And it felt so good that, to her great shame, Alexa had very nearly broken. Something that she might do if she agreed to this latest proposal. But now her love for getting her little ass fucked had been reawakened, could she really turned Nikki down?
It was unfair to expect Nikki to do something that Alexa wouldn't, unless she had too. And that finger felt so good in her ass. Especially when it was joined by a second one. Oh God, while Alexa was fully debating her next move, Nikki pushed her luck by pushing an extra finger into the other female wrestler's butt hole.
Something which was obviously designed to force a yes out of The Goddess. And to Alexa's shame, it worked. Because oh fuck, it felt so good, that Alexa just continued. The only problem now, was saying yes while clinging onto a little bit of dignity while doing it. If that was even possible. The poor little blonde wasn't convinced, and the brunette wasn't making it easy, given how smug she looked. But she had to try.
So, after burying her face in the bed sheets, Alexa grumbled, "Fine!"
"What was that, Alexa?" Nikki pushed gently, trying to be clear she wasn't trying to be mean, but knowing that it was coming off that way, "I need to hear some proper consent from you, otherwise I won't do it. I would never make anyone do anything that they didn't really want to do. Especially not you. I hope you know that. I, I just-"
"I said fine!" Alexa snapped angrily, after lifting her head up from the bed sheets to make it clear what she was saying, "Fuck me! Okay? Mmmmmmmmm, fuck my ass! Oh God, I... I want you to fuck my ass."
Which in turn, had Nikki grinning with wicked delight, especially given the way that Alexa went from being angry too embarrassed by what she was saying. Unfortunately Nikki really pushed her luck by chuckling in reply, although she just couldn't help herself, or stop herself from teasing, "Anything for you... Lexi The Butt Slut."
Hearing that name again was exactly why Alexa didn't like to be called Lexi, and it should've snapped her out of whatever lust drunk haze she was under, to turn the tables back to what they should be. But she didn't, because Nikki then pulled her fingers out, and replaced them with a strap-on. There was a pause in which the other woman sucked those fingers clean, and Alexa actually felt jealous of her.
That, and the words, had her pressing her face against the bed sheets and whimpering in shame. And because she knew what would happen next. And sure enough, Nikki quickly got up, and quickly retrieved a strap-on, covered it with lube, and then started to use it to stretch the fallen Goddess's ass hole.
Thankfully she didn't push her luck, by asking Alexa to spread her cheeks, or even finger her own butt in preparation for this. Two things which to her shame, Alexa almost did without having to be asked. But she wanted to do it. Oh God, she wanted to expose herself, and continue to keep her slutty little back door ready for this, and was just so horny in that moment, that she would've done anything that she was asked.
Which was obvious, given that she whimpered, cried out, and even moan just from the feeling of her ass being once again being stretched with a nice big dick. Oh God, she had missed this so much. And Nikki was doing it perfectly. Nice and slow, so they could both savour every precious moment that slutty little butt hole got what it so desperately needed. As the other woman had rightfully called it.
Nikki had a huge twisted grin on her face, as she watched the head of her strap-on slowly stretching the hole in front of her wider, and wider, and wider, until she did it! She actually did it! Oh God, Alexa Bliss's perfect little butt hole stretched wide enough for the first few inches of that dick to slide into it, this meaning that Nikki Cross was inside of Alexa Bliss. Inside that perfect little bubble butt. Oh fuck, this was the greatest day of her life.
Something she desperately wanted to point out, given what a big moment this was for her. However, she was also on very thin ice, and she didn't want to risk pushing the other girl to call the whole thing off. Besides, even someone as chatty as her, knew there were times where silence spoke volumes.
Hell, this particular silence was deafening, as although it was far from Alexa's first time, it was the first time in a long time giving up her butt willingly. At least as far as Nikki knew. And she was giving it up to someone much lower in the pecking order than she was. Someone who hadn't ever topped anyone of real note. Until now. Oh yes, this was the biggest win of Nikki's career, and honestly, it felt better than winning a match at Wrestlemania.
She imagined. Were there ways this could be better? Sure, Alexa could've been spreading her cheeks, and begging for it. But there was also something to be said for this silent submission, something they both savoured for a few long seconds, before the brunette started pushing her dick deeper into the blonde's bowels.
She of course had no problem spreading those cheeks herself, ensuring herself the best view possible of that big dick disappearing into that perfect little ass hole. Also, it just increasing the domination she was experiencing tenfold. And without a doubt the submission that Alexa was experiencing, which might be even more important. God, it was so beautiful, that Nikki almost didn't notice the reaction she was getting from all this.
Then there was just the fact that while there were whimpers and cries of pain, mostly, it was of pure pleasure. Oh God, Alexa Bliss was loving every second of this. And why wouldn't she? Her bubble butt was literally made for this. Something that Nikki had to point out, when her thighs came to rest against those meaty cheeks, announcing every inch of the dildo was buried deep within that hot little booty.
"Oh my God Alexa, mmmmmmmmm, you did it! Every single inch of that big dick in your big booty!" Nikki exclaimed excitedly, even clapping her hands in delight, before going right back to spreading, and fondling, those meaty cheeks, "Ooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, you just took every inch of that strap-on in yer shit-pipe! And so easy, too. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, you took it so easy up the butt. Took it like the anal loving slut you are, mmmmmmmmm, because this is what this big fat arse was made for. And I'm so proud of you, for finally feeding this cock starved hole. And now? Oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, I'm gonna give you exactly what you need. Oh yes, aaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh, take it, Lexi! Take it all! Ah fuck!"
Poor Nikki knew she was pushing her luck here, but she just couldn't resist continuing her happy words as she officially began to sodomize Alexa Bliss. To be fair, she was barely aware of things she was saying, and the other woman was almost certainly in the same boat, given she was experiencing the overwhelming feeling of having a cock beginning to be pumped in and out of her ass hole.
Especially given that whatever sounds of discomfort Alexa had been making before, quickly went away in favour of pure pleasure. Which again wasn't surprising, as it only reinforced everything that was already known about this perfect booty, and the Goddess of a woman attached to it.
Alexa desperately tried to hide her own enjoyment, but it was no use. It just felt so incredibly good. Her treacherous ass was just too well-trained, especially after being reminded of what it loved so much. Oh God yes, her big booty welcomed the dick invading it, so much so that Alexa even found herself enjoying the pain.
Which didn't even last that long, because it felt like she was able to take every inch of that strap-on in her shit-pipe ridiculously quickly. Most likely because Nikki had chosen a humble 8 incher, which was tiny compared to some of the monsters which had been shoved up her booty. And her greedy little butt hole craved more. God, she even got close to begging for that, rather than a simple orgasm.
Partly because Alexa was afraid what cumming would do to her. It might just be the last straw, which broke her once and for all. But mostly? She just wanted this to last longer. For her slutty little ass to be stretched out with increasingly big toys, until she couldn't take it anymore, and she hysterically begged for more.
That's what someone like Charlotte would've done, and in that moment, Alexa shamefully wished that was the case. Something that she actually thought again, when she was then given the chance to cum. However, at the same time she recognized that she was lucky to have someone as kind as Nikki, who actually followed through on giving her what she so desperately needed. Or at least, the nicest version of it possible.