Disclaimer: I do not own Supergirl or anything to do with DC. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.
*****
Kara Danvers felt like she had been walking on egg shells around her adopted sibling the past couple of days. Alex hadn't freaked out after they had sex, or during the journey back, or to her knowledge even in their time apart, but things between them were a little awkward, and Kara knew it wouldn't take much for the other girl to freak out and put a stop to their relationship before it even really begun.
So as much as she didn't want to Kara gave Alex some time to breathe, while making it clear that she was here for her, if she needed her. Alex didn't say it out loud, but Kara was sure she was grateful for this. However the other side to it was she didn't want to wait too long, just in case Alex talked herself out of being with her. So a few days after their first time together she approached her at the DEO.
"Hey, can we talk?" Kara asked softly.
"Erm... I... I mean, sure." Alex stammered, quickly darting into an empty room, and then when Kara closed the door behind them she asked, "What's up?"
"I was wondering if you were free tonight?" Kara asked instantly, "Cause we haven't had a girls night in forever, and I know why that is, but I just miss you."
"I miss you too." Alex admitted softly, hating herself for it as it had only been less than a week since the last 'girls night', if that was really what this was, a point which she hesitantly clarified, "Just a girls night?"
"If you want it to be." Kara said hesitantly.
Alex bit her lip for a few long seconds, and then admitted, "I don't know Kara... I, I'm really busy."
"Come on Alex, please." Kara pleaded, glancing around briefly to make sure they were really alone and then lowering her voice just in case, "I just want to spent some time with you, that's all. No funny business, I swear. I'll be good. Just please come over?"
*
A few hours later Kara was on top of Alex, gently pinning the other girl under her super strong body as she kissed her. Which was something that Kara felt really bad about, or at least she wanted to be when she was done kissing Alex. To be fair she had genuinely planned a strictly sisterly night of fun, and had no intention of making a move on the other girl.
But it just kind of, happened. Kara wasn't even sure how it really started. One minute they were playfully teasing each other while watching a movie on Netflix, the teasing slowly turning from the mocking kind to the flirty kind as without thinking she inched closer to Alex, and Alex inched closer to her, and then all of a sudden they were both leaning in at the same time, and wow!
All of a sudden it came crashing back down to reality as Alex pulled back and whimpered, "Kara!"
For a few long seconds Kara studied Alex's face and the way she said that, which was a long time to someone who could move it super speed, and then she lowered her head and mumbled, "Sorry... I'm... I'm so, so sorry Alex."
"You're not." Alex pointed out softly.
"You're right, I'm not." Kara said flatly, and kind of boldly for her, before clarifying, "But you started it."
"Really?" Alex smiled softly, "Because it felt kind of mutual. And I know, I know you would never-"
"Lie just to get you here, so I could jump your bones?" Kara offered with a soft smile, before admitting, "Okay, I'd totally do that if you were my girlfriend, but I know we're not there yet, and I really did invite you over to Netflix without the chill part. Except, to literally chill, you know?"
"I know." Alex said softly, "So..."
"I should get off of you." Kara came to the realisation, unable to hide the disappointment in her voice.
"Yes, you should..." Alex mumbled, in her heart knowing it was for the best, "We, we should stop."
The fact that those words sounded so hollow gave Kara hope, but she still needed to get off Alex first. Like, she really, really needed to get off of her. And she would. It was just having Alex's body beneath her was literally a dream come true, and it was hard for her to lift herself up, especially when she felt Alex's boobs pressed against hers, one of Alex's legs in between hers and vice versa, and of course that beautiful face inches away from hers.
But she had been going to do it, honestly, and even pushed her hands down either side of Alex and started pushing herself up when the other girl suddenly grabbed her face and pulled her down into another kiss. Which Alex wouldn't have been able to do unless Kara wanted her too, and Rao, how Kara wanted her too.
Even before she came to Earth Kara was fluent in a variety of different alien languages, and thanks to her cousin and his Fortress of Solitude she had only learned more, but even with all those 'tongues' as the humans would say Kara couldn't accurately describe just how much she wanted Alex to pull her down into another kiss.
Sadly while it was proof that Alex wanted her too, the kiss combined with the conversation which came before it solidified that Alex was still very unsure about what was going on with them. This meant that Kara could either be a good friend, a good sister, and insist they go no further tonight. Or she could try and use her body convince to Alex this was what she should do. Which wasn't exactly an easy choice for her. Luckily for her Alex was kind of making the choice for her.
Alex knew this was the wrong choice, and was inwardly screaming at herself to stop, but for whatever reason she just couldn't. Kara's lips were just too kiss-able, and her body just felt so good pressed against hers, and most of all Alex just wanted her so badly. It was like that stupid Black Mercy induced dream about marrying Kara had awoken something inside of her, and ever since she had been nervous of thinking about her adopted sister, but it had got so much worse since they actually slept together.
Now Alex couldn't stop thinking about those things again, and then even more things, and now they were finally alone together for the first time in almost a week, and Alex just couldn't get it out of her head, no matter how much she tried to concentrate on the stupid movie.
Now here they were with her alien sister on top of her on the couch of Kara's apartment, making out like a couple of teenagers, Alex struggling to think of anything, let alone the reasons they shouldn't be doing this. Hell, at one point she went off on a tangent about how soft Kara's skin was under her fingertips as she pushed her hand underneath her adopted sibling's clothes, which was weird considering she was the Girl of Steel.
For that matter theoretically Alex should be getting crushed by ton of weight, yet Kara didn't feel heavy at all, Alex wondering if that was another superpower, or Kara was lightly floating or something. Alex almost considered asking, but no, she was far too preoccupied with kissing her sister.
Eventually Alex also became preoccupied with feeling her sister up, her hands slipping under Kara's loose shirt of their own accord to gently stroke her back and sides, and then when she realised she was doing that instead of stopping Alex went even further with it, namely bringing her hand up to cup Kara's boobs. Predictably this caused Kara to grin into the kiss and return the favour, then taking one step further by reaching down to grab Alex's butt with one hand while keeping the other on her tits.
They then kept groping each other like that for quite a while, even after they started switching between making out and kissing each other's necks. During this Kara carefully remove both their shirts and bras, so a few minutes later she could start kissing her way down Alex's chest, which again gave the older sister a chance to stop this, but she didn't.
Instead Alex just moaned, gasped and whimpered as Kara slowly kissed up one breast to wrap her lips around a nipple and then gently suck on it. After maybe a minute of that Kara kissed her way down one boob and up the other to repeat the process with the other nipple, then going back and forth between them while adding her tongue into the mix, swirling it around those nipples while Alex continued to let out sounds which were way too positive.