** This story contains several fetish themes: small penis humiliation, cuckolding, incest, cfnm. This may not be something you enjoy if these themes do not resonate with you. All characters are over 18. This is a work of fiction - some characters will have actions that would never work in real life. If you enjoy this story, please leave a comment and check out some of my other stories. **
Complicated, unconventional, and private, all words my wife and I have used to talk about our relationship. I know most people wouldn't understand; they wouldn't have a clue how to make sense of our life.
On the outside, as far as anyone could tell, we led a simple vanilla life. We didn't make tons of money, we lived simple lives, but beneath the surface of our beige Camry, khaki pants-wearing lives, we've had to make some compromises, some adjustments to make our marriage work. And no one in our day-to-day lives has even been close to seeing the real us. Until now.
It started 25 years ago, when Charity and I were dating. We were young, in love, and absolutely convinced we were soul mates - meant to be. But there was one thing that hung over us, something that neither of us wanted to talk about but couldn't ignore.
I have a small penis.
As a teenager, I tried to brush it off. "It's not the size, it's how you use it," I told myself, repeating the age-old mantra like a prayer. But deep down, I knew it wasn't enough; all the boys I'd seen were much bigger than me, most bigger soft than mine erect.
Charity had never said anything and never made me feel inadequate, but I could see it in her eyes sometimes. That quiet, unspoken longing for something more. I always did my part to make her feel good, and never shied away from using my mouth and hands on her, even after I'd already cum.
And then, one night, it all came to a head. We'd been in bed together, I was doing everything I could, pounding, grinding, and feeling good about how long I was lasting - but she just laid there, no emotion at all - I may as well had been fucking her feet. The silence between us was heavy, awkward, and suddenly it just felt sad. I slid down her sexy body, ready to lick her to pleasure, but this time she stopped me. I rolled off her, and she turned to me, taking my face in her hands, her voice soft but resolute.
"Jason," she said, her hand resting on my cheek, "I love you more than anything. But... we need to talk. About us. About... this."
"I know." I could feel my face redden. "You don't have to say it... I'm not... enough," I whispered, my voice breaking. "I am trying. I'll do whatever it takes."
"You're everything to me. But... I can't pretend that this doesn't bother me. I can't deny that I don't want... no, that's not right, that I need more. I need it, Jason." Her fingers tightening around my small dick. We were approaching graduation from college and had already started talking about marriage and life after school. I wasn't her first, and I knew I was smaller than her other boyfriends, I had to be just statistically speaking.
But, for the first time, she said it, and there it was. The truth lay bare between us. The humiliation lit a fire in my face and a lust inside me, a wave of fetishes implanted in my soul as she talked, and my body sealed it by releasing a flood of endorphins through my body, my small penis pulsing as she talked, I was ashamed, but it was also a relief. Finally, we could stop pretending.
We explored with toys - vibrators, dildos, but her favorite was a penis sleeve, she liked the feeling of my body on top of hers, the grinding of my hips, the physical embrace while using it.
We committed to talking about our sexual past, our current desires, our deepest fantasies, and our future hopes. We embraced being vocal in bed, asking for what we wanted, and mutually working together to satisfy one another. And to our surprise, I loved hearing about her past lovers, I couldn't explain how much desire it ignited in me hearing about her having sex with these other guys, and particularly with Brad. Charity confessed he was her biggest, easily 8-9 inches.
She was honest about how good his cock felt deep inside her, how he would stretch her, filling her, making her feel full and feminine. And, that was the only thing they had in common; she grew to despise talking with him, hanging out with his friends became unbearable due to the way he talked about her and to her in front of his "bros."
Charity was an open book to me, and no matter what she said, my fondness and connection to her grew. And she reciprocated that desire, even when I shared how much I loved hearing her talk about my little dick, I wanted her to tease me and humiliate me for having a tiny dick, she embraced it and me.
Over the years, Charity had gotten good at giving me just the right amount of small penis teasing, without ever being mean. And, it worked... for a while. It hit me hard after she bought a new toy - all of our nightstand goodies had been for her, to please her, but this new toy was for me, it was called a Fleshlight, a fake pussy for her to use on me.
The first time she used it was a night I wanted to play, but she wasn't feeling well, so she offered to use it on me. It was fine, better than a dry handjob, but nowhere near as good as the real thing. Then something odd happened, weeks went by, and I realized I hadn't been inside her. We had played with toys, and she sucked me, but I hadn't been in her pussy, and I craved it.