It's late Sunday morning. Max and I have just returned home from the hotel. We are having coffee and reading the paper before we go out for brunch. Actually, Max is reading the paper. I'm just pretending.
An hour ago, I reached into my purse to retrieve my cell phone so I could charge the battery. Inside, I found a folded piece of paper. 'Call me,' it said in a decidedly female hand and provided a phone number. The note is unsigned, but I have no doubt that Erin found a way to slip it into my purse last night, either in the ladies room or after we returned to the table.
And there it was; that flutter in my stomach again. Erin represents the first time in my life that I've been sexually attracted to another woman. It was the same feeling I experienced last night. Since I met her for the first time less than twenty-four hours ago, this is all very disconcerting.
I don't keep secrets from my husband, at least not for very long. I have no idea why Erin wants me to call her, so I will wait to talk to Max when I find out what's going on. I'll look for an opportunity to call her and then decide what to do.
Visions of last night have been swirling in my head since awakening. Max and I enjoyed our first bondage experience with another couple at the Densmere Hotel in the city. We were matched up with Erin and Craig by the computer program that belongs to the organization we joined several months ago; one that links consenting adults who have unfulfilled sexual desires.
Our very first tryst occurred with Lacey and Scott so that I could indulge my fantasy; watching my husband fuck another woman. No suitable candidate was available, so our options were limited to other couples and we ended up having a four-way. It blew our minds, but we were unsure if we wanted to do anything like that again. If Max had not revealed his fantasy to me last week, one that involved him tying me up so another man could fuck me while he watched, we might never have engaged in couples sex again. And we certainly would not have met Erin and Craig for our first bondage experience outside our own bedroom.
What happened last night was almost unbelievable when reviewed in the light of day. I've spent much of the morning trying to add up the number of orgasms I had getting fucked by Craig and then by my husband. I'm having a little trouble coming up with a total because my recollection of what happened when Max fucked me with a butt plug in place is a little fuzzy. I think the correct number is six, or maybe seven. I am naturally inclined toward multiple orgasms, but last night was nothing like I've ever experienced before. Still, either six or seven seems like an outrageous number and either would be a new record for me by a wide margin.
Suddenly, Max sets his paper aside.
"I can't concentrate," he announces.
"Why not?"
"I can't completely wrap my head around what happened last night," he replies.
"Why not?" I repeat. "You and Craig planned the whole thing so you must have been certain of the outcome."
"That's true, about ninety percent of the evening went exactly as we intended. All of my fantasies about tying you up so another guy could fuck you were realized."
"So what's the issue?" I inquire, a little mystified.
"The butt plug thing was a crap shoot. I need to explain to you what that was all about," he answers.
"You don't need to explain anything to me," I counter with a smile. "I've never felt anything like that before. I'm not certain how many orgasms I had, but they were the most powerful I've ever experienced. And I've had some doozies."
"I know, I've been around for most of them," he says with a little smile.
"So what's the big deal?"
"Right up to the last minute before Craig and I entered the room, the evening wasn't supposed to end that way."
"Really?" Now I am both puzzled and curious. "How was it supposed to end?"
"Like we originally planned. Craig would do you throughout the entire evening and I would do Erin," Max replies. "We were not supposed to fuck our own wives."
"What changed?"
"Craig mentioned that he had come across a bondage article on the internet that said lots of women experience orgasms that are unprecedented in their intensity when a butt plug is involved. When he told me that, I immediately decided that I didn't want anyone but me to give you that much pleasure for the very first time. When I told him I was changing the ending to our evening, he readily agreed. It seems he may have been thinking the same thing, which is apparently why he brought up the subject to begin with."
"Well, if I'd had any idea how it was going to feel, I wouldn't have wanted anyone but you to do that to me, so I am thrilled that you made the change. If you hadn't, I would be sitting here right now being upset that a stranger had given me the most sensational orgasms of my life," I respond with a bit of a hammer thumping in my chest. "The original plan, with last night's outcome, would have been difficult for me to deal with."
"It was a close call," Max declares. "We almost blew it."
"Then, whatever we do in the future, let's ensure that you and I are the ones who do anything unusual, at least for the first time. If it's planned that way from the beginning, we won't have any more near misses," I suggest with a smile.
"You gotta deal, let's go to brunch."
****
"Haley, are you okay?" asks Max halfway through brunch. "You seem a little distracted."
"I'm fine," I reply, as I pile more cream cheese and lox on a bagel. "It's just that I keep replaying last night through my mind
"Yeah, well, me too," he responds. "Reach any conclusions?"
"Not really. But a question or two is running through my mind."
"Care to share?"
"Sure." Actually two questions are occupying my thoughts, one I'm willing to share right now, and one I'm not. "I've been wondering what's next for us."
"What do you mean?"
"Let me answer your question with a question. Do you have any interest in repeating our first encounter with Lacey and Scott?"
"You mean get it touch with them and do it again?"
"Not them in particular. I'm talking about doing pretty much the same thing but with a different couple."
"Been there, done that."
"Exactly," I tell him. "We were responding to a particular fantasy of mine that has now been satisfied. Doing the same thing would not be nearly as exciting a second time around."
"And last night we took care of my fantasy."
"We did. And quite nicely I might add."
"So what's troubling you?" he inquires as he takes a sip of his Bloody Mary.
"What do we do next? Nothing at all? Conjure up a new fantasy? Maybe different bondage scenarios?"
"I'm not sure about more bondage," he says with a frown.
"Me neither. I don't want anything more extreme than what you and Craig did to me last night. I'm not going to wear a dog collar and crawl around on a hotel floor saying 'yes master, yes master' while some guy is cracking a whip in the air," I respond. "And simply repeating last night with another couple would be a lot less exciting. If we do any more bondage stuff, it'll have to be different but still relatively mild."
"I agree," Max responds with a nod of his head. "So basically we stop doing this sort of thing or we start using our imaginations to..."
"Maybe push the envelope a little," I interrupt.
"Maybe. Any ideas?"
"Not a one," I answer.
"So let's just let the idea rest for a while until one of us comes up with something new."
"But as for bondage, you can tie me up and fuck me whenever, and however, you like," I offer with a mischievous smile. "I might even let you use the butt plug again," I add with a wink.
"I think that can be arranged," he offers with a grin.
"I'm counting on it," I reply as I take a bite of my bagel and another sip of my Bloody Mary. Now all I have to do if find out what Erin wants to talk to me about.
****
We are now back home from brunch and I'm trying to decide when to call Erin. The fact that she wrote a note rather than just tell me up front says that, for now at least, she wants to keep Craig out of it. I've already decided to do the same with Max until I know what's happening. On the other hand, she could have told me while we were in the ladies room and not use a note at all. Was she uncertain of my response? Until I can talk to her, it all remains a mystery.
I'm reluctant to call her on a Sunday because I don't know what the situation is at her house. I also don't want to sneak around my own home trying to keep the call a secret from Max. I finally decide to wait until tomorrow. Shit. I'll be a nervous wreck for the rest of the day.