell overtook her. She stared at her husband and pushed him away from the sink so she could vomit. Hard.
Jack wavered between getting dressed or helping his wife. When he approached her, still naked, she yelled, "Get the fuck away...." and proceeded retching. His cock was lightly brown and he quickly pulled his boxers on and shirt, then pants. Then went to hug his wife.
Dina, who seemed sort of in a daze, hopped off the toilet and stood as she wiped her anus clean. Jack watched, then scolded himself for looking. Dina flushed the toilet and looked at her sister, heaving. The smell lingered as Dina picked up her clothes and gave Jack and Heather space in the small bathroom.
In the mirror, much the same way Jack had just unloaded his balls in his wife's sister's bowels, he looks at his wife in her eyes. The smell of her puke covering up her sister's poop, she growled, crying. "How could you?"
"Heather," he said, stroking his wife's hair. "I don't know. I don't know what happened. Or why. I am so sorry. It is not about the sex. I love you. I love you." he repeated the last part over and over.
"Then what was it?" she grunted, deep in her belly. "Oh my god, did you watch her....poop?" Heather vomited again.
"Just," Jack said, "listen to me. Please?"
"What?"
"I can try to explain."
And he tried. And then the sun came up and there were more tears.
And then, five weeks later, Jack looked around the house he had bought with his wife for the last time and climbed into the moving van, heading for the opposite part of the country, away from the life he'd ruined for letting his cock lead him so far astray.
He and Heather texted off an on for the better part of the next year, but only administrative stuff and the occasional birthday wish. Heather kept telling Jack that she hasn't, nor will she ever, speak to her sister again. Jack, to his bleak credit, said nothing back.
Heather was set to be remarried the following year and didn't invite her sister, Dina, and that is when things got interesting for Jack. Again.
A text: *Hey. It's Dina. Remember me?*
Jack waited a day to respond. Then said, *I do.*
Dina: *Haha. So you know about Heather's wedding? The 'I do' seems too perfect.*
Jack: *I had no idea. Good for her. You going?*
Dina: *Hell no. After nearly three years she still won't say a word to me."
Jack: *Go figure*
Dina: *Heard you're in Boston now.*