I met Caitlin in a night club when we were both aged nineteen. We quickly fell madly in love with each other and within three months we had set up our first home together. Life was great to start with; we were young, in love and could not get enough of each other.
However as we shared our lives together we slowly began to have our differences, and our relationship deteriated from the perfect start to one where after eighteen months together we came to the mutual decision that it was best to break up and go our separate ways. I suppose that one of the main causes of our relationship deteriating was our sex life. To start with we made love all the time, enjoying each others bodies and experiencing new and different things together. However it soon became apparent that Caitlin had very prudish and different attitudes towards sex than I did.
Since I was a young teenager I have always had a fetish for sperm and cream pies. Before Caitlin my previous sexual encounters had indulged me at times in this fetish. I had several previous casual girlfriends and one night stands that used to let me clean up and eat out the sperm from their sticky pussies after we had made love. I really enjoy the sight, taste and smell of a fresh cream pie. Unfortunately the first time that I tried to go down on Caitlin after we had made love to taste my cream pie, she screamed and pushed my head away saying that it was disgusting and un-natural.
Caitlin did try and make the effort to accommodate my fetish. Occasionally if she had a few drinks and got a little tipsy she would let me clean up her pussy of my sperm with my tongue and mouth, but she never really enjoyed it and I could tell that she was only going through he motions to try and please me. She would not even shave or trim her pussy hair, which she knew that I preferred, saying that it was not normal to do so. We tried to talk about my fetish on occasions, but she always told me that it disgusted her and that she could not understand how I could possibly get any enjoyment from seeing her used sticky pussy full up with sperm, let alone licking and tasting it. I remember one time vividly when we talked and I suggested that it would be great to let another man fuck her so that I could eat up a cream pie that was not my own. Caitlin went berserk at this suggestion and we didn't even talk to each other for at least a week. It was probably this admission that I would enjoy watching her with another man, and then afterwards eating up the sticky mess that they had made together that was the final straw for our relationship. It was not long after I had mentioned this that we agreed that we were not compatible and it would be best for all concerned if we were to split up.
About three months after I had split from Caitlin I was starting to sort my life out again. I had moved in to a pleasant one bedroom flat and was making social contacts with a group of friends that had nothing to do with Caitlin and our previous life together. I had had the pleasure of a couple of one night stands and enjoyed going down on one of the girls after we had fucked. I had seen Caitlin around a couple of times and we remained on reasonably friendly terms with each other. Things were certainly starting to look up. It was at this time that I had a telephone call from Anne, Caitlin's mother. She invited me round to her house for a cup of tea one morning for a chat and to catch up.
Anne was a pleasant lady aged in her mid forties. She was always impeccibly dressed, although always on the conservative side. She looked reasonably attractive for her age, and she still had a good figure which was aided by her membership of a private health and beauty club, which she attended on a regular basis. She was happily married to Steve and I had always got on well with both of them when I had visited her home with Caitlin. She had always been warm and very hospitable while I was living with her daughter, and it did not seem un-natural for her to contact me to arrange a meeting for a chat.
As arranged a few days after her phone call I arrived early one morning at Anne's house. She welcomed me in, made me comfortable in her lounge and prepared a drink. As we made idle chat over a cup of tea and biscuits Anne finally got round to asking "Why exactly did you separate from Caitlin?"
"It's a long story," I replied. "But in the end we decided that we weren't really getting along and that it was best for both of us to move on."
"That's a shame." Anne said. "I was looking forward to eventually having you as a son-in-law."
"I'm sorry." I meekly replied.
"No problem, these things happen in life. Why did you think that you weren't getting along?"
"There were lots of reasons," I replied as evasively as possible as I really couldn't go into the details of our relationship with Anne.
"I thought that the two of you were getting along so well, I was really surprised, and sad, when you broke up."
"Yeah it was a real shame," I muttered.
"Was it because Caitlin wouldn't give you cream pies?" Anne bluntly asked.
I didn't know where to look or what to do. I was so embarrassed and could feel my face and neck flushing red with total embarrassment. I could not take in that Anne had mentioned cream pies. How, and what did she know? Why was she asking me this? How embarrassing for my ex-girlfriends mother to even mention the word in my presence.
"Last week I had a long heart to heart chat with Caitlin and she finally got round to telling me some of the reasons as to why you split up," Anne said. "She told me that you seem to have a fetish about sperm and cream pies, and that she just couldn't bring herself to give you what you wanted. My daughter seems to have very prudish ideas when it comes to sex."
I listened to Anne in total shock. This was my ex girlfriends mother talking openly about sperm and cream pies as if they were the most normal thing in the world. I could not believe that I was listening to her bringing this matter up in conversation about her own daughter.
"Was that the reason why you split from my daughter?" Anne asked.
I muttered "I don't know what you mean."
"As Caitlin wouldn't let you clean her pussy up after you had made love, was that the reason that you split up?"
I nodded slowly embarrassingly back at Anne.
"Was it?" said Anne again a little more firmly.
"Yes," I replied in a voice that was barely a whisper.
I couldn't believe that I was sitting in my ex girlfriends mother's lounge, drinking tea and admitting to her that I had split up from her daughter because she wouldn't let me eat up my sperm from her sticky pussy after we had made love. The whole situation seemed totally surreal and I was very embarrassed. I fidgeted in my chair trying to think of a tactful way that I could quickly get out of there.