((This is Chapter One of a five chapter story. Each chapter will feature some of the main, framing story of a bartender and a girl in a bar in modern times and also a full fantastical tale that one of them tells the other about one of their relatives. Both of their families are from the Appalachian Mountains of Tennessee and Kentucky, so the stories are told in the style of those cultures. The stories they tell are more than just tall tales - they'll be important to the bigger plot as well. I hope you enjoy these tales half as much as I enjoy similar stories by Manly Wade Wellman, whose Silver John stories made me want to write.))
*****
The One I Love the Best
It was always Thursday when these things happen at the bar, always when I was filling the well bottles and breaking down cardboard boxes with a knife that wouldn't cut cold butter. It was like a secret song summoned wild things up out of the past of the hills, one that slid in under the strains of the old country standards I played all afternoon on the digital jukebox.
Your Cheatin' Heart
played.
He Stopped Loving Her Today
played. There were only three other people in the bar, drinking, and they looked like they needed those old, sad songs exactly as much as I did, but for a different reason. I needed them for their incredible power to plumb those artesian wells of East Tennessee weirdness with the sound of slides across steel guitar strings. When I made out the schedule for the week, I put myself on Thursday afternoons to back the bar alone and nobody else cared because the tips were terrible. They had never seen a blind guy's seeing-eye dog run off with another man's prosthetic leg.
That's what happened
last
Thursday.
I had my back to the door when jukebox Dolly Parton started begging Jolene not to take her man. I must have, since I didn't see the girl until she was already sitting there with her elbows on the bar and her chin propped in her upturned palms, puffy coat shrugged off onto the back of her chair revealing her thin tank top and no bra to speak of underneath. Of course she was wearing a tank top in the middle of February. I'd never seen her wear anything
but
a tank top. She had as many freckles from her wrists down as a winter night on the mountains has stars.
"Well," I said, smiling in surprise, "flaming locks of auburn hair, ivory skin, and eyes of emerald green." And, just as the song said, her beauty was beyond compare.
"I love it when you play my song, John."
"Jolene, what am I about to ask you?"
"Whether I want my bourbon water back or on the rocks?" She tilted her head and smirked.
"Noooo..." I drew out the syllable even as I drew closer to her. I leaned down, set my elbows against the bar, and mirrored her. "I'm going to ask if I missed you turning twenty-one. You're too young to be here, Jo, too young by two years last I checked."
"But John," she near sang. The way her lips pursed around the "O" in my name could have boiled snow. "What's a drink gonna hurt?"
"Hurt me plenty when I go to jail and they fine my ass back to rags for serving underage."
She cut those glass-green eyes to the right at the guy sitting ten feet down at the corner of the polished oak bar. "Randall, you a cop?"
"No ma'am," the old flannel-wrapped man said, looking away from his beer. "I hope to never be."
"Pete, you a cop?" She turned away from me to look behind her at the guy who comes in from open to happy hour three times a week to read Clive Cussler novels in peace. I don't keep the TVs on in the bar if I can help it.
"Nope," he said without looking up from the yellowed page he was turning. "Junior's in the bathroom, but he's so far from a cop he's a felon. John, give that girl a drink. Nobody here got any problem with Jolene having a drink but you."
Her triumphant smile broke open over the slight crook in her front teeth. I rolled my eyes at her.
"I can't sell you alcohol. It's not going to happen." I started off as a bouncer here, before I learned anything about bourbon. I can still push my palms against the insides of my biceps, square my shoulders, and speak with the authority that makes people change their course with a quickness.
"Don't sell me anything, then." She leaned forward across the bar and stroked her long fingers down the front of my t-shirt. Every hair on my chest electrified. "Trade it to me."
"Trade?"
"Sure," she purred, her nose inches from mine. "I got something I know you want."
Did she ever! I had a split-second of absolute certainty. I would pour Randall, Pete, and Junior each a finger of Old Granddad, then tell them to kindly take a hike. I'd lock the door and let Waylon Jennings sing out from the jukebox about his love for a girl named Amanda while I finally got to see every inch of pale skin and every rusty freckle that ever teased from under Jolene's tank top and cut-offs. I'd have the perfect fiddle curves of her back beneath my hands while I made her gasp at my thickness parting her tight folds. How long could I keep the bar closed before people pounded on the door to be let in? Maybe I'd just throw her over my shoulder and take her back to my apartment. It was only two blocks away. Hell, I'd carry her back up whatever mountain her people came down from just to part those long, creamy thighs with my cheek and hear what she sounded like when she came.
Then I remembered how much I didn't want to go to jail.
"No, Jo, I'm pretty sure serving you bourbon in that kind of trade is whole other kind of illegal."
"What could ever be so bad about a story?"
"A...story?" Her tone was teasing, but I was certain that's what she said.
"That's what I know you love the best, John. What you want." She barely spoke the last word, it floated on a soft exhalation right into my ear. "One of them old mountain stories."
"Like the Flat? Waiting to wrap around me in the shadows?" I laughed, walking around the short side of the bar. Knowing what game Jolene was playing made me want to run the scores up a bit. "Or maybe the Tailypo, circling my cabin in the night?" I leaned against her back, gripping the bar to either side of her and whispering against her red hair in a voice I made creak like an old screen door, "Tailypo, tailypo, give me back my
tailypo
!"
"Not bad," she leaned her head back against my shoulder. Our cheeks were almost touching and I swear I felt sparks arc between them. "You sound like a nice old lady telling haint stories."
"Like your grandma, maybe?"
"Nope." She swiveled on her stool suddenly and pressed the tip of her nose against mine, her pupils crowned with gold in her feral green irises. "My old gran's near as mean as me."
She called my bluff before I was full-aware that bluffing was what I was doing. I had seventy pounds of (mostly) muscle on Jolene, but in the half dozen times she'd been in my bar trying to scam a drink, I had the distinct feeling she could snap all my bones like a stack of sticks if I hit the wrong wild note inside her. I backed away, but tried to cover it by going to the jukebox and cuing up some serious bluegrass. If Jo wanted to spin out a mountain story, she might as well have the fiddle riffs to run it on. I took my place again behind the safety of the bar.
"I don't care if you look as good as you think you do, I'm not trading good bourbon for some old haint tale I could hear at the county fair."
"What if it's one you never heard before?"
"Not likely," I snorted. "I've heard them all. All the little variations, too."
"Heard 'em all? Says who?" The idea seemed to genuinely offend her.
"The ethnomusicology department of the University of Tennessee, for one." Even wrinkling her nose in confusion she was one of the most beautiful girls I'd ever seen. "But they only gave me a Master's. Maybe there are a few more stories you get to hear when you go for the Ph.D."
"You got a college degree in