"Hey, Laura?" I said from the living room. "Remember when I mentioned I had been working on a surprise for Valentine's Day?"
"Yeah. I have to admit, I'm super excited to find out what that was all about," Laura replied excitedly from the other end of the phone call. "Can I maybe get a hint or something?"
"Well," I stammered. "At first, I wanted to surprise you with keys to a chastity cage that I'd be wearing..."
"Ooh, interesting!" Laura teased. "That does open a whole new realm of possibilities! But I'm sensing there's more to this, so, please, continue."
I shifted uncomfortably on the couch. Alice had not allowed me to put my clothing back on, so I was still naked, apart from the tailed butt plug. "Well, the cashier that sold me the cage, asked me why I wanted it..." I said, taking breaks while speaking, carefully picking my words.
"Uh-huh," Laura said, listening attentively.
"When I mentioned it being a surprise on Valentine's Day," I continued. "She suggested taking the surprise a step further and arranging a threesome." I blushed hard. I feared the many possible negative replies Laura could say, given that she had never before suggested such a thing to me.
There was a moment of quietness on the phone, before Laura finally replied, "Okay... so, like, do you, I mean, uhm," Laura seemed to be struggling to collect her thoughts into coherent sentences. Suddenly a barrage of questions flooded out of Laura's mouth, "Like, with another man? Another woman? Do we cuck you? Do you participate?" Laura's questions did not seem to be of disgust or disapproval, but of genuine interest and curiosity.
"Well, the cashier offered to join in, herself," I managed to say, struggling to find the words to make it seem like the proposition was genuine, and that I hadn't been cheating on her for the past week with the idea only coming to me just now.
"Normally, I wouldn't like the thought of you with another woman," Laura began. "But, if she works at a sex shop, at least she'd be professional about it... She'd more likely know what to do as well... Plus, you'd be in a chastity cage, and I'd have your key... So at least I wouldn't have to worry about you fucking her either..." Laura weighed the idea very carefully, before eventually agreeing, "Okay! But we all know a threesome like that is mainly exciting for you... So how about we also do a threesome with another guy, to really spice things up?"
I swallowed hard. "I, uhm," I stammered. Thoughts rushed to my head. Was this leading up to a proposal for interracial sex? I knew it was popular in porn, but I always thought that it was just some people's fantasy... I never expected to face something like that personally... Could it be that Laura was aware of such porn and had developed a desire to experience it too?
I suddenly felt inadequate and realized that being in chastity, in combination with a threesome, would make me much more vulnerable than I originally intended to be. What was once meant as a loving gift and a proof of loyalty, had now mentally been corrupted into an admittance of inadequacy and surrender to the life of a cuckold.
"By the quietness, I can tell it's a sensitive subject," Laura eventually said. "I get it... When you're in chastity, you can't fuck the girl, but I can get fucked by the guy... It's not a fair role reversal, and I suppose that that makes you uncomfortable."
"Y- Yeah," I said, sweat dripping from my forehead. "I guess that's a good way to put it." For a moment, I felt relieved, but that sense of victory quickly disappeared as Laura spoke again.
"Then how about this: I'd still like a threesome with another guy, but I won't let his dick anywhere near my pussy," Laura said. "That way, you'd both be equals in terms of their ability to fuck me!"
I had not accounted for this suggestion. Laura had a point, but whoever the other person was, could still display his erection, while I couldn't. I trusted Laura, but I still felt like I was at a disadvantage. My moment of relief had gone sour.
"I don't know..." I said. "I'm still a bit insecure about it."
"You think I'm full of confidence with another girl in the mix?" Laura asked matter-of-factly.
"You have a point," I conceded. "I'll do it... but only because you want this, and I love you enough to go out of my comfort zone for you."
"Noted," Laura replied. "I'll make sure you won't feel neglected. I promise! I've got to go now, only one week left to go, and I haven't even selected our male candidate yet! There's work to be done! Bye, babe, love you!"
Laura hung up before I could say as much as 'I love you' back to her. Did she just call me 'babe'? That's a first...
"Sounds like that's settled then," Alice spoke as she entered the living room carrying a box.
"Were you eavesdropping?" I asked embarrassed.
"I mainly just overheard your replies as I was looking for this box here," Alice said and laughed. "It's a phone, not a speaker."
"Right," I said and apologized. "Basically, Laura agreed to the threesome, but she also wants a threesome with a guy."
"Kinky," Alice replied with a wink. "Would you like me to ask Tyler?" She laughed.
Oh, God, no. It's already bad enough that she's pimping me out to him soon. I'd prefer to keep Tyler's involvement a one-time, isolated occurrence. "N- No, thanks," I stuttered. "Laura already opted to find a male candidate herself."