My phone rang at 8:15 a.m., a bit early by New England phone etiquette standards. It was Mindy, a woman in my writers group. She sounded distressed and wondered if she could come by to talk. She mentioned something I couldn't quite make sense of, regarding marital issues, something I was no expert in, except that I had had some of my own. This morning in fact.
My wife and I had made love upon awakening, before she was to leave for the week at her out-of-town job. And as we lay there in what I thought was a quite pleasant afterglow, she, for some reason, reached back into the past and snipped, "Was that as good as with Rebecca?"
What followed was our perennial argument.
"That was years ago, honey."
"But you still want it. I know you do."
"I told you before we got married, that I could not do monogamy."
"I should never have married you."
"But we have had so many wonderful things to celebrate in our 45 years together."
"And one thing that I never will."
With that, she got out of bed, showered, dressed, and headed off for the week, after just a peck on my lips to say goodbye.
Mindy was due shortly, so I didn't have time for a shower. I pulled my clothes on, over my used body, and went into the kitchen to make a pot of coffee.
A few minutes after nine, I heard her knocking. Melinda Arroyo, an Anglo woman in her mid-60s, came in. Mindy, as she preferred to be called, was pretty, a little matronly plump after having had four children, but she still had luscious brown hair, without a strand of gray, just shy of shoulder length, matching her brown eyes, and framing a face with an omnipresent smile. This morning, though, she was uncharacteristically disheveled, smelling of cigarettes. Her hair was unusually mussed, and there was no hint of a smile on her face.
She accepted a cup of coffee, and we sat at our breakfast table to talk.
I knew little about the individuals in our writers group which had been meeting for a number of months. Only what we shared in our writings, which I assumed were somewhat autobiographical.
Mindy wrote mostly about straight couple matters. I wrote about people too, but mostly those encompassed in the rainbow coalition. Maybe because of our mutual interest in relationships, she thought to turn to me this morning to talk about hers. She began quite bluntly.
"I just found out that Ramon is having an affair. He's got a sex drive which we need to satisfy by love-making two or three times a week. This morning while we were doing so, he came inside me screaming "Maria, Maria" so when I asked who this Maria was, he faltered, tried to fabricate a story, then confessed."
I wasn't sure what to say, especially because I was feeling more like Ramon, although my interests were in men as well as in women.
She didn't look good. In fact, there was a slight tremor to her hand, as she brought the coffee cup to her mouth.
"Are you OK?" I asked.
Obviously, she wasn't. It was a stupid thing to say.
"Do you mind if I have a smoke? I don't regularly smoke cigarettes, but I keep a pack on hand for times when I feel stressed. It seems to take the edge off."
I didn't like cigarettes. I had been a smoker over forty years ago, before our kids were born. Both my wife and I smoked, in fact, but we had decided to quit when we started to conceive. Ever since then, the smell of cigarettes had made me nauseous, especially when going into the house of a friend who smoked.
But there was something about my wife's attitude this morning that bothered me. I felt annoyed. Angry. Maybe tinged with an underlying shame that I could never shake, even though I generally liked myself, and my polyamorous side. Her attitude toward me made me feel like I was a bad person. So I was going to be bad. Even badder.
Not only did I tell Mindy that she could have a smoke, but I asked her if I could bum one off her, too. She looked at me quizzically, but then offered me the pack. She then took one herself, lit mine and then hers. We sat in silence for a few minutes as we both inhaled and blew the smoke out, filling the room with a dense haze.
"Do you know what it's like when you give everything to your husband, including having sex three times a week when you're really not interested, and you find out he's banging another girl?"
I honestly did not know because my wife was faithfully monogamous. Though at times when I had fantasized about such a thing, I found it turned me on. Especially if she promised to let me in on things from time to time with her other man. But I couldn't really tell Mindy that, and so I just said in all honesty,
"No. I don't know what that's like."
I asked her to tell me more, which she obligingly did.
I mostly listened, taking a drag on my cigarette, tapping the ashes into my empty coffee mug, but maintaining my eye contact all the while. For some odd reason, when she explained in a very sensitive way what she was feeling, I looked beyond the smoking habit and her unkempt appearance and found myself feeling an attraction. Getting aroused, in fact. Something I shouldn't have been doing. I mean, it almost seemed like I was preying upon her vulnerability.
Our sharing a smoke seemed to help her somewhat. Her tremor was less noticeable now, as she continued to sip her coffee.
At one point, though, as the conversation continued, she got very tearful, and I moved my chair closer to hers, slid my arm behind her shoulders, and laid my other hand across her two hands clasped in her lap.
Her shaking returned a bit more violently, and she began to cry. I drew her head closer so that she could rest it on my shoulder, as I continued to sit and listen.
"I know it's not even ten o'clock in the morning, but I think I need a little glass of wine to calm my nerves," Mindy sobbed.
I was out of wine and only had a couple of lagers in the fridge. She said one of those would be fine, and I brought out two. Again, my bad boy attitude let me welcome a little buzz this morning. After all, each of us was hurting.
I popped the tops, gave her one and even though it was corny, we clinked and took our first long swallow. So from coffee to a smoke to a beer in less than an hour. I was really debauching it. We both were.
With what she shared with me, I felt I owed her some honesty on my part. And although it was a risk, and I felt it would be perhaps an insult to her, I told her about my conversation with my wife this morning. I was expecting her to be outraged, but she said something quite true, yet unexpected. The fact that I had told my then fiancee that I could not do monogamy and she still agreed to get married was different than her husband promising to be faithful and then going behind her back. She felt there was an honorability in me which was not present in Ramon.
I'd always found that more honesty led to a deeper conversation and a deeper conversation led to a deeper attraction. At least I was feeling that for Mindy, and I think she was feeling the same for me. Maybe it was the effect of the beers, but she started to rub my hand in a very affectionate way, and when she took her head off my shoulder and alternately wiped her tears on her sleeves, she gazed up into my eyes and offered me a very throaty "thank you."
I said "thank you" back, after a "you're welcome," and we hugged the kind of hug sitting in chairs that could not be a full bodied embrace, but still could show a kind of connection that was genuine, just not perfectly innocent. That became clear when, after we slowly released our hug, she turned fully toward me, with her eyes closed and moved her face toward me with her lips gently parted.
I accepted her offer to kiss.
If it were originally meant to be a brief one, her kiss did not stay that way. Rather, it led to a passionate probing of each other's mouth with our tongues, and a twisting of our heads from side to side to explore more deeply.
We paused long enough for Mindy to say,
"Ever since we started in our writing group, Mark, I've been feeling an attraction for you. I've kept it to myself because I wanted to be faithful to my husband. And I didn't want to do anything to affect things with you and your wife."
"I've always liked your writing, Mindy, and probably naΓ―vely didn't pick up on any signals that you were giving, because I thought you were completely satisfied with your marriage.
"Actually, I wasn't completely satisfied, but since I thought Ramon was happy, and because we'd been married for over 30 years, I just kept going on with things, thinking this is what long married life is like. But now I'm through being his faithful wife. Although being completely honest with you right now, it does feel a little bit like I am a cheating slut by kissing you."
"I'm feeling that in some ways, too. We've both been wronged today, and I'm feeling OK with making it right. I'm not exactly sure where this is going, but I wouldn't mind finding out.
We each took several long swallows of our beers to finish them and then began kissing madly again.
We forwent our contorted sitting positions for a standing embrace, and I reached under her top in back to undo her bra. She reciprocated by unbuttoning my shirt and pulling it down behind me and off my arms in an inside-out manner. Then she did the same with my T-shirt, so I was naked from the waist up.
I took her top off over her head, also inside out, and then pulled her bra down off her shoulders and freed her breasts. They sagged--she had had four babies sucking from them, after all--but they were smooth and beautiful and offered me a generous handful.