I woke up for breakfast and ate French toast that Miller made us. I had a few minutes to determine everything he knew, and it was just as bad as I had worried. While he knew there would be nudity in the play, he didn't know I would be appearing naked until Chuck brought home the add in his pervert flyer. Worse yet, Miller had already bought tickets for the show—he had called up when they first went on sale and bought them out-of-pocket, thinking it would be a nice surprise, supportive and all that. Very Miller of him.
"You can't come," I told him, and he seemed both surprised and wounded. "Look, I'm sorry, Miller, but this isn't like a regular play. I would be nervous as hell up there knowing you're out there." He ran his fingers through his beard and asked me what was so bad about someone I knew being in the audience—if I could stand up there for strangers, why couldn't he come to support me. "I know you're not a sex fiend, Mill..."
"Not a successful one," he said, but then he laughed away my squirrel-in-headlights look. "I bought those tickets because I've been to all your other shows and I wanted to be there for you. When you were in that Mamet play that sold out, I talked the box office into letting me stand in the wings by telling them I was your brother. I don't care if you're naked or not, Chels. I'm just a fan of yours. And you've been telling me how cool this play is—you know, I'm kind of hurt you didn't tell me about the nudity. I might have been able to make you feel better about it..."
"Enough. Let's just stop talking about it," I sighed. "I don't even have a big problem with you going, Mill, it's not that... you're cooler about this sort of thing than... you know who... but I can't let him—"
Chuck walked out of the hallway, and it was obvious he heard me talking. He was a little aloof, though playing it off as if he found it funny, which was his usual way of giving me the cold shoulder.
"Right. I forgot how holy and pure Miller is," he said, snickering as he went and started a pot of coffee.
Miller asked, "Want some French—"
"'Cause I couldn't
possibly
want to see this play because it's good and my friend is in it and I'm a nice guy. Only Miller would do that. I'm just a prick who shows up to make fun of you."
"I didn't say you would be there making fun of me," I had to defend, losing none of my antagonism, "but we both know you weren't planning on going to the play before you found this out."
"I was so."
"Miller's already asked me like six times for comp tickets, I told him I was trying to get them. I was kind of hoping I could just pretend I forgot—sorry, Mill, but you know..."
As he shrugged and tried to keep himself out of the argument, Chuck turned from the coffee machine and shook his head. "So it's okay if Miller comes but not me, 'cause I just couldn't be a good guy about it. Miller's your fucking friend, I'm just some asshole..." I tried to argue with him while not letting him guilt me when he knew very well he hadn't cared about the play before he saw the naked picture. I was right, and he knew it, but that only made him argue louder and harder. "I don't pretend I don't think you're cute. You're hot, Chels—Miller thinks so, too, but I just—I catch shit because I'm being myself. He pretends to be a big brother and all that garbage. But he would fuck you if got the chance—"
"Chuck, hey—don't be a prick."
"What you call being a prick is just me telling her the truth. If you two both want to pretend we're all
Three's Company
in here and nobody ever thinks about fucking someone else, you do what you want. But you're gonna punish me for it?"
"Well, you can get over your 'truth,' Chuck, because I'm not fucking Miller or you. I certainly don't want you coming to the—"
"You mean again," he said, and then I could tell he felt guilty for opening his big mouth. He looked at Miller, and neither of us was sure he caught it, but Chuck chose that moment to expurgate himself. "You mean you wouldn't fuck me
again
, Chels. Look, I'm sorry, but he deserves to know—"
"Oh, what an asshole you are..." Miller crossed his arms and glanced toward me and I had to nod. He asked when it happened, and I got the sense he was hopeful something had happened between us a long time ago. "It was... we both got pretty drunk the night of the underwear party," I told him, and I felt awful seeing his expression sink. "We didn't want you to know about it. We were both pretty embarrassed."
Chuck cleared his throat, but I shut him up with a look.
"It didn't really change anything between us," I said, as if it were a defense. "We haven't done it again or anything. I don't love him and he doesn't love me, of course. We just..."