This is Chapter Two of a five chapter story. Each chapter will feature some of the main, framing story of a bartender and a girl in a bar in modern times and also a full fantastical tale that one of them tells the other about one of their relatives. Both of their families are from the Appalachian Mountains of Tennessee and Kentucky, so the stories are told in the style of those cultures. The stories they tell are more than just tall tales - they'll be important to the bigger plot as well. In Chapter One, "The One I Love the Best," Jolene won a bet with bartender John that she knew a story he'd never heard before. Now it's his turn.
*****
Don't Sing Love Songs
"Stories are what I really love the best." Jolene was standing, leaning back against the bar on both freckled elbows. Even the wan February sun streaming in through the front window could set her hair afire. It glowed the color of fine bourbon in the bottle and the actual bourbon in her glass, what little was left of it, turned gold.
"You sure about that?" I walked to where the jukebox hunched against the wall and started looking for the song I needed. "Looks to me like you're enjoying that bourbon an awful lot. If you're expecting a story that can stand against that pleasure, well, I'm not sure I can deliver. Been a while since I had Buffalo Trace, might be better than any story I've got."
"You wanna taste to be sure?" Ice clinked in her glass. I cast a quick look over my shoulder, just an instinct, like a rabbit peering around to see a hawk bearing down. She was holding one of the ice cubes from the glass to her lips. Her pink tongue darted out underneath it to catch the watered-down bourbon drip before the whole cube disappeared inside her mouth and she crunched it apart. "Looks like you're either going to have to come have it off my lips or pour another we can share."
My laugh came out as an uncertain wheeze on the front end before catching. Her red lips, her pink tongue were enough to wobble my orbit a touch, but it was the realization that they'd never come without the snap of her teeth that set me along my edge. I turned back to the glowing screen of the digital jukebox and found the song I needed. It would play next, enough time for me to get back behind the psychological safety of the bar.
"Are we gonna dance?" Jolene didn't bother to turn her body towards me. She looked over her shoulder as I had just done, but that was where all similarity in the movements ended. Her turn was deliberate, almost languid. Her arched eyebrow was a challenge everywhere it wasn't an invitation.
"I sure hope we will," I answered, "but not to this song. It's not really for dancing." That was the very moment those first few notes of guitar started, the ones instantly familiar to anyone who's ever listened to a Golden Oldies radio station or owned a Casio keyboard. She turned to face me full then, understanding that I had shifted it all. I stood in my place behind my bar, I'd reset the mood with the song, and I had a secret she suddenly wanted but couldn't get without letting me speak my piece. The singer laid into the lyrics with the kind of well-bottom sadness you'd never believe a British guy with a terrible haircut could muster.
There is a house in New Orleans, they call The Rising Sun.
"Yeah, you're right. This is no dancing kind of song." She settled back into her stool.
It's been the ruin of many a poor boy, and God, I know, I'm one.
"You know that song, don't you? Sure you do." I wanted to pick up a glass and a towel to polish it with to give my hands something to do, but it seemed to on-the-nose for my role as tale-spinning bartender. I poured myself a Coke instead.
"John, everybody with ears knows that song."
"Bet I know something about it that you don't, though."
"Bet what?"
"Another drink." I tipped my Coke too fast and the ice shifted, gracelessly soaking my mustache in a cold line just above my lip. "If you've ever heard this story before, I'll pour you another bourbon."
"How will you know I'm not just saying I have?" She set her crossed arms against the bar, under her breasts. I thought about running my tongue just under the edge of her tank top, from one strap to the other.
"I'll just have to trust you. Same way you trusted me to own up when I'd never heard your story before."
"It's not balanced, though," she frowned at me. "You tell me a story I've never heard, I win. You tell me a story I've heard before, you pour me a drink, I win. Where do you win in this, John?"
"If I tell you something you've never heard before?" I leaned close to her ear across the bar, close enough I could feel the trimmed hair of my beard compressing against her cheek. I brushed her earlobe with my mustache and raised a reflexive shiver from her that was in no part due to my mishap with the ice. "You'll dance with me to a different song when I'm done."
"I'm listening." It was near a sigh, the sound of her settling in as my audience.
This was the story I told Jolene that made her dance with me.