Chapter 5: In The Middle
Pony rolled off Amber with a deep, satisfied sigh. Amber chuckled. They curled up together, Amber caressing Pony's hairy chest, and Pony twirling a lock of her red hair between his fingers. They had just celebrated being together for two months.
-That was amazing, murmured Amber.
-Yeah... said Pony dreamily.
-You actually fulfilled an old fantasy for me, said Amber.
-Really? said Pony, kissing her neck. Tell me about it!
-I've never tried it anally before, said Amber.
-Really? Pony stopped kissing her and stared into her face. Why didn't you tell me? I could have been more gentle..?
-If you had hurt me, I WOULD have told you, said Amber reassuring, pinching him in the side, making him squirm.
Pony was very ticklish.
-Pony? said Amber.
-What, hon'?
-Tell me about one of your sexual fantasies.
-Ummmm...
-Come on! I told you one of mine...
-OK, OK! Actually, mine is not that different from yours...
Amber's eyes widened. Did he actually mean..?
-You mean you'd like some... anal stimulation? she said, smiling.
-Yeah... said Pony. I tried it once, with this girl... I'm telling you, I had such a fucking strong orgasm, I thought my dick was gonna explode!
-Well, we could do that, said Amber. I could use my fingers on you... or a butt plug... or we could have a threesome! You, me, and some other guy!
Pony surprised her by neither laughing nor getting disgusted by her remark. Instead, he bit his lip and looked deep into her eyes.
-That's another fantasy of mine, he blurted out.
Amber stared at him.
-I'm not queer or anything! said Pony. I've just... been curious, you know... what it would be like doing it with another guy.
-I think it sounds sexy, said Amber.
Pony's relief was obvious. He had been afraid of her reaction. He had never told anyone else about this fantasy before. No-one. Amber licked her middle finger.
-So, what would you like? she said, letting her hand glide down between Pony's legs, down to his butt, carefully inserting her wet finger inside his ass. Something like this..?
-Hmmm-mmm..? said Pony, turning his attention to her pussy.
-Welcome to my humble abode! said Amber, giggling. Well, mine and Andie's, actually!
She stepped into the living room of the small apartment that she and Andie were sharing at the dorm, and Pony and Johnnie walked in behind her. Pony was of course already accustomed to the place, after all, he had fucked Amber all over it for the past two months. Johnnie, however, Amber's good friend, a Hawaiian exchange student, looked around appreciatively.
-Nice, Amber, he said, with his soft, masculine voice. Real nice.
Pony was bewildered. Amber had asked him out, but when he met her, she had brought along this other guy – a friend, she said – and that guy had been with them all night, drinking, dancing... He was a great guy, no problem there, but why had Amber brought him back with them to the dorm? He had thought that they would be naked in bed by now, not entertaining... waaaaaait a minute!
-I'm going to get us some wine, said Amber.
-I'll go with you, said Pony.
The minute they got into the kitchen, he grabbed her arm and turned her towards him.
-What are you up to? said Pony.
-What do you mean? said Amber, looking at him innocently.
-Don't give me that! said Pony. I know you. Just what have you planned?
-Well... said Amber. Remember when we talked about our most secret fantasies?
-What about it? said Pony.
-You said, that you've always been curious about what it would be like to be with another man, said Amber. So... I talked to Johnnie, and we agreed on this... double date. If you want, you can have your fantasy come through tonight. If you don't want to, we'll just have a drink, chat a bit, and then he'll go.
-Oh, fuck! said Pony, stepping away from her, staring at her. Fuck you, Amber! Why didn't you tell me in advance?
-Because I didn't want you to go on and on about it, said Amber. Saying yes, you want to, no, you can't, yes you can, no, you can't... This way, we're rid of all that. Either you want it, and we do it, or you don't want to, and then we don't do it.
Pony blew out air through his pointed lips, and stared up into the ceiling. His whole being was in a state of chaos. He walked up to the half-closed door and peeped into the living room, where Johnnie sat down on the couch, stretching out his long body, resting an arm on the back of the couch. He looked around, appreciatively.
-Can we trust him? said Pony.
-Oh, yes, said Amber. He's a good friend of mine. Besides, you really think he'd go around telling everyone that he's bisexual? He won't say anything if we don't.
-OK, said Pony.
-You wanna do it? said Amber.
-Yes, said Pony.
Amber took out the wine and three glasses out into the living room, and put them down on the coffee table.
-OK, you guys sit down and relax, while I go and change into something a little more... comfortable, said Amber. And then we can start playing...
She left, and Pony sat down next to Johnnie, embarrassed and nervous. Amber's words had been a clear sign to Johnnie that Pony had accepted their idea of a threesome. A threesome with himself in the middle!
-Want some more wine? asked Pony.
-No thanks, said Johnnie. I don't want to drink too much.
Pony poured himself a glass. He needed something to give him courage to go through with this.
-OK, I'm done! said Amber, and came out of the bedroom.
The two young men gasped for breath. Amber had changed into a black corset with a garter belt and thin, black stockings. She wasn't wearing any underwear. Her red curls gleamed under the black lace.
Pony got up and walked up to her. He kissed her, and she put her arms around his neck. Pony's hands slid across her voluptuous body, over the large breasts and down to squeeze her full, rounded ass. Johnnie went behind Amber and inhaled the scent of her warm skin and newly washed hair. His left hand slid under her corset and played with one of her nipples, and the other explored her moist, bushy pussy. He spread kisses over her shoulders.
Amber caressed her lovers, wrapped her arms around them, leaned backwards and kissed Johnnie. Pony pulled the corset down and sucked on her nipples, one at a time. Johnnie took his shirt off. Amber turned around and licked his neck, his collar bones, his chest; nibbled his nipples, and caressed his flat stomach. Pony kneeled behind her, and buried his face in her wet crotch. He parted her legs so he could reach better, parted her nether lips and licked around the wet opening. Amber moaned. Johnnie opened the zipper of his pants and took out a slim but long, semi-erect cock. Amber took it in her mouth and Johnnie fucked her mouth with slow, long thrusts.
Seeing her deep-throating Johnnie's cock like that made Pony hard. He dove back down between her legs, licked her pussy, and put a finger inside her and began to move it in and out.
Amber could hardly concentrate on sucking Johnnie while Pony was giving her such a nice treatment. She groaned as she came, and her well-trained muscles squeezed Pony's finger.
-How about we get a little more comfortable? said Johnnie.
They went into Amber's bedroom. Johnnie stepped out of his pants, and revealed a slim and smooth body, tanned and hairless. Pony pulled off his T-shirt, slightly nervous, yet relaxed, due to the wine. Johnnie and Amber sat down on each side of him on the bed. Amber caressed his chest and Richard pulled his hand through Pony's hair.
-You're so tense, said Amber. Are you feeling nervous?
