After the second orgasm, he backed off and lowered his pants, almost timidly-- and what popped out was a tiny little 3 inch penis. I blinked and we had a brief conversation about it but I told him I wanted to continue and so I spun around and began to suck on it softly. It felt great not to have my mouth split open by a massive dick, I took my time pleasuring him. The feeling was new, but new doesn't necessarily mean bad it was the opposite I loved it.
Eventually though, I wanted to feel him in my pussy-- so I turned back around onto my back so we could fuck in missionary. He put it in me (basically all the way in immediately) and when I say I felt the head in just the right spot, I mean it rubbed my insides in all the right ways. I let out a moan and he was surprised- I told him to fuck me good. He kissed me and thrust into my tight little pussy over and over and I came on his cock twice.
We rolled over and I rode his little dick until I came on him again. I moaned for him so others outside could hear him getting some of the best pussy he'd ever have, and told him his cock felt soooo good. It was literally perfect for my pussy, and it didn't hurt at all which was one of the best parts.
After about thirty minutes of missionary and doggy he told me he was going to cum and pulled out, he sprayed an impressive load over my tummy. I cleaned up but decided to stay and we fucked two more times and I had a few more orgasms. We basically talked the whole night about deep things too he told me that he coped with his dick so hard his whole life and finally felt appreciated that someone really enjoyed it. He told me most girls didn't even cum and didn't moan.
So overall it was a great night and I'll never judge a cock by its size ever again. That was a lesson that stuck with me back then and even though noone of my previous sex partners had a small dick like him, there were still 4 incher guys which I enjoyed to its fullest too. It was my new fetish from there on.