One Wednesday night late in August we wrapped up a little earlier that usual. Mack still had not finished his duties so we did some busy work to pass the time. He seemed to be stalling too for some reason. Finally Rev asked if he was staying late he said that he would be leaving in about 30 minutes. We decided to go out for ice- cream and then return. When we got back, Mack's car was gone and the church doors locked. Rev found his spare key and we went into the building toward the back room. We finished our Ice cream and then started our usual "heavy petting". The Good Reverend was in rare form that night. As usual he sucked my puffy breast until they ached; but then he got a notion to fuck them.
I thoroughly enjoyed being able to watch his fat dick up close and personal and I squeezed my tits together to make yet another mock pussy. I licked the head as it peeked through my tits with every stroke. He loved it; shortly afterward I was wearing pearls. The sight of cum dripping from my plump reddish brown, now tender nipples, made him crazy. I didn't really think he would come that way. I think he was surprised too. He had always been obsessed with my large tits and freakish nipples but it had never occurred to him to him to fuck them before.
The combination of him coming hard and the rich ice cream made him a little sluggish. So after I went to clean up, we spooned there on the cushions awhile and he started to doze. Suddenly I felt eyes and the heat of someone else nearby. Looking into the door we had only partially closed was Mack. I wasn't surprised at all to see that he was Masturbating. I sat up and Rev stirred a little. I was embarrassed but relieved that it was just crazy-ass Mack, and not one of the other church members.
"Mack what you doing here?"
"I forgot my tools." He said.
Then he brazenly opened the door. In an instant the Reverend was awake. He looked at Mack as if he were a ghost.
"Mack close the door man!"
"I need a taste Rev, just a taste." He said in an eerily, calm voice.
"What you talking 'bout man get out!"
"You know what I'm talking 'bout."
He reached again for his dick which was sticking out of his fly, then he began to slowly stroke it while staring at me.
"Get out Mack I mean it."
"No I need a taste, Mr. Rev Perfect, Just a taste."
He looked at Rev with contempt but envy. The implication behind him calling Rev "Mr. Reverend Perfect" was perfectly clear. Mack was going to be a pussy extortionist. Rev continued to argue with him but Mack would only repeat over and over:
"Just a taste Rev, just a taste."
In spite of all the drama his dick was rock Hard. He was actually stroking it the whole time he and the Reverend argued. Rev tried to physically push him out of the room, but he pushed back, and pushed hard. In a moment Rev's bare ass was on the floor and Mack was coming toward me. Mack was a very horny determined man. Rev was still on the floor and looked embarrassed, probably about being disrespected by the janitor but also at being caught off guard. I was actually getting more nervous than embarrassed, and I was growing really concerned for our safety. It looked to me like Mack might be cranking up to crazy. I had heard how volatile he could be and I just didn't want proof. So I decided to humor him.
Mack what you wanna do? "
"I just wanna suck those fat tittles and put my dick in you for two minutes that's all then I'm gone".
He said it as if he felt once his mission was accomplished, all would be well in his world.
"Mack" Rev said, "you can't do that brother"
"You doing it." He spat, looking over his shoulder at Rev.
It was futile trying to explain that we never actually fucked. So again I decided to humor him.
"Mack you have a condom? You know you can't be getting me pregnant "I said jokingly.
Rev looked at me in a combination of disbelief, and then sheer jealousy. I loved it!
Well apparently Mack had been a Boy Scout. He not only had the usual single condom, but three condoms in his wallet. He let go of his dick just long enough to fish them out for me to see. Oh shit! I thought. I told him to put one on. Then I lay back on the cushions and started to rub my thighs and play with myself like I had seen the porn queens do it. Just two minutes he had said, I could definitely make it short and sweet. Hopefully he would leave us alone and not tell since he too would be involved.
Unfortunately The Good Reverend had not completed his homework that evening so I was genuinely kind of hot. I thoroughly enjoyed the titty fuck earlier but I decided that titty fucking was definitely a spectator sport. My pussy was hungry. It was at that moment I realized that though I thought I truly loved and wanted The Reverend, what I wanted as much was to take the leap into womanhood. My God! I was 22 years old. For once I wanted to feel a man hot and hard inside me. The titty fuck had only served to start a fire. Granted, raggedy mouth Mack was not my firefighter of choice, but his hose was starting to look pretty damn good.
Mack's Dick also had a nice sized head on it. It was not as thick as Rev's but thick enough, and possibly a whole inch longer. He seemed very proud of it. Rev was obviously uncomfortable and embarrassed about Mack being in control, but he was strangely cooperative. I lay on the cushions and continued to play with myself and wiggle my hips a la Vanessa del Rio. Then I reached down and spread my pussy wide. Short and sweet I kept thinking. Oddly I loved the attention and I felt I was proving myself a woman. Mack looked at me hungrily then removed his pants and underwear. His bony legs and big dick seemed to be all about the same size. He put on one of the condoms and knelt down between my legs. I watched his dick bounce suddenly as he put his elbows under my knees and lifted my hips in the air.
Slowly at first he slipped just the tip of his tongue between my slit. Then with light gentle strokes he licked my clit and watched for my reaction. I felt raging heat and my clit grew hard and tight. Suddenly he started to eat my pussy as if it was his last meal. He was ravenous. Damn! I had heard about it, and I had even seen it on cable, but that was the first time I had ever had my pussy eaten. I thought Rev was creative but that beat anything he had ever done. My pussy was throbbing my nipples were like pebbles and I was enjoying his tongue so much that I did not even realize that The Good Reverend was watching it all with his dick in his hand. I got even more turned on then. I pulled Mack's head down deeper into my pussy and started to push up as hard as I could into his face. Which only made him hungrier. Next he gently put me down and started to work on the tits he so worshipped. He proceeded to tell me that he often dreamt about my "bresses," and that it was his intention to milk my titties or suck them until they were twice their size. Well not quite, but he damn sure tried. I felt my pussy contract over and over from his expert tongue on my tits.
Mack's two minutes had long been up, but neither one of us was counting. The next thing I knew his dick was in his hand once again. He pushed me back on the cushions and in an instant he was working his way inside my welcoming pussy. He looked surprised to feel some resistance, I guess he was prepared for his usual smooth and easy entry. Suddenly I could tell from the look on his face that he realized I was a "technical Virgin." I was actually ashamed.
Now a gentleman would have backed away as the Good Reverend had done so many times; obviously Mack was no gentleman, but he gazed into my eyes in the most tender way, and gently whispered:
"Hold on baby, just hold onto me"
He reached down for his dick and carefully placed it at the door where the Reverend had stood so many times. He grabbed both of my hands so that I would brace myself. Then he pushed once, drew back, pushed again and drew back one last time and he was in. The pain was awful and I began to moan. Rev came over and tried to move him off me but Mack wasn't having it. I assured Rev I was OK and asked Mack to just give me a minute. He was still surprisingly tender and was making only small shallow strokes back and forth and round and round inside my hot, wet but sore pussy. The small strokes had the effect of loosening me up and also spreading my natural lube. I almost giggled at watching his wiry body rotate so sensuously, but I had to admit the "crazy man" had skills. He bent over to lick my breast again, then he blew on my neck as if to cool me off while I got myself together.
Suddenly he withdrew all the way, lifted my knees as before and proceeded to feast on my clit and pussy again. Soon my hips were spinning and I was begging for his big dick. He then grabbed it and shoved in hard inside me. It hurt so good. He started to fuck me fast and hard, I begged for more and grabbed his ass to make sure he stroked every inch of my newly deflowered pussy. He gladly obliged and I fucked him back as hard as I knew how.
"Oh my God, Oh my God, Oh God! Ohhhhhhhh, Take this good hot pussy Mack, Take it Mack, Take it Mack. I been saving it just for you."