I felt him nod aggressively. "Hell yes!" he said, louder than he thought he was being. I moved my hips up and down, grinding my wetness against his rigid cock. It throbbed against my clit and I couldn't hold back and longer. I manipulated his cock with my body, positioning the head against my opening and pushed. It pressed inward against my lips and finally passed through them to my opening. I let the head slip past the ring and inside, and he groaned at the heat on his cockhead. Slowly I sank lower, letting it slide inch by inch deeper inside me. His breath was heavy and he pushed upwards, our thighs meeting as he entered me completely.
I squeezed the walls of my cunt around his cock, gripping it tightly. He let out a moan. "You like that?" I asked in a teasing whisper. "A lot better than jacking off while you watch me sleep, isn't it?" I rocked up and down on his cock, clenching it with my pussy each time I impaled myself on it. He didn't answer. He must have been too caught up in the moment.
I let his hands go and slid my hands down his chest, grazing through the curly hair that lightly covered the center of his chest. I pressed my hands flat on his chest firmly, sitting upwards to give myself better leverage to slowly rock up and down on him. As soon as I had let go of his wrists and sat up, his hands were on the small globes of my ass, squeezing tightly and guiding my hips up and down as he continued thrusting up to meet me.
My wetness leaked down his cock and through his pubes. His balls, now soaked with the sweet sticky nectar he was forcing me to produce, pressed against my ass with each thrust. I was so wet, fucking this younger guy. My best friend's younger brother. I thought of how innocent he was, now losing that innocence to me. Though he wasn't really that innocent. No boy is.
I rose up a bit higher than I wanted to and his cock slipped out of my pussy. It was rock solid, however, and stuck straight up, pointed at my holes. As I went to impale myself back on it, it slipped against my pussy lips and about 2 inches of it slid inside my ass. Both his cock and my asshole had been so wet from my cum that it slipped in effortlessly.
I stopped before it slid completely in, almost collapsing from the shock onto his chest. The sudden blast of pain shot through my body instantly and I almost screamed. I, myself, froze, not knowing what to do. I didn't want to just yank myself off of him, but I also didn't want to push more of it inside me. "What's wrong? What happened?" he asked me, his hands still gripping my ass and spreading my cheeks apart.
"You're in my ass!" I whispered loudly.
"Oh my god! I'm so sorry!" he whispered back. He started to move, but I pressed my hands against his chest, pushing him back down on the bed.
"Don't move," I said. "It's ok. I did it by accident. It's my fault." Suddenly, I realized that the pain was gone. His cock was a third of the way inside my backdoor and it was starting to feel good. As the walls of my ass had stretched and were slowly getting used to the feeling of him inside me, I decided that I wanted more. I had never done anal and always wanted to. At least his cock was a normal size and wouldn't hurt as bad as one of the larger ones my pussy had had the pleasure of milking.
I switched back into naughty mode. "You want it?" I asked. "You want my ass you dirty little perv?" I teased, pressing back against his cock letting another third of the length slide up into me. I groaned and he grunted at the tightness. His hands spread my cheeks and without warning he took control and slammed the rest of his cock up my ass and held me down on it forcefully.
I let out a low groan, my pussy soaking his abdomen as I came hard. With one hand on his chest to steady myself, I reached down with the other one and furiously rubbed my clit. I squeezed and contracted my muscles and he grunted again as he felt my ass grip his cock tight. He pulled his cock halfway out and then pushed back in.
The pain was now a mixture of discomfort and an immense pleasure. It was hard to wrap my mind around the mixture of emotions I was feeling. As he slowly but steadily began pumping in and out of my tight pink asshole, his cock stretching me, another orgasm built from deep inside of me. I panted as he began to pump harder and faster, pistoning in and out of my ass as I diddled my clit and let out a low moan. It was overwhelming. I came so hard again, gushing clear sweet cum which covered his stomach and my thighs. I fought to catch my breath, my hand pulling away from my cunt and clutching my heaving chest. I shuddered and shook, tears streaming down my face as I whimpered loudly.
He thrust hard, and I heard him grunting roughly as he gave one hard fucking motion with his cock, slamming it up inside me as deep as it would go before pumping shot after shot of thick cum inside my ass. I continued to ride my lengthy orgasm as I felt his cock throb as it unloaded his sticky wet balls up inside me, filling me up. I felt his cum leak out past his pulsing dick and trickle down to mix with mine.
My body contined to shiver and shake as I came down from my orgasm. We both breathed heavily, panting and dripping with sweat and cum. He slid his cock out of my ass and it rested on my ass cheeks. My hole was sore, but it was worth it. It felt amazing. I collapsed onto him, resting my head on his chest.
"That was fucking amazing!" I said to him as I curled up and rested, catching my breath. My head rose and fell in time with his chest and I curled my fingers through his chest hair. I wrapped my leg around him as I my body melted off of his and I laid beside him resting on his chest for what seemed like hours. He held me in his arms in the silence, the discomfort and slight pain of my freshly abused ass slowly subsided.
I looked over at the clock after awhile and saw that it was 4:30AM. I slowly sat up and his hand touched mine. "I have to go back to the living room. I don't want your sister waking up to find us like this," I whispered. He sat up as I pushed off the edge of the bed to stand. My legs were weak and I leaned my hand on the bedside for stability as I tried to regain my composure.
I made my way slowly across the room to the door and reached down, grabbing my clothes. I redressed and tip-toed back to his bed. Leaning down, I caressed his face and we kissed for the first time. It was soft and sweet and when I pulled away, I whispered, "Thank you. That was incredible." He smiled and I kissed his cheek one last time before turning and making my way back to the door.
As I turned to close it behind me, I whispered to him, "Good night." I tip-toed back to the living room and crawled back into my sleeping bag. I was still feeling light-headed as I laid back, covering myself up good this time. I didn't want the scent of me and Aaron's cum lingering in the air for Hailey so smell. I turned over and closed my eyes, exhausted.
In the morning, we woke up and Hailey's father made us breakfast. As I sat at the table next to Hailey, Aaron walked in and flashed a smile at me as he reached into the fridge for some orange juice. He sat across from me and looked at me with hungry eyes. His bare feet caressed the edge of my ankle under the table and I gave him a light kick. I smirked at him and glared, motioning slightly to Hailey. He smirked back and we stopped our little dance for the time being.
Later, when I was getting ready to leave, I brushed my teeth in the bathroom and as I was walking by the laundry room, I saw Hailey's dad standing in front of the open washing machine. He had been loading laundry, but stopped, holding up my sleeping bag. He raised it to his face and inhaled deeply, taking in the smell I left behind. He moaned as he exhaled and suddenly he froze as he saw me watching him. I smiled and his eyes widened.
I was about to turn around and walk away when he said, "I'm sorry about last night Lindsey. I know you saw me watching you, and I apologize. I couldn't help it." He shook with nervousness, and I raised my hand above me using it to lean on the door frame to catch my balance. It was him that had watched me and jerked off in the living room. Not Aaron! I was shocked. Hailey's dad had cum while watching me sleep.
I saw how nervous he was while he apologized and suddenly found myself feeling bad. I looked behind me up and down the hallway. No one was around. I slowly walked forward towards him. He froze, dropping the sleeping bag. I pressed myself against him, reaching down to grab his cock through his pajama pants. I felt the thickness and length of it began to get harder. I looked up at him with my baby blue eyes wide and innocent and I bit my lower lip. I leaned up and pressed my cheek against his as I whispered in his ear, "Next time I sleep over, don't let me catch you jacking off." I looked into his eyes as I pulled away. "There's no need to waste a perfectly good load of hot daddy cum by stroking this big thick cock, when my wet pussy would feel so much better wrapped around it than your own hands do." His mouth gaped open and his eyes were wide with shock. I gave his now hard cock a tight squeeze around the shaft through his pajamas and turned around, walking away.