I'm not sure how it started but eventually Brian, Mike and I would end up going out quite a bit together. Initially it was relatively innocent. We'd play miniature golf, maybe go to bar, just hang out really. Eventually though when we'd go out I'd end up dancing most of the night with Mike. We'd flirt a little bit and Brian would see us. Later Brian would ask about it and we would both get turned on by the thought of me doing something with Mike. I don't think we thought I'd fuck him but both of us enjoyed the idea of me giving him a hand job. Mike would tell me he had a big dick (locker room showers) and that intrigued me. As the summer went on we would go to the drive-in and I'd sit in the middle and flirt with Mike while Brian was sitting next to me. At some point Brian would always to leave to get popcorn (I know.. really) and while he was gone Mike and I would make out a little bit and I always made sure I'd rub his cock through his pants, getting him hard and turning me on. Eventually Brian would come back and other than sneaking in a few feels Mike and I would stop.
This went on for a few weeks. Brian, of course knew it was happening and encouraged me to keep it up. It was big turn on for both of us. I don't think Brian and Mike ever talked about it. But of course, Mike knew that Brian knew and finally one day after the three of us had been at the beach it was clear Mike wanted to finish what we were starting.
Mike had left his car at my house. Brian had to go to work so when Brian brought us back to my house it was time for Mike to come in. My mother and sisters were gone and when Brian left it was pretty clear that Mike and I were going get together. I was expecting Mike and I would make out and that I'd give him a hand job. I was not thinking we would fuck. I don't think Brian thought we would either. While we enjoyed all the flirting and play with Mike and stories about Matt I think both Brian and I thought we'd save the fucking for each other.
It didn't take long for Mike to make his move after Brian left. Up until then, probably because Brian was usually around I had been the aggressor with Mike. But this time, knowing he was gone Mike came right at me. We were passionately making out on my living room couch before Brian's car had left the driveway. I felt his hands move up my chest. We were already grinding away at each other when I moved my hand down to his pants and unbuckled his belt and grabbed his cock. He was already as hard as stone.
I was wearing a short jean skirt. One of Mike's hands had left my breast and was now rubbing my pussy. I wasn't planning on fucking him and when he tried to pull off my thong I told him no. He stopped. But his fingers still found his way into my cunt. I was very wet and I gripped his cock tighter and began to stroke. Soft moans were escaping from my lips. Mike positioned me under him and I assumed we were going to start dry humping. His cock was free but I still had my panties on though my skirt was now pushed up above my waist.
I felt Mike's weight on me and I spread my legs. I wanted badly to feel the hard pressure of his cock on my clit. Mike pushed himself up and down a couple of times, God, it felt good, and then I felt his fingers pull my thong aside. I felt Mike's cock bare cock press against my bare pussy. I started to say "no" but before I could get it out he slid deep into me on his first thrust. He slid deeper into me than I ever thought possible.
It usually took Brian two or three attempts to penetrate. But Mike was deep inside me in an instant and my body spasmed in pleasure. It was like nothing I had felt before. It felt like my pussy was on fire filled with a rod of hot steel. The no I had started to say turned into "oh goooodddd." After that I just remember pleasure as Mike fucked me hard until we both came in a way I never had. Mike filled my pussy with his cum and my cunt contracted around his cock again and again, milking all his seed deep into me. I wrapped my leg high around his back and we stayed like that for several minutes savoring the pleasure we had both just felt.
I didn't tell Brian right away. At first he thought we had just done the usual dry humping. When I did tell him about a year later he was pretty turned on. By then Brian knew something was very different about me. You know how they say marijuana is a gateway drug? Mike was my gateway fuck. We fucked a few more times that summer but when he left to go back to his school I knew I could never just fuck Brian anymore. I needed to fuck guys with big dicks and guys that knew how to use them.
Before that summer was over I had fucked Matt (home on leave) and my old high school history teach (mmhhmm). Eventually Brian heard about them, as well as a couple of his roommates. Brian knows about most of the guys I fucked. That first fuck with Mike opened our lives to a path I don't think either one of us ever expected.