Creampie Discovery

Author's Note - Jeff and I are still together, so I let him read this and add a few notes of his own. His notes are in italics. I think his perspective adds to the story.

*

My first lover, Mark, loved to lick my pussy after he fucked me so that he could lick his cum as it dripped from my vagina. I was a very naïve eighteen year old at the time I gave my virginity to him and so I assumed that it was pretty normal when Mark would go down on me and lick me clean after he fucked me. In the course of our short and somewhat tumultuous year together I picked up a bit of a cum obsession from being with Mark. He always talked dirty about filling my pussy with cum just before he would climax and soon I loved the feeling of a hard cock throbbing inside me and I always pictured a big load of semen being squirted against my cervix. If I gave Mark a blowjob, he would always bring it up the next time we were having sex and he would ask me to describe taking his cum in my mouth and swallowing it.

While the sex was great, Mark and I had other problems and we certainly were not helped by trying to sustain a long distance relationship as we were both studying at different colleges our freshman year. By spring of my first year away at school we broke up. I had a couple wild sexual adventures that spring and summer (I'm not getting into those right here, see my other stories), but no steady boyfriends until the next fall. In the fall of my second year at school I met Jeff in a science class with a lab. Jeff and I were assigned as lab partners, which suited me fine as he was very cute, very smart and quite funny. He had light brown wavy hair that was thick and he wore glasses over striking green eyes. I decided to seduce him before we even finished the first lab.

I had Jeff over to my apartment bedroom one afternoon to write up our lab report together. Instead of getting our work done, Jeff wound up fucking me which was exactly what I had in mind. Soon we were exclusive and for the next couple months we enjoyed frequent sex that was very good if a bit vanilla. What triggered this story was what happened the first time I decided to give Jeff a blowjob.

You would think that a girl who likes semen as much as me would have sucked off a new boyfriend sooner. While I do find it very erotic to take a load in my mouth, I also find giving head to be a pain in the jaw. So oral is one of those things I do every now and then and not all the time. In any case, after a couple months with Jeff I was in the mood to suck him off one night as we were in my bed making out. I slipped down his body and started licking all around his shaft. Soon I had him in my mouth, taking him for long slow strokes into my throat. Jeff was alternately moaning, running his fingers through my hair and thrusting his cock up into my mouth. Finally with a groan he erupted, shooting several large pulses of thick cum into my mouth. His semen was salty and thick, and it tasted good to me as I swallowed it. I was very horny as I slid back up along his body. I went to give Jeff a kiss and as I moved in he suddenly turned his head away from me. Abruptly and irrationally I was pissed. I know that just because I like cum in my mouth does not mean that it makes sense for my lover to like it as well. Nevertheless, I could not help feeling insulted that he would let me suck him off but was then too grossed out to kiss me. I guess I also just wanted him to share my love of semen, and so I started working on a plan to get him to do just that.

I thought it over for the next couple days. I decided that the best thing was to teach Jeff to lick me clean. And the best way to get him to do this was by talking him into a trade of favors.

The next time we were working on a lab report together I started asking Jeff about his fantasies. He was hesitant at first owing to some embarrassment, but I eventually got him to admit to an anal sex fantasy. Jeff was no more experienced than me (in many ways, less experienced) and he had never even discussed much less tried anal sex with his only two previous girlfriends. Sensing my chance I offered him a deal. "If you agree to try out one of my fantasies, I'll do yours for you." I suggested. Naturally, Jeff wanted to know what my fantasy was. "I'd rather keep it a surprise." I told him. I waited in suspense, expecting him to demand more information about my fantasy before agreeing. Apparently the chance to fuck my ass was too tempting, because Jeff agreed to the trade without any more information. "When did you want my ass?" I asked him. It turned out he wanted it right away.

Jeff's comment -- I wasn't so blinded by my lust for anal sex that I was unthinking of what she would demand in return as Nikki seems to suggest. The fact is that I wasn't experienced when I was only nineteen. I simply figured that a girl would probably have some pretty tame fantasies. I expected Nicole would want me to rub her feet or eat whipped cream off her body or some such thing. Little did I know.

I stripped naked right then and there and got on my bed. I spread my legs. "Come lick me" I told Jeff. He stripped naked too and then grasping my hips, he pulled me to the edge of the bed. With my legs dangling over his shoulders Jeff went down and started to lick my pussy. He started by roaming his tongue over and around my outer lips, teasing me without delivering. Finally I grasped his hair and pulled him to my center. He ran his tongue around and around my clit then, which quickly stoked my fires. Before long I was very wet and very aroused. It was time.

I pushed Jeff away and rolled over on the bed. I stood on the floor with my legs spread and bent forward onto the mattress to present my ass to him. I wanted to make this really good for him to increase his sense of obligation. I slid a hand down and started to touch myself. "Fuck me. Fuck my tight ass." I commanded him. I jumped as he applied a cool dollop of lube to my asshole and then I heard him rubbing more on his cock. A moment later I felt the hard knob of the head of his dick press into the center of my ass. I squeezed hard internally as Jeff pushed and I felt his thick cock slide past the first tightness and suddenly start to spread my ass wide. "Ohhhh" I groaned. "Your fat cock feels so big in my ass". Jeff continued to press forward until he had slid his entire length into me and his balls rested against my pussy.

I paused a moment as I got used to his girth, then I nodded and told him it was OK. I rubbed my clit continuously with my fingers as Jeff started to steadily fuck his cock in and out of my ass. "That's it baby. Fuck my ass. I love the way your huge cock is stretching me. I feel so full. I want to feel you cum in my ass." I went on and on, babbling the dirtiest, nastiest things imaginable as Jeff enjoyed his first anal fuck. The tight grip of my butt, the stream of filth coming from my mouth and the novelty of the encounter all combined to ensure this was not going to be a marathon session. I was enjoying the fucking all the same. Jeff's cock really did feel huge in my ass, and the intense sense of fullness was bringing me to an orgasm.

I started to cum after a few minutes, gasping as my climax hit me. "Ohhhhh.....I'm cumming. I'm cumming with your cock in my ass." This pushed Jeff over the edge and he came with a yell. His cock started to throb deep in my ass. "Uhhh. I can feel you cumming. Fill my ass with your cum. Fill me up." I screamed. I mentally pictured his cock spewing gobs of white cum deep inside me as he came. Finally sated, Jeff delicately pulled his softening cock out of me. We lay together on the bed for a long time before Jeff commented on how intense the sex had been. "I'm glad you liked it" I told him. Jeff thought for a few moments and then asked me about what sexual favor I wanted in return. "You'll find out. We'll do it Friday night."

Jeff's comment - When Nicole took my cock in her ass like a seasoned pro and started talking like an experienced phone sex worker as I fucked her ass, I did start to get an inkling that she might be both more experienced and kinkier than me. I was definitely looking forward to Friday with both excitement and trepidation.

That Friday we went out for dinner together and then were back at my apartment pretty early. I was kind of eager to get started and I think Jeff was anticipating learning my secret fantasy too. My roommates were out for the evening which was good. I had fielded a few complaints from them about the noise of our anal sex session escaping my bedroom and it was nice to not have an audience. I told Jeff to wait for me in the living room and I slipped into my bedroom to get ready. I had blown my budget buying this silly outfit of a black satin bustier coupled with a black garter belt and stockings. I wore no panties. I tied some silk scarves to my bedposts and then moved back to the door. "Take off your clothes and then come in here" I called.

Less than a minute later, Jeff entered the room completely naked. His cock was hard and jutted out in front of him. His eyes traced up and down my body, obviously liking the outfit. I gestured to the bed and told him to lie down. Once he did I knelt over him and started to kiss him. As our tongues entwined, I pulled his arms up over his head. I tied his arms to the bed which forced him to stay on his back. "What is this fantasy of yours?" he asked me. I slipped down his body. A moment later I took his cock in my mouth and started to suck him. "I'm liking this fantasy so far" he commented.

I sucked Jeff's cock into my throat over and over as I carefully gauged his breathing. Finally I felt his legs tensing up as he pulled hard on the silk ties and I knew he was at the point of no return. I abruptly stopped sucking him. Jeff's cock bobbed up and down as he panted with his near orgasm. I quickly reviewed what I was about to say. I could not believe how nervous I was to speak my fantasy aloud. I was totally afraid he would freak out. "OK" I said before plunging in. "Here is what I want. I want to get on top of you and ride your cock until you cum and fill my pussy. Then, I am going to get into a sixty-nine with you. I want you to lick me and clean up my pussy. Can you do that?"

Jeff was silent as my heart pounded in my chest. Then he said "Yes, I can do that."

I leaned forward and looked him in the eyes. "You're not freaked out?" I asked.

"No really....it's hot" he assured me.

With that I slipped back down to suck him again. I took him as close as I dared to cumming a second time before I once again stopped and left him gasping for relief.

Jeff's comment. Nicole actually really shocked me when she told me what she wanted. I had never contemplated such an act. I wasn't lying about the idea being arousing. As soon as I heard it the idea did turn me on. I was worried about how I would feel after I had an orgasm though.

Once Jeff's imminent orgasm abated, I knelt over him and placed his cockhead at the entrance to my pussy. I was really aroused by now and it took a lot of willpower to not slam my twat down his length immediately. I had brought Jeff to the brink of orgasm twice because Mark had once taught me that this would increase the size of his load. I also knew that this would have Jeff on a hair trigger and I was not likely to get a very long fuck. This was a sacrifice I was going to have to make. I slowly sat down on Jeff's dick until I rested with his entire length filling my pussy. His fullness felt wonderful stretching my vagina as I rubbed my clit against his pubic bone. Then I started to rock my hips, sliding his cock forward and back inside me as well as in and out.

I closed my eyes and enjoyed the sensations. I let my mind wander and I started to fantasize as I rode Jeff's hardness. I thought about thick semen dripping from my pussy onto his lips and I dreamed of his hard cock shooting loads of cum deep inside me. In a few minutes this dream was about to become a reality. As I had expected, Jeff was aroused beyond belief and ready to cum. He suddenly started thrusting his hips wildly, driving his cock up and into my needy pussy with abandon. He groaned and suddenly was still, his body tense under me with his cock thrust up as far as he could reach. I clearly felt his cock throb heavily in my pussy as he injected me with a massive load of semen. Finally, spent, he collapsed back onto the bed. I held his softening cock inside me as I lay on his body and kissed him.

After a few minutes I decided it was time. I rose up and felt Jeff's soft cock fall out of my vagina. Without a word, I turned around until I was kneeling over his face. I lowered my pussy to his lips. "Lick me....lick me clean." I ordered him. Jeff began to tentatively lick my pussy. I had not had an orgasm, and the licking started to arouse me greatly. I had felt semen running out of me as I had turned around, and I imagined Jeff licking thick cum off my lips. "Harder, harder." I ordered. Jeff obeyed me and soon I was getting close. I sat up straight as his tongue strummed my clit steadily. Sitting upright, I felt more semen running from my wet hole directly onto my boyfriend's tongue. This put me over the top and finally I came with a loud sigh, grinding my pussy against Jeff's chin and lips relentlessly. Sated, I stopped and climbed off. Jeff's mouth and chin were wet and glistening with our combined juices. I kissed him passionately and tasted hot semen on his tongue. The taste renewed my arousal, and I rubbed my body close against his. I felt his cock stiffening against my belly as we kissed. He was recovering in record time, so apparently he found my fantasy to be extremely erotic as well.

Jeff's comment. When Nicole finally sat down on my dick I was ready to have an orgasm. I was aroused beyond belief after she left me hanging twice without letting me cum. Once I was in her, it must have been only a minute before I exploded with one of the biggest orgasms of my life. As soon as I came I started to panic. Nicole's fantasy was suddenly totally repulsive to me. My only hope was that my spunk would stay inside of her for a while, at least long enough for me to recover a little. It's strange because now this memory is a huge turn on for me, but at that moment I was very reluctant. Once Nicole swapped ends I was staring at her pussy inches from my face.

To my horror, thick semen was already pooling right at the mouth of her vagina. I had just a moment to see it start sliding down between her inner lips when she lowered herself to me and ordered me to eat her out. I got control of myself and just started following orders. I licked her clit with a swipe of my tongue and got a mouthful of cum. It was thicker than anything I could think of and it had a faint saltiness. I suddenly realized that cleaning her up was not a problem as I swallowed the first bit. I concentrated on licking her clit to bring her to orgasm. After a few minutes, my repulsion evaporated. Suddenly the salty cum taste of her pussy was turning me on. Nicole sat up straight above me and a lot more semen drained from her. This second load was thinner but tasted the same. I licked it all from her dripping snatch with relish until she came hard against my lips. It was totally hot.

I cuddled with Jeff and slowly stroked his growing erection with a loose grip. I was a little giddy with pleasure and I was still super aroused. My excitement spilled over. "God that was hot!" I exclaimed.

Jeff nodded his agreement. "I was very nervous at first" he told me. "But once I got started, it was incredibly sexy. I loved licking your hot pussy clean." I told him this was certainly something we would try again. In the meantime, I was very horny and stroking a cock that was almost completely hard again. I decided to reward Jeff in a way that I hoped would encourage future performances.

Leaving Jeff still tied to the bed, I got up and walked around the headboard to where it was hard to see me. I grabbed my lube from the nightstand and liberally greased my ass. Then I returned to the bed and knelt over Jeff. His cock was at full mast, so I went with the most direct approach. I grasped Jeff's erection and placed the head at my asshole. Then I simply sat down on him as I clenched my muscles to let him penetrate me. I felt a short pang and then I was stretched open and sliding down his pole. I groaned as I reached bottom with his cock firmly lodged in my butt.

"Ohhhhh.....your cock feels so good in my ass" I told him. Then I started to rub my pussy with my hand as I slowly rose and fell on his cock. I had never tried anal sex on top, but the experience was just fine. I felt the intense fullness I was starting to regard as typical and my arousal built steadily. Ultimately, it took me a long time to cum which surprised me, but it was just as well as Jeff had endless endurance for his second round. Finally I came, groaning in relief while my ass clenched Jeff's cock in spasms. As my orgasm receded, I started to feel some discomfort. Jeff's cock was pretty big, and after filling my ass for some time I was running out of endurance. I looked Jeff in the eyes and started talking again. I told him his cock was huge, that he was filling my ass and I was desperate for his load.

My slutty talk had the desired effect as Jeff started to respond in kind. "Take my cock bitch! Feel my cock stretch your ass. I'm going to fill your ass with cum." It was pretty hot stuff, and in a minute he closed his eyes as his orgasm hit. Jeff simply moaned "I'm cumming" and he started to fill my ass once again. Finally, with both of us satisfied we lay together on the bed. I had achieved more than I'd hoped. We were much more open with each other and we were able to discuss and explore some pretty hot and kinky fantasies. This turned out for the best as we dated another four years and have been married ever since.