This story started a few years ago when I was dating Cindy, a gorgeous 38-year-old blonde. She had always reminded me of Stevie Nicks in a way. Cindy was in the process of finishing her degree at the same time that she was going through a very nasty divorce. Not very long after I had started seeing her, she lost her job and had her car repossessed. In short, she was having a very difficult time.
In order to help her out, I offered her a job. Being that we lived a fair distance from one another and she did not have a car, I started staying the night with her and driving her to school in the morning, waiting for her and then we would go to work. Spending this much time together, the relationship soon became very intense. Everything was clicking, including our sex life!
At first, Cindy was very uncomfortable with me staying over because she had an 18-year-old daughter, Nikki. She was afraid that she would be sending the wrong message to her about pre-marital sex and such. Actually, Cindy was pretty uncomfortable about sex in general, at least at first. One of the reasons for this was that she had married young and had never had a very unsatisfying sex life with her husband. She described it as ânon-existentâ. As our relationship grew and Cindy became more aware of what a âgoodâ sex life could be like, her inhibitions lessened. Before long, we were openly sharing her bed.
Like I said above, everything was clicking. Cindy was getting back on her feet and we were both having the time of our lives. Things just kept getting better and better. Including our sex lives. As time went on, she became more and more adventuresome in the bedroom. It was very playful and fun. We experimented with all kinds of different things, watching videos, oral sex (both giving and receiving); eventually she even wanted to experiment with anal. In essence, she was experimenting with just about anything sexual. Which led us to experimenting with role-play.
One night before going to bed we were folding laundry and Cindy took Vickiâs cheerleading outfit out of the basket and was holding the dress up to her body as she brushed some small wrinkles out. As she did this, I let out a soft wolf whistle and teasing told her that she would look sexy in that outfit. She told me to cut it out that she would never be able to fit in it and that she would feel uncomfortable wearing Vickiâs things for my sexual enjoyment. I dropped it and we continued talking until the laundry was all put away.
Later that night, after having gone to bed, Cindy asked me if I would really enjoy seeing her in the cheerleading outfit. I told her that I would indeed! She made me promise that I wouldnât tell anybody and slipped out of bed and out of the room. When she returned she was wearing the outfit and had put her long blonde hair up in pigtails. She looked all the part of the high school cheerleader. I called her to the bed and we proceeded to make out. I was very excited by the scene. As we kissed and petted, she asked me if she really looked like a teenager. I told her that yes she did and continued to rub her full breasts through the material of the sweater. As my hands explored her body I flipped the skirt up and rubbed on her pussy through the material of the matching panties that went with the outfit. She told me that she felt like she was a teenager making out in the back of some boyâs car. As I proceeded to undress her, I ran with that scenario and pretended to be a high school stud, making it with the hot young cheerleader.
She got into her role too. She pretended to be a nervous virgin and made me âseduceâ her. Much like two teenagers in the back of a car, I went from first base to second base and then to third, where she âattemptedâ to stop me. I retreated and went back to the safety of second base. Kissing and sucking on her firm, full titties and massaging the inside of her thigh. Slowly, I moved my fingertips back up to where they were massaging her pussy through the thin material of the panties. Eventually, I removed her sweater completely and kissed my way down her stomach and began licking and nibbling her pussy through that same material. Between the moisture from my mouth and her pussy juices as she became more and more excited, the panties became soaked.
I pulled the elastic aside and started fingering her. First with one finger, then two and eventually three. All the time, still licking her clit area through the material. As she got into the sex more and more, she didnât seem to notice me pulling her panties down and going to work on her clit minus the panties. The panties fell on top of the skirt and sweater at the side of the bed.
I continued to eat her until she had an enormous and loud orgasm. I then climbed on top of her and slid my throbbing member into her. With my entering her she continued in what seemed like a series of orgasms. I fucked her hard and with abandon. Unnoticed by us the headboard was pounding into the wall that separated Cindyâs room from Vickiâs. After several minutes of this pace, I came and collapsed on top of her. Rolling over, I took her into my arms and we just laid there, breathing hard and recuperating. I think that both of us were totally surprised that we had gotten so carried away!
As we laid there, Cindy asked me if I had enjoyed myself. I joked with her that it had been âalrightâ. To which she punched me and teasingly told me that now that she knew that I was into such âyoungerâ women, that she would have to watch me around Vicki. I told her that she was out of her mind! She said, âRight! That she had seen me checking Vicki out before. I told her that she was nuts, that I wasnât a pedophile. She said that Vicki was 18, so it wouldnât be being a âpedophileâ. I told her that she didnât have anything to worry about, that I would never look at Vicki that way! She said, âBullshit! That there wasnât a heterosexual man alive who wouldnât at least sneak a peak at Vicki if she was wearing that cheerleading outfit.
Knowing that she was probably right, I finally agreed that if she were any other 18 year old hard body in that outfit, I probably would sneak a peak, but that would be it! This seemed to placate Cindy and kissed and rolled over to go to sleep. Later that night I awoke to the feeling of Cindyâs hand on my cock. She was jacking me off and my cock had already responded and was at itâs full length. Cindy nuzzled up to my ear and whispered, âBobbyâŠ. you canât tell me that if this was Vicki playing with your cock, that you would tell her to quitâ. Not being fully awake, I didnât know what to say. So, I just laid there. She continued to kiss me and play with my cock and then rolled on top of me, placing the head of my cock at the opening to her pussy. As she slid down on it, her face came to my ear and she said, âAh come onâŠ. Tell the truthâŠif this was Vicki, youâd fuck her wouldnât you?â
As she said this she slid her pussy down on my cock and back up really slowly. I could feel the sides of her pussy gripping the shaft of my dick. She whispered in a commanding sort of way, âTell me! Youâd fuck her, wouldnât you?â She started fucking me faster and faster and as she did, she looked me straight in the eye. This time she didnât whisper, she told me out loud, âTELL ME youâd fuck her, wouldnât you!â
I didnât know what to say? Iâm a kinky bastard, but this was too much! Did she really want me to tell her that I would fuck her daughter? Was this some kind of weird test? I didnât know? I guess that she saw my indecision and she again put her mouth to my ear and told me, âItâs alright, I want you to pretend that Iâm Vicki, please?â I said, âOkayâ and told her, âFuck me Vickiâ. With that she moaned and went back to riding me like a horse! As we fucked she rolled off of me and I had no choice but to follow her to where I was now back on top of her. She told me to tell her want I wanted to do.
I told her, âI want to fuck you Vicki!â And, âOh, Vicki, youâve got such a tight young pussy! Oh God, I want to fuck you!â and things to that accord. The dirtier I talked, the more Cindy got into it. The more she got into it, the more I did too! Soon, we were banging the headboard against the wall again! As she came, she cried out, âFuck me Bob! Fuck your little girl!â With that, I shot another load into Cindyâs tight little pussy!
Again, I rolled off of her and she reached up and kissed me tenderly on the lips and said, âThank you! I love you Bobbyâ. With that we rolled over. I laid there thinking about what had just happened. After a few minutes I heard the rythmatic sound of her breathing, telling me that she was asleep. As she laid there I looked at her and then at the bedroom door, which led to the hallway and then to Vickiâs room. For the first time, I actually did imagine what it would be like to fuck Vicki.
I imagined what it would be like if it were Vicki laying there next to me, not Cindy. What it would be like to reach over and run my hand over Vickiâs firm young ass. What it would be like to kiss her. To kiss my way down her supple body, to suck on her smaller, but very nice titties. To taste her sweet young pussy. To fuck her, like I had just fucked her mom. As I was thinking these things, I got hard again. Not bad for a forty year old guy! Trying not to wake Cindy, I jacked myself off to a third orgasm of the night. Fantasizing about fucking Cindyâs sweet little Vicki.
The following morning I awoke to the sound of a light knocking on the bedroom door. Without thinking Cindy told Vicki to come in. Vicki stepped into the bedroom wearing an oversized basketball jersey as a nightshirt. I sat up as Cindy asked her what she needed.
Vicki responded that she needed her cheerleading outfit and did Cindy know where it was. As she said this, her eyes looked down at the outfit and still damp panties piled next to the bed. Before Cindy could say anything, Vicki said never mind and retreated back out the door.
Cindy rolled over and told me âthatâs weird. Why does she need that outfit on a Sunday?â I responded that I didnât know. Thinking to myself that it was weird. She wouldnât have any games or other school activities on a Sunday? I also thought to myself that it was weird that Cindy didnât seem to have wondered what Vicki would have been thinking when she saw her cheerleading outfit rumpled on the floor next to her Momâs bed?â âOh well.â I thought to myself as I bent over and pulled on a pair of jogging shorts so that I could dash to the rest room.