We did as we were told and I stripped Jeremy bare as I fell to me knees to let him face fuck me, wrapping my hands around his beautiful round furry ass. Mike made himself comfortable in a chair, and Donna started to undress herself. Donna was around 5'7 with a beautiful hour glass figure. Her hair was in a blonde pixie cut, and her body was decorated in colorful (but tasteful) tattoos.
"Ok, my turn," she said, and instructed Jeremy to lay down. "Ever tasted pussy?" She said, and before he could answer, she got on top of him in a 69 position. "Use your tongue, there that's it" She said, and she went down on his 8 inch cock. I played with his balls while she worked his shaft, and judging by the fact that he didn't lose wood and from the moaning, I was pretty sure he was enjoying himself. Mike was practically salivating in the chair, when he spoke up "I want you to ride him honey!"
"Condoms?" Jeremy was able to speak after she removed her pussy from his face. "Are you clean?" Donna simply asked, which I knew the answer, Jeremy was a nurse and always played safe, and got tested regularly. "Yes, but" he croaked, but Donna chimed in "I am too, don't worry babe," as she lowered herself onto his dick, facing him. I had to admit, it was a sexy sight to see, witnessing my gay friend take pussy for the first time.
"This really is your first time?" Donna asked, moving at a slow rhythm, looking down on him. "Y...yes, man you are so hot!" Jeremy said, and Donna looked like she was blushing. I remained standing by the bed, I assumed for providing moral support of my friend losing his gold star status but also liking the view. Jeremy had a nice sized cock, and was thick. This didn't seem to faze Donna, as she rode the whole length of him balls deep, and he played with her boobs. A few minutes in and Donna came, convulsing herself on Jeremy's dick, and he let out a moan. He apparently had pinched her nipples. "That makes her gush for sure," Mike pipped in.
"Where do you want me to come? Jeremy asked, as Donna turned herself around to ride him reverse cowgirl. "In her," Mike said, and that was that. As I watched Jeremy's beautiful dick getting hugged by Donna's cunt, I noticed it getting harder and his urethra bulging and getting more prominent. I couldn't help it, so I started massaging his balls, just as Donna started riding him full throttle. He suddenly gasped "coming!" and probably spurt ten big squirts of jizz up her cunt. Jeremy was the heaviest cummer I had ever seen, so I wasn't surprised. Donna stayed propped up on his dick for a while, while I saw some of his cream leak out of her pussy and onto his balls.
"Wow!" he said, and she got off and put on a robe. His dick plopped on his belly, with some cum spilling out, but it seemed that most of it was still in Donna. I pulled Jeremy up and gave him a pat on the back. "That was the hottest thing I've been since you fucked my husband while giving me head." We all started laughing, and Jeremy and I soon left to go to our own room, but not before Donna leaned in and kissed him and said, "Thanks hon, I needed that."
Epilogue
Three months later, my dear friend Jeremy took a job as a traveling nurse, and moved away. We never really talked about what happened at bike week again, but I could tell that Donna's pussy, although clearly a nut buster, didn't sway Jeremy at all. He loved dick too much, but I had my doubts that Donna would be his last.
A week after Jeremy left, Eric called me into his home office to look at his computer at a profile picture on a social media page. "Look! Apparently Donna's pregnant. You don't think?" I sat down to put the pieces together from the encounter at bike week, and I was speechless. "Well, I guess they aren't empty nesters anymore! Clearly people are gonna think they got a donor" And we both shook our heads. "Maybe they talked it over with Jeremy?" Eric asked, and I told him I seriously doubted it. Up until that night I didn't even know they had an open marriage. "I guess there's no proof, but either way, that was a hot and crazy night!" Eric rebuffed, "I made out with a drag queen, and you may have helped our friend impregnate another friend. Yeah, I would call that a crazy night!" And even though it sounded ludicrous and unreal, we just had to laugh. Crazy fun at bike week indeed.