This story is a work of fiction. Some real places and institutions are mentioned or implied, but they are used fictitiously here. As far as the author knows, no real person affiliated with any of those places or institutions has done anything akin to what is described in this story. Any similarities between any character in this story and any real person are coincidental and unintended. I encourage comments on this story, both favorable and unfavorable. Thank you for reading.
_______________________________________________________________
Carly Durre and I were both athletes in college. Carly was a diver on the women's team. I was a swimmer on the men's team. However, we met in a European history class sophomore year. We were in the same discussion group. Carly had a gorgeous face with short brown hair, an upturned nose, high cheekbones, a strong jaw, large blue eyes, and a smile that could light-up a room. Interacting with her in the discussion group, I learned that Carly was also very intelligent, articulate, and, occasionally, very funny.
The men's team typically had practice after the women's team, there was only one practice pool. I arrived at practice early about a week after I'd met Carly. Walking out of the locker room onto the pool deck, I almost bumped into her. She smiled, said hello, and walked on towards the springboard. As she walked on in her suit, I got a good view of a tight ass above long, elegant legs. As she stood on the diving board, I couldn't help but admire the flat stomach and perfectly proportioned breasts outlined by her suit. Carly Durre was a very beautiful, and sexy, young woman.
Carly and I were both history majors, so we ended up having several classes together. As I interacted with her more, I learned that her personality was even more attractive than her appearance. By the start of our junior year, Carly and I had become good friends. Unfortunately, we did not become lovers. Carly was dating a music student named Keith, who sang with a soulful voice and played piano and guitar. A mere jock like me couldn't compete.
I did see Carly naked once during college. Although I had no inkling at the time, that incident led to what happened later. Carly had a pretty good senior year diving, qualifying for the national championships. I missed qualifying in the 100 fly by two one-hundredths of a second, an eon in swimming. After the season was over for both teams, we had a party for the senior swimmers. The party was on a Saturday night at the apartment two senior women swimmers shared a couple of blocks off campus.
Most of us had reached twenty-one, so there was some beer and wine at the party. Better still, Carly came to the party by herself. When I asked, she said that Keith, who was in a band, was playing a gig in the city. With swimmers from the two teams along with boyfriends and girlfriends, there were around thirty people at the party. While many of the people were friends of mine, I spent most of the party talking with Carly. She didn't seem to mind.
By midnight, we were all a little buzzed, although I don't think anyone was trashed. One of the girls hosting the party called out, "we should go to the pool. It's our last chance to swim together!" The natatorium was only a few blocks away and most of us knew the security code to get in after hours. Several of us left the party for the pool. Most of the group changed their minds, another beer seeming more inviting than chlorinated water. However, six of us got to the pool: Carly and two other girls, Jana and Lynne, and me, Matt, and Shane. The natatorium was, of course, empty at that hour.
When the six of us reached the pool deck, Shane said, "Ok, now what? None of us brought suits."
"We're skinny dipping, silly," Jana retorted. To emphasize the point, Jana pulled off her top, undid her bra, and dropped both on the deck. Jana kicked off her shoes and unbuckled her jeans, I noticed Carly and Lynne starting to undress. I was perfectly happy to skinny dip with Carly. Jana and Lynne were also friends, so I began to undress. We had not turned on any lights, but the night lights, which were on all the time, were bright enough that we could see each other clearly.
In moments, Carly, Jana, Lynne, and I were naked. I did, of course, look at Carly. She was more beautiful naked than I'd imagined. I thought Carly was looking at me but dismissed that idea as wishful thinking.
There was a problem. Matt and Shane were still clothed and showed no signs they were about to undress. "Come on guys," Jana said, "get naked like Peter!" The two guys just stood there, staring at the three naked women.
I couldn't deny that the three women were worth staring at, but I thought it was unfair for the guys just to be gawkers. "Come on guys," I said, "strip off or leave."
"Fuck off Peter," Matt said. I wasn't going to let that go, first because I'd been drinking some and, second, because I was being challenged in front of the women.
"I mean it," I said. "Get naked or get out!"
"You're going to throw us out?" Matt replied.
"If I have to," I said, and started walking towards him.
I need to explain that I was large for a swimmer and muscular. A year earlier, for laughs, I had agreed to wrestle a wrestling team member who was a little bigger than me. The wrestler didn't take our bout seriously, which allowed me to pin him. I knew well I could never have done that had my opponent been wrestling seriously, but it did give me a reputation.
Shane had been quiet. However, as I walked towards the two clothed young men, he said, "Matt, I don't think it's smart to fuck with Peter."
Matt was sizing the situation up. He had also been drinking and, of course, didn't want to back down in front of three attractive women. On the other hand, I was bigger than Matt and Matt knew that, if there was a fight, he'd be on his own. Shane's comment made clear he wasn't going to get into it with me. Matt finally said, "fuck you Peter. I'm not getting into it with a naked guy. Let's go Shane." Matt and Shane walked out of the pool. A few seconds later, I heard a steel outside door on the building slam shut. I expected that to set off an alarm, but it didn't.
I turned around to see Carly, Jana, and Lynne standing on the pool deck, naked and smiling. "Good job!" Jana said.
Carly stepped to me. "My hero," she said. Keeping her body out of contact with mine, she leaned forward and gave me a quick peck on the lips.
You're probably expecting me to tell you that I fucked at least one of the girls beside the pool that night. I didn't. That would have caused problems with my then girlfriend, who had declined to go to the party. I also feared ruining my friendship with Carly. All we did was swim; although I did get to wash all three girls' upper backs when we showered off together. Karen, my girlfriend, was a little suspicious when she came to my apartment the next morning and found me in what she called "a silly mood."
My first class the following Monday was a small senior seminar that Carly was also in. She came up to me in the hall after the seminar. "Peter, I want to thank you for being a gentleman Saturday night," she said. Then, she added, "you look pretty nice naked."
"Thank you," I replied. "You are very beautiful naked."
Carly didn't say anything for a moment. I was silently cursing my big mouth when she broke into one of her high wattage smiles and said, "thank you."
My relationship with Karen ended at graduation. She was off to med school in Baltimore. I had graduated with honors and my faculty adviser had urged me to get a Master's. I would have except, with my swimming scholarship over, I couldn't afford to. Hoping to make a little money and qualify for a staff tuition rate in a couple of years, I got a job in the University Archivist's office. Carly had also graduated with honors. I was surprised when Carly told me she was taking a job at a private swim club in Ohio.
"I'm going to be 'aquatic director,'" Carly explained. "The club has swimming and tennis. It's run by a non-profit. The woman who heads the board swam with Coach Deardorf in college. Coach D recommended me. The members are primarily adults, so I won't have to run swim classes for little kids. Its in a college town, which is nice. Low cost of living and I'll make some money while I figure out what to do next."
I asked what Keith thought about her plans. "Nothing," Carly answered. "He's got an opportunity to be a studio musician in Nashville. His music career comes first with him." Personally, I thought Carly was worth sacrificing any career, but that wasn't a decision I'd ever have to make.
Keith was already gone, so I helped Carly move out of her apartment after graduation. I had time since I was staying in Chicago and didn't have to move. I was more than a little sad as Carly drove off. I didn't expect to see her again. She was such a great person, and so beautiful and, well, sexy. I wished we had become lovers, but I was sure I'd have killed a great friendship if I'd ever tried to push things that way.
I didn't meet many people working for the Archivist in the basement of the old university library building, and I didn't have the money to be going to bars on the weekends. To be around people as much as anything else, I picked up a second gig as a graduate assistant swim coach for $ 750 for the season. I learned more about swimming that year as a grad assistant, basically a gofer for the real coaches, than I had learned during the years I'd been a swimmer. A fringe benefit was that I could still workout in the athletic department facilities.
By the following Spring, I was frustrated. What little I earned was eaten up by living expenses and the University had changed its rules to lengthen the time you had to be on staff before you were eligible for reduced grad school tuition. I needed a Plan B, but I wasn't coming up with one.
My phone rang on a Sunday morning in early May. I didn't get many calls any time, and never on a Sunday morning. When I answered the phone, I heard a voice I'd not heard in almost a year.
"Peter, its Carly Durre," Carly said. "Remember me? Sorry if I woke you up, but this was the only time I could think of when I thought sure I'd catch you in."
I was a little ashamed of how thrilled I was to hear Carly's voice again. Couldn't I move on from college? "No, I was up," I said. "It's great to hear from you, but I'm curious why it was important that you catch me in person. I do have voicemail."
Carly laughed. I'd always loved the musical quality to her laugh. "We haven't talked in almost a year, so I wasn't sure you'd call me back. And, well, if I took the time to leave a message and wait for you to call back, I might talk myself out of what I want to ask you."
"Now, you really have my curiosity piqued," I said. "What do you want to ask?"
"Uh, well," Carly said, "I let my mouth get me into something and I need a partner in crime."
That was an odd thing to say I thought. "What crime?" I asked.
"Not a real crime," Carly replied. "I just let my enthusiasm carry me away and promised to do something. If I'm really going to do it, I'm going to need a partner. I was thinking about that time we skinny dipped at the natatorium, I remember that often, and I thought you'd be the perfect."