[This version of the story is identical to the previous Elvira story until the halfway point, at which point it takes an alternate path. This version emphasizes corruption, seduction and incest.]
*
"Oh, Bob..." Elvira gasped, rubbing her hands over Bob Redding's plaid shirt. She could feel his taut muscles underneath the soft flannel and she pulled the two of them tighter, pressing herself against his chest. "Hold me..."
Her voice was tremulous and frightened but she wasted no time throwing one of her long legs over his hip and leaning back as though faint, forcing Bob to gently lower her to the attic floor to prevent her from falling. She reached out, dimming the light of the oil lamp as Bob's muscular frame lay over hers.
He was breathing heavily and she could feel his heart hammering in his chest as she started to undo the top buttons of his shirt.
Finally! Country boys are fun but they're so slow on the uptake. I've been trying to bring this big oaf in for a landing since I came to town.
"Elvira..." Bob's voice was hesitant, uncertain.
Oh God, what is it? Is he a virgin? He's not going to try and marry me after this is he?
"Hey, don't get weird on me Bob...we're just having a bit of fun." She continued to unbutton his shirt, baring his chiseled, hairy chest and his rippling abdominal muscles. She ran her hands down his torso, moving slowly towards his waist. Since she'd gotten to this town there'd been nothing but horny teens and old creeps, so she was practically trembling in anticipation. "No harm in that, right?"
Her fingers undid the button of his jeans and, too impatient to undress him, she slid her hand down the front of his underwear. Her questing fingertips buried themselves in the wiry thicket of his pubic hair.
Seems like manscaping hasn't made it to Fallwell. Good thing I don't mind a few weeds on the lawn.
Elvira's fingers closed around Bob's dick...
"Wait...what the frick is this?"
It was soft.
She gave it an experimental squeeze, causing Bob's to make a weird little sound of surprise. Still soft. Not even a semi.
"What's the big idea, Bob?!" She snapped at Bob, staring up at him in consternation. "Or not so big, in this case."
"I'm sorry, Elvira. It's just..." He sat up, rubbing his neck. She couldn't make out his expression in the dim light of the attic but he sounded bashful. "The dog's watching."
"What?" She looked over to the far side of the crowded attic room. Sure enough, Algonquin was sitting on his haunches and staring at the two of them. The poodle's eyes glinted red, seeming to reflect more light than they should. "Gonk! Get! Can't you see I'm trying to dig up a bone?"
The poodle just wagged its tail, tongue lolling from its mouth.
"Dumb mutt..." She muttered. Trying to hide her annoyance, she flashed Bob what she hoped was a seductive smile. "Do you want to go down to the bedroom? Then maybe go down in the bedroom?"
"It's just never happened to me before." Bob looked uncertain.
"Don't worry, it happens to a lot of guys! We just need to give it a jump start."
"No, I don't mean that, I'm talking about...all of this." Bob waved his hand vaguely in the air. He started buttoning up his shirt and she could barely contain her disappointment as the expanse of tan skin was covered in that dumb black-and-red plaid once more. "I'm sorry, Elvira...tonight was just...a lot. First, there was the whole thing at the movie theater...then dinner tried to have us for supper...and the whole witch thing."
"Come on, it's not that big a deal." She did her best to sound casual. She had been trying not to think too much about everything herself.
You know what would help take my mind off all of it? A nice big cock!
"There was a giant snake just like...five minutes ago! And then it caught on fire!" Bob pointed at the circle of ash on the floor where the snake she had summoned had accidentally vanished. "Was that a demon? Are demons real? It's just...it's a lot to take in, you know? I just need some time to process."
Elvira sat pouting on the floor of the attic as Bob finished dressing and made his way through the crowded brick-a-brack of the attic. He stumbled over a few pieces of cobwebbed furniture, eliciting G-rated swears like "darn it" and "fudge" as he made his way to the stairs.
She lay back on the floor of the attic, listening to the sound of his footsteps headed out of the house.
"Looks like another night paddling the canoe all by myself, Gonk." She looked over at the dog, still wagging its tail. She sighed and turned her head, looking at the large trunk the two of them had uncovered, thinking about the revelations in the letter her great-aunt had left her.
I thought my mom was a bitch for dumping me in a convent...turns out she's a witch! And creepy uncle Vinnie is actually some kind of evil warlock?
With a sigh, she got back on her feet and turned up the oil lamp once more, filling the attic with flickering shadows. She picked up the so-called "recipe book" her aunt had left her, examining the cracked leather cover and running her fingers across the yellowed, ancient pages.
"I guess I'm not getting that fifty bucks after all." She muttered to herself. Fifty bucks probably wasn't worth handing a book of spells over to the man who killed her mother.
She looked down at the trunk, filled with unusual, occult-looking garbage.
I wonder if anything in here is worth selling? I doubt Uncle Vinnie is going to play nice if I decide not to hand over the book but I'll need cash if I'm going to get out of town.
She sat down by the trunk and started to dig around inside, tossing aside anything that didn't look valuable.
"Mogwai spores...Leprechaun repellant...Krampus dung...ew, gross." She read off labels on canisters and boxes before flinging them over her shoulder. "What the hell is this?"
It was a large book with a cover of stitched-together leather creating the shape of a distorted face. A small yellow post-it note was stuck to the cover with the word "Necronomicon".
"Creepy." She flipped through the book until she reached a random page. "Let's see...klattu...barada..."
She shook her head and snapped the book closed, dropping it next to the trunk. I've already got one weird book that I can't read, I don't need another one.
"Oh? What's this?"
She pulled out a small, rectangular object wrapped in moth-eaten black cloth. She tore the covering off and her eyes widened with excitement. Inside the cloth was a wooden box, carved with unusual symbols and inlaid with gilt. It was about the right size and shape to be a jewelry box.
"Oh, auntie Morgana, what do we have here? I'm sure you wouldn't mind if I pawn some of your old jewelry, would you?"
She reached out to open the box but she almost jumped out of her skin at the sound of a blood-curdling growl. She turned around, quickly enough that she practically spilled out of the front of her dress. The sound was coming from Algonquin. The dog's teeth were bared and its eyes still glinted red in the lamplight, fixated on the box in Elvira's hands.
"What's gotten into you, Gonk?" He was definitely looking right at the jewelry box, with a vicious expression entirely out of place on the poodle. She shook her head. This dumb dog had already cock-blocked her once tonight, she wasn't going to take it again. "Come on, you stupid mutt. Get out."
She dropped the box back into the trunk and Algonquin immediately calmed. He still whimpered when she picked him up by the scruff of the neck and dragged him to the stairway. Closing the attic door behind him she returned to the trunk once more and retrieved the box again. Visions of jewels and rings danced in her head as she grabbed the lid of the box.
It was locked.
She tried tugging harder.
It still wouldn't open.
"Come on! Can't I get a break for once in this stupid town?"
She dug through the pile of loose objects in the trunk, hoping to find some kind of key for the jewelry box's tiny lock. There was a large ring of keys in the chest but they were all big, rusty keys that looked like they belonged in a medieval castle.
"Ah-hah!" She exclaimed, pulling out her discovery. It was a knife, sporting a short, wide blade and a pentagram design on the hilt. It wasn't a key but beggars couldn't be choosers.