After my divorce, I was a little gun-shy about relationships, but did quite a bit of casual dating. This was the golden age of online dating, when decent sites were free, tons of people were on them, and you could actually meet people. I was living in the south at the time, and attended church fairly regularly, so mentioned that in my profile.
One of the responses I got was from a red-haired woman who was about 26 or 27, had a really cute face, and who told me that the thing that had attracted her to my profile was that I wasn't afraid to mention that I went to church. She didn't even lose interest when she found out that I was a Methodist, and not a Baptist like her. And she truly was a Baptist – no drinking, no partying, and – I would learn later, saving herself for marriage.
Just so you don't give up on the story right here and now, I will say that, whether or not she was only "technically" a virgin when we met, she was certainly only technically a virgin when our relationship ended.
On our first date, we ended up at my apartment, and made out on the couch. We kissed, held each other close, and I ran my hands over her body outside of her clothes. As I said, Carrie had a cute face porcelain white skin with freckles, full lips, a cute little button of a nose, green eyes, copper-colored red hair, and a well rounded body. Probably a healthy C-cup (although I'm generally not much of a breast man), but a very large, well rounded and surprisingly firm bubble butt. This girl was a Sir Mix-a-Lot dream girl, with her big, sexy butt wagging around behind her. She was a bit clueless, and didn't understand the reference until I played her the song.
"So you think my big butt is sexy? I always just thought I had a fat ass." She told me. "Do other guys like big butts, or is it just you and that Mix guy?"
"It's not just him and me, believe me Carrie, but they say that black guys are more likely than white guys to find big butts attractive."
"Oh! Do you think that's why black guys are always looking at me? I thought it was my hair." Every one of my black buddies who saw her commented on her "sweet looking ghetto booty" and joked that I must have learned some habits from "the brothers" at my very mixed high school. Maybe they were right – I've always been an ass man, and I wanted Carrie's ass real bad.
That first night, as we were making out, I squeezed her ass through her jeans, and she ran her hands into my shirt, brushing her fingers over my chest. "You know I'm a church girl, right? I told you about the church school I went to from third grade on, right?" She whispered huskily as I kneaded her firm cheeks with my fingers. I wondered if this meant she was going to insist on dragging me to Sunday service with her. She kissed me again, then licked my neck. "I hope you don't freak out or anything when I tell you this," she continued, stroking my chest with one hand, and groping for my cock through my trousers with the other. My own hands were sliding into her jeans, and starting to cup her ass cheeks. "But I'm saving myself until marriage."
Full stop.
"What? What did you say?"
"I'm saving myself – I'm a virgin." She gripped my cock through the fabric of my trousers, and gave it a tug. "Don't worry," She continued, seeing the look of confusion on my face. "I still know how to gave fun, how to help you enjoy yourself. It's just that I'm not going to let you fuck me – unless we get married first."
I decided that this was likely going to be our last date, as well as our first. "Should we stop?" I asked her.
"No," She giggled. "Not unless you want to. I'm enjoying the things I'm finding."
Okay, I thought to myself, if she gives good head, I don't need to fuck her – even though I'd love to tap that ass... Wait! Could this be that unicorn of girls – the virgin who sucks dick and takes it in her ass? I continued to explore her body as we continued to make out. Her hands went into my trousers, she awkwardly fumbled with the button and zipper, and just as awkwardly grabbed my cock and tugged on it – no stroking, just uncertain tugs.
"Lie back and relax." She told me. "I think I need to take care of you now." She continued tugging on my cock, looking up at me with an eager smile on her face. After about two minutes, she looked down at my cock, with a confused expression. "Is this alright? Usually the guy's finished by now." Then, her eyes lit up. "Do you want to titty fuck me? I'm really good at that!" She pulled her shirt over her head, unclasped her bra, and let her full breasts hang free. She grabbed her breasts and wrapped them around my shaft. "Okay now!" She smiled up at me. "You can titty fuck me now." I didn't have a lot of experience with this, my ex had perfect 32A/B breasts that fit her small frame nicely, didn't require a bra to stand up perkily, and had nipples like erasers that were easy to rb between my fingers, suck, or even lightly chew on. Carries breasts were more like water balloons, with large nipples that spread out across her breasts, not sticking up at all. I thrust my cock between her boobs, enjoying the novelty of the jiggly sensation. Carrie giggled again. Then, as I slowed down due to friction, she asked "Isn't this okay?"
"Yeah Carrie, it's great, it's just a little dry right now. Do you think you could, maybe..." I was thinking about what a good cocksucker a girl would have to be to keep her virginity until she was 26. "Lick it for me, to get some saliva on it?"
"Ummm, okay." She responded, with a smile, and grasping my hard cock in one hand, brought it up near her mouth, stuck out her tongue, and poked her tongue into the side of my cock. "Like that?" She asked. "Is that what you want?"
Okay, maybe she wasn't going to be a great or experienced cocksucker, after all.
"Carrie," I asked. "Exactly what kind of sexual experiences have you had before?"
"Well," She blushed and looked down, lowering her voice to a whisper. "My other boyfriends always finished up when I put them in my hands, then I'd wash up - except for one of them who liked to titty fuck me. I had to take a shower before I went home after dates with him."
"Are you sure you're 26?" I asked.