First Night Pt. 02

Author's Note: This is part of a series following Casey and Alex as they explore their exhibitionist and voyeur kinks, along with many others, in the sex club Haven. They don't have to be read in order to make sense, they are more like vignettes.

***

"And did you see the size of his cock Alex? Its like he was fucking her with a baseball bat!" Casey said, still aroused from her first experience as a voyeur just down the hall from the bar they were now seated in. They sat in a booth, Alex with a strong rum and coke and Casey with a lager.

"Of course I saw it, it was impossible to miss! And it looked like he was literally fucking that woman's brains out. I don't think she would have known her name if you asked her!" Alex responded, his arousal equal to his wife's. Their first night in Haven was certainly off to a sexy start. The couple was supposed to be simmering down but they couldn't stop discussing the animalistic sex they had just witnessed. In fact their arousal was at an all time high. Alex could see Casey's stiff nipples trying to push out of her lacy top which mirrored his cock in his briefs. He was certain that Casey was sitting in a puddle of her own wetness.

Just then Casey spotted movement by the entrance. "Oh fuck!" Casey whispered "It's them!" The source of their arousal had just walked in and were ordering drinks at the bar. From the way they were joking with the bartender it was clear that, unlike Casey and Alex, this was not their first night at Haven. They got their drinks and turned to look for a seat. Casey noticed that they each had two drinks in their hands. The man raised one of his glasses at them as if to wave and started to walk in their direction. "They're walking over here!" Casey whispered in a small panic, taking a big gulp of her beer.

"Mind if we join you?" The woman asked as they approached the table. Alex looked at Casey and shrugged, he couldn't think of a good reason why not to invite the couple to join them. "Not at all, here" Alex responded with a smile and scooched over to make room. Casey did the same on the opposite bench. The man sat beside Alex and the woman beside Casey.

"We bought you guys another round, hope that's okay." The woman said with a smile as she passed her two drinks down the table. "I'm Debra and this is my husband Phil." Casey and Alex introduced themselves as well.

Soon the couples had shared a fair amount of info about themselves and everyone was feeling comfortable. Debra was a professor at the local college and Phil formerly worked in admissions at the same college, which is how they met. Phil quit admissions after seeing so many students pushed into career paths that didn't fit them. "Not everyone has to go to college, but kids don't hear that when they are in school. That's why I became a carpentry teacher at the local high school, to help kids figure out what's best for them."

The topic turned to Haven. "So what led you guys to Haven? I know you're at least into watching couples." Phil asked with a wink and a smile.

Alex laughed "Well for tonight I think we were going to try having sex with an audience. Keep things simple for our first night out."

"But we're into a little bit of everything, so I expect us to have lots of fun in the future." Casey added with a devious smile.

Phil laughed and looked at his wife. "You guys sound like a younger version of us! That's smart though, you don't need to overdo things. There's plenty of time to explore. Deb and I have been here for a few months now and it feels like we've just scratched the surface of our list!" Phil continued "But if you want an audience, we'd be happy to watch! We have that room rented out for the next hour."

Debra sensed the hesitation in the young couple. "No pressure, you can say no. We were nervous on our first time so we just wanted to offer."

Casey and Alex looked at each other and agreed. The couples discussed some ground rules, finished their drinks, and set off for the room.

...

Debra was the last one in and closed the door behind her. Casey and Alex crawled onto the bed together while Phil found a place on the couch. Debra joined him, kissed him deeply, then they both turned their attention to Casey and Alex. It was immediately clear that the young couple was still nervous. Thankfully Debra spoke up "Don't worry, that's to be expected on your first night. Would you like us to help you?"

Casey nodded "Yes, please. I've never been naked in front of strangers before."

Debra laughed "Not many people have!"

"Okay, let's get started nice and slowly. Alex, why don't you start by kissing your beautiful wife?" Alex turned and looked Casey in the eye, they both smiled. Alex pushed her back onto the bed so that she was laying flat on her back. Then he positioned himself parallel to her and dropped close to her for a deep, passionate kiss. Quickly arousal overtook their nerves and they began making out. After a few minutes Debra spoke up again "Good, when you're ready Alex take off Casey's top and show us her gorgeous tits. Then suck on her nipples." Alex broke from the kiss after a few moments and followed Debra's instructions. He unclasped the lace bra, freeing his wife's breasts for their new friends to see. Casey felt a jolt of excitement in her clit, she was topless in front of strangers. Her nipples hardened but she couldn't tell if it was from arousal, the cool air, or in some sort of erotic pavlovian response knowing her husband was about to suckle on them. She didn't have time to parse it out before Alex latched onto her left nipple with his mouth. Casey let out an accidental moan. "Oooooh she likes that" Debra cooed.

Alex was being thorough, spending several moments on her breast. Casey moaned a few more times, she loved having her nipples sucked. As Alex switched to her right breast she looked over at the couple on the couch. Even from across the room she could tell that Phil's massive cock was erect in his pants. Her eyes must have lingered because Debra started rubbing it. "Now you have my husband all worked up. And from what I can see, your husband is too. I think they would like having their cocks touched, don't you agree?" Casey nodded and reached her hand to Alex's crotch. His cock was rock hard, as it always was when he suckled from her. She began massaging it through his pants as well. Alex groaned as he pulled Casey's right nipple into his mouth and began sucking. Casey's pussy spasmed at the feeling. She continued touching Alex's cock, subconsciously mirroring Debra's motions on Phil's. Debra slid her free hand to her panties and began rubbing herself, now masturbating them both to the sight of Casey dry nursing Alex. Her arousal was in full swing now, she could feel her pussy getting wetter, more relaxed. It was ready for a cock.

"Baby I need you to fuck me" She interrupted Alex's suckling with a husky voice filled with need. "Please, baby, please use my pussy." Alex had learned when to tease his wife and when to listen. He could hear the desperate arousal in Casey's voice; a perfect time to tease her. Alex sat up on the bed and once again pushed Casey onto her back. The anxiety of being naked in front of others was entirely displaced with their horniness. Alex removed Casey's panties which were soaked through and his own pants and underwear as well. Casey's pussy looked so inviting, glistening with her precum.

Alex couldn't help himself as he lowered his face to her slit and began licking her delicious juices. He made a few passes with his tongue, each started just above her asshole and glided up over her clit which was protruding ever so slightly. Casey moaned with each spasm of her clit, her need for a cock grew by the second. She felt Alex's tongue invade her pussy, pushing a few inches inside before retracting. He repeated this several times, fucking her with his tongue. Casey could feel an orgasm building, she couldn't take much more teasing. Her clit felt like it was on a hair trigger, ready to cum at any second. Alex could tell Casey was close too. He stopped working her pussy and pulled her up onto her hands and knees then positioned himself behind her.

Casey saw that the couple on the couch had shed their clothing and were now openly masturbating to her and Alex. Debra's tits were on display as she fingered herself and Phil had his massive cock in hand. He was stroking it slowly as he stared intently at her. Casey didn't have long to appreciate the scene as Alex pushed her upper body to the bed. Casey felt Alex move and braced herself for his cock. Instead she felt his tongue on her asshole. Casey let out a loud surprised moan "Oh Gooooooood". She loved having her ass eaten but it felt so slutty and dirty. Alex knew her feelings about it well, it was her slutty guilty pleasure. Now he was going to make her cum publicly with it. He swirled his tongue clockwise around her tight hole, collecting all of the wetness that dripped down from her pussy. She felt her asshole relax with every circle of his warm tongue.

Alex inserted two fingers into her pussy as he continued to rim her. He used his two fingers to rub her g-spot while his thumb curled under her to stimulate her clit in one fluid motion. Casey could feel herself on the brink of orgasm, she was moaning through her embarrassment. She was beginning to accept that her first public orgasm would be from having her ass eaten like some slut. Alex was licking her hole up and down now, slowly and matching the pace of his fingers. Each pass she felt her asshole relax just a little more, permitting his tongue to drive just a little deeper each time. Eventually he abandoned the vertical motion and switched to simply driving his down in and out of her. Casey looked up and saw Phil and Debra masturbating to her getting her asshole fucked by her husband's tongue. She was overwhelmed by the filthiness of it all.

"Oh Goddd... I'm sorry.... I'm not... fuck... I'm not usually... fuck... so dirty... it's just... huuuuuuh... so fucking good! Huuuuuuh..." As she finished her attempt to downplay her sluttiness Alex jammed what felt like his entire tongue into her asshole. Casey's eyes rolled back into her head and her body shuddered with an intense orgasm. She heard Phil whisper "Oh fuck" as she convulsed confirming he was still stroking his cock to her. Her orgasm subsided but before she could comment on the situation she felt Alex's cock at the entrance to her pussy. She tried to get back onto her hands but Alex shoved her back down onto the bed. Clearly he had overcome his nerves as well and now desperately needed to fuck her. Without giving her any time to protest Alex shoved his thick cock into Casey's drenched pussy. Casey let out a satisfied groan as she took the entire shaft inside of her, finally her pussy was being stretched like it needed to be. Alex gave Casey a few moments to enjoy the sensation of being filled with a cock that he knew she enjoyed so much.

Debra spokeup after the pause "God you two are hot. Now fuck her like she needs Alex." Spurred by Debra's words, Alex began pumping his cock in and out of Casey with a good amount of force. Casey was back to moaning as he slammed into her. It was Alex's turn to look over at the couple watching them. Debra had seemingly been inspired by what she saw because she had climbed onto Phil's lap and was grinding on his cock as they both watched him pound his wife. Debra had one hand on her clit and the other played with Phil's balls under her. Alex's cock pulled his attention back to his wife, it had been edged all night and was finally ready to erupt. He grabbed Casey's hips and fucked her harder. It only took a few more strokes before he was shooting ropes of cum into her, painting the walls of her pussy with his sperm. Casey moaned at the sudden sensation of warmth filling her. She'd just been creampied in front of an audience. Alex withdrew his cock from Casey's sloppy hole. Some cum dribbled out as he did. Casey stretched her legs and laid prone on the bed. Debra and Phil continued to fuck, giving Alex a moment to check in with Casey

"How do you feel baby?" Alex asked her as he knelt beside her.

"So goooood. That was really hot. I can't believe you ate my ass in front of people." She responded.

Alex smiled and shrugged "I thought it would be a fun first impression. I can't believe how hard you got off on it. Should we get dressed?"

Casey glanced over at Phil and Debra and decided to press her luck. "We cooooould, but I really could use another cock baby. I'm still horny" Casey faked a frown.

"I knew you wouldn't be able to resist!" Alex thought for a moment. "Alright, it's okay with me. I'm still a little turned on too and I want to see you take Phil's monster cock. Besides, I guess it's not really fair to call them strangers at this point."

They both confirmed that it was okay with each other once more and then Alex stood up. "Hey Debra, would you mind if my wife borrowed your husband's cock?"

Debra stopped bouncing on Phil's cock and smiled. "As long as it's okay with you guys!"

Phil lifted Debra from his cock and stood up. He did another round of checks with both Alex and Casey before getting on the bed. Alex took a seat on the couch beside Debra.

"You are going to enjoy this dear." They watched as Phil got into plank position over Casey and pointed his cock at her cum covered pussy. "And she is going to love it!"

Phil plunged his cock into Casey. "Holy... fuuuuuck..." Casey's mouth opened as Phil's cock sank into her, displacing her husband's cum as it filled every possible inch of space. Cum overflowed on all sides of her pussy. Finally after what felt like minutes she felt Phil's hips hit her ass, signaling that she had taken the entirety of his manhood. It helped that she was pre-stretched by Alex but this was a new level of fullness. It would have been almost painful if it didn't feel so incredibly good. Phil was nice enough to give her plenty of time to adjust to the length and girth of his cock, something he was surely used to doing. After a few moments Phil lifted his cock from Casey's depths back to the entrance. Casey felt emptiness like she had never felt before. It didn't last long as Phil buried his cock back into her, returning her to the feeling of overwhelming fullness.

Phil picked up his pace and found a moderate rhythm, fucking Casey prone into the mattress. "Oh my God... fuck!... so fucking huge..." Casey couldn't help but cry out as Phil fucked her. It was easily the biggest cock she'd ever taken and it was rubbing directly on her g-spot thanks to her position. "Yes fuck me... fuck me... youre gonna make me cum... please don't stop!" Casey was practically yelling out as Phil rammed his cock into her. She couldn't help but beg to be fucked. Phil pushed her harder into the bed and increased his pace. It was getting too much to handle, Casey needed to cum again. She looked up and saw Alex where Phil was previously seated. He was stroking his cock as he watched. Casey had been so focused on taking Phil's cock that she had temporarily forgotten that she was being fucked by another man in front of her husband. She had another man's cock in her pussy. And her husband was jerking off to it. She made eye contact with Alex which was enough to launch her into a powerful orgasm. "Oh fuuuuuuck baaaaby.... Huuuuuuuuuh... I'm cumming!" It felt like her entire body contacted, her pussy clamped around Phil's cock like a vice desperate for his cum. She might have squirted, she didn't have the capacity to tell as she moaned in bliss.

Phil again gave Casey a few moments to collect herself before taking action. This time he removed his cock from Casey and pulled her up to her knees gently. "We have a new audience!" Phil announced as he gestured to the window of the room where three people, a woman and two men, were watching. "Let's give them a better view!" Phil said with a smile. He laid down on his back."I want you to ride me reverse cowgirl."

Casey did as Phil asked and swung her leg over him. She once again made eye contact with Alex, who was still masturbating, and impaled herself on Phil's cock. She couldn't have hidden the pleasure from her face if she tried. Her eyes rolled up a little bit as she took the entire thing. She heard Alex mutter "Jesus Christ." as she bottomed out, sitting entirely on the cock below her. She ground her crotch back into Phil, driving the last little bit of his cock into her. He grunted in response.

"That's it Casey, now lean back and put your arms beside my chest so they can see your pussy take my cock." Casey again took Phil's instructions. Groaning as every motion stretched her in a new way. Once she was in position she started working up the cock in and out of her. Alex was transfixed on her pussy, to him it was the most beautiful thing in the world. Her pubic hair was a little matted with his cum but otherwise the perfect length and well kept. Her clit was protruding ever so slightly, engorged with her arousal. Her lips were red and swollen from being pounded by both men tonight. No matter how many times he saw it though Alex couldn't help but admire it. He had seen it hundreds, even thousands of times. But he had never seen it with another man's cock in it. They'd fantasized about it and used toys to mimic it. But this was real. His wife was sitting in front of him with her pussy on display, taking a cock that was not his. He was stroking himself to the scene and was nearly ready to cum despite cumming just ten minutes before.

"Fuck, I want both holes filled" Casey interjected, lifting herself from Phil. "Alex baby, come lay on the bed. I need you in my ass." The two men got into position. This time Casey lowered herself onto Alex's cock, allowing it to burrow all of the way into her ass. Casey groaned as she slid down. "Fuck that's good. Phil, fuck me hard!" Phil nodded and got between the couples legs and rubbed his cock on Casey's clit a few times just to tease her before shoving his cock back in. With Alex's cock in her ass she was nearly too tight for Phil's cock. Alex moaned as Phil's cock slid over top of his through his wife's walls. Not only was the sensation incredible, it was exhilarating knowing his wife had two cocks in her. Phil started thrusting, coaxing all three of them to orgasm with his motion. Each of them were moaning at different points on his cocks path. Casey was unable to think about anything beyond the two cocks stuffing her greedy holes. Her mouth hung open and her eyes were once again rolled up slightly, not in orgasm this time, but pure, sustained, sexual bliss. Phil was ready to cum. He increased his pace, pushing Casey up and down her husband's cock in the process.

"God I'm such a slut, fuck. Fuck me. Use my fuck holes" She cried out as an orgasm crashed over her. "Fuuuuuuck I'm cumming! Huuuuuuuh!" Casey quivered on the cocks, pushing them over the edge. Both men unleashed a torrent of cum into her, grunting in unison. Phil was the first to remove his cock, cum streamed out Casey's pussy and down Alex's shaft. After checking on the young couple he returned to his own wife who seemingly had an orgasm of her own while watching. Alex helped Casey off of his waning cock and got them some wipes and towels from the shelf.

The quad cleaned themselves up and tidied up what they could. Phil rejoined the young couple and offered to buy a round for the group before they left for the night. They filed out of the room and left for the bar. Alex and Casey would certainly have lots to discuss on their ride home tonight.