Matt didn't know it was my first time, and I didn't tell him until much later. Like so many insecure teens, I pretended what we did was no big deal, even though...I lost IT.
I was so happy! It was shitty sex, to be sure, but it was...approximately what I had expected, and I became RAVENOUS. It was all I could think about doing through the night and the next day; I masturbated like 10 times in the immediate aftermath. I was also riddled with anxiety about how to handle it, didn't if I should take any initiative...
But he texted me first, asking when we could "hang out" again, which made me literally laugh out loud, because we both knew what was up. I was horny as hell and he was my only sex partner, so I saw no reason to be coy and told him Tuesday evening after my last class. When I asked what he wanted to do, he kept it vague, for obvious reasons.
When I showed up to pick him up, I still had no idea what was going to happen, and felt like a cab driver when I asked him, "Where to?"
"How about a movie?"
I agreed but could barely conceal my disappointment, until he pointed out it was a drive-in. I thanked God in my mind. We saw some bland Hollywood piece of shit, so brainless that we knew exactly what was going on even when we took 20-minute periods to bone in between.
As soon as everything was set up and people around us got in their cars to watch, we got to work and hopped in my backseat. Stupidly, I'd worn a button-down which was hell to try and get off in a frenzy, but Matt grabbed my hand and told me to "just leave it." I realized he was kind of right; there was no point in getting naked; we might need to get dressed again quickly, so it was probably better for everyone involved if we just kept our tops on. He kept his t-shirt on.
A mild struggle ensued to get my pants off (again; why?! Now I know: if you wanna get fucked, wear a DRESS), but once he did, he got between my legs and on top of me. His hands played with my pussy over the panties, feeling the obvious wetness. I made sure to wear cute ones this time, but they went mostly unappreciated. He kissed me while he strummed me, and it was quite nice. I was unconsciously grinding on his hand and let my own hands reach under his shirt and explore his back and chest. After only a minute or two of that I felt him move my panties aside and start feeling around for the hole with his index finger. He found it easily, as I'd been wet since the moment he got in the car, and with this tiny bit of foreplay, was soaking through the lacy fabric.
He penetrated me with his finger and moved it gently in and out; I was so creamy that when there was any quiet moment in the movie, I could hear the rhythmic squish, squish, squish and I giggled a little. Matt seemed like he couldn't get enough of me. The car was warming up fast with our shallow breathing, and my lady's scent was definitely noticeable. Matt wasn't at it for more than a couple of minutes before he sat up and started fumbling in his pocket for a condom. I hadn't even seen him unzip his pants, but his hard dick was already out, standing fully erect. He hurried putting on the condom and then took a last look around to see if anyone had noticed anything; I suppose the coast was clear, because he sank back down onto me. I felt one of his hands pushing my panties aside while his thing poked at my pussy. The whole area was so creamy he found it easily, and pushed in.
It hurt a lot less this time, but I was still feeling stretched. I made a mental note in that moment that I should "practice" opening up more for him with some objects I could find around my parent's house and discreetly clean and put back: the pasta fork handle, the electric toothbrush...I should get a hair brush with a "better" handle...
I think Matt was conscious of possibly attracting attention, because he didn't pump very much. Once his erect cock was fully inside me, he just kissed me, felt me up, especially my tits over my shirt. It was turning me on and everything felt really good, but it wasn't pushing me toward an orgasm. I think it's something that a lot of men don't understand about women who want and like sex, even though they rarely or never orgasm from it; there's so much else going on with your senses, it's just a fun thing to do and sure way to bond with someone. Even though I was being fucked in the backseat of my car, shirt and panties still on, while a superhero movie blared in the background, I was feeling much better this time around with Matt.
When my nipples hardened he started really pinching and holding onto them and it kept me really wet. I think he started to lose some of his caution (or control) and started rhythmically thrusting. I couldn't have given less of a fuck if anyone was watching at that point, and used my left leg to pull him in and encourage the thrusting; it sucked just feeling that coarse denim instead of his firm backside. I'd only just found a comfortable position for all my limbs and was really getting into the fucking when he started moaning. He picked up speed for another five thrusts and then a really big moan, and finally I felt the spasming inside my pussy.
Unlike last time, he lingered a bit, as if to just hold me in that position, hold himself inside of me just a bit longer before separating. It was kind of nice being so thoroughly wrapped up, and I savored that feeling for a long time. I think I tried flexing my kegels for the first time, just wanting to feel up his penis inside me more, but being so untrained, it wasn't much of a squeeze. I did, however, feel him get a lot softer; I think there was some squishiness because of the semen in the condom too. Looking back, I'm amazed at how little seduction it took for me to get so wet, but I think it was because of the newness of the sensations; it made for an erotic feedback loop in my brain that I'd always be trying to catch over and over again.
Matt pulled off of me and turned away as he removed the condom, and I guess tried to clean himself up a little. I became really embarrassed as I sat up too and noticed the awkward messiness of the situation. My windows were completely fogged up, and the whole car reeked of cooch. It wasn't totally new to me; I'd dipped fingers in and even tasted it before, but this was much, MUCH more pungent than what my under-the-blanket diddlings made. It was also combined with latex (so gross) and Matt's sweat (gross too, but in a way I didn't mind).
We were both still panting a little. I sat up and adjusted my panties back, but they were saturated and long past any point of protecting my pants. "Hey, can you reach over to the glove box, there are some tissues in there."
"Oh sure, yeah. Here you go. Um...can I have one?"
"Of course."
We wiped ourselves in an awkward silence until we balled up the tissues and put them in my door pocket.
"You're a lot of fun," he said.
"Um...thanks, you are too."
"Did you, uh...finish?" In a second, a lot of thoughts raced through my head as I weighed a response. The total truth was not an option: Of course I didn't finish, are you fucking kidding me? That was only slightly less absurd than last time, which sucked pretty bad. But I also didn't want to scare this guy off, and I'm not mean by nature. Then again, we were adults (however young) and this (sex) was important to me, and furthermore, I did barely know this guy, so the stakes were pretty low even if he reacted badly. So I gave him a softened version of the truth.
"Um...I didn't, but it still felt really nice."
"Oh, well, um, do you want to? I mean, I can use my hands."
Now there's an idea. "Yeah, erm...sure, you want to?"
"Of course."
"Oh...yeah just like, the smell?"
"Oh I love it. I mean, not the condom; that reeks. But you smell great." GREAT?! It was a realization so intense that I felt like it gave me a superpower. Until that point, I'd thought there was no way a guy would like that sweaty, pickly, ham type smell that would come from there in torrents when I was aroused. Later I'd do some reading and understand that there are chemicals and pheromones in that smell that make a (straight) man's dick hard before they even see the woman they want to fuck.
That new confidence, along with Matt generally being such a sweet and gentle guy, made me game to try his hand. I lifted my butt up and whisked my panties off, putting them on the front seat on top of my pants, leaned back, and opened my legs. "Okay," I said, "try it."
He leaned in and started to make out with me, lots of kissing and boob touching, and then his right hand snaked down and got between my thighs. His index and middle finger rubbed gently on the outside of my pussy, but when they landed there, indirectly getting at my clit, it was electric. A moan rushed out of my mouth, and Matt took the direction well to basically just keep doing that. Though it felt good, after about a minute of that rubbing at that rhythm, I knew nothing was going to happen, and struggled in my head about what to do next, how to ask for something without sounding pushy. Was it pushy? I mean, he had already nutted; why shouldn't I? Fuck it.
"Faster...please." Good man did as he was told, and it was *almost* right. "Harder, just...yes..." There it was, I could feel it coming. But unlike the thousands of times I did it myself, because it was another person doing it, it wasn't *quite* right. But I knew I could get there. "Keep going," I encouraged as I closed my eyes. Unconsciously, I gripped his arm, perhaps wanting to control the pace a little bit as I got over the hump. In a few minutes, I was finally there, the familiar quaking shocks jolting through my body, but it was so much more intense than when I was alone; I knew how orgasm quietly—I could even do it without much leg movement—but this time, I truly lost control of myself and moaned LOUDLY while my legs spasmed and my nails dug into his arm. I held his arm perfectly still—luckily he kept his hands and fingers rigid—and then I ground like three hard grinds over my clit and simply popped.
I was breathing hard, heart pounding. The moans stopped at least, but my head was back and I was seeing stars. Matt giggled; he looked pleased with himself, as he should have been. He was a quick study. After a little more basking, it looked like he was paying attention to the movie again. I put my panties back on but when I reached to get my pants, Matt caught my hand. "Are you cold?"
"Not really, but..."
"I'd like to go again soon, actually."