Exactly what I had thought was going to happen, happened. The game of dares that my newfound friends and I had been playing for the last few hours, has been progressively getting more heated. For most of the game Sean, Nathan and Zack had been getting dared to do things amongst each other, whilst Liv and did our own dares. However, This dynamic changed for Liv when Nathan was dared to stick his fingers inside her, leaving me as the only one to be brought into their group.
This all changed when I received a dare from Nathan.
All he said was, "My dare for you is to jerk off Zack for two minutes."
Now in the context of the game, this dare was pretty tame, but up until that moment, the only other person I had ever sexually touched was Liv and that was less than an hour ago. I had also been under the impression that Nathan was somewhat on my side, as he had been the one to get me to touch Liv, but eventually, his attitude must have shifted and now my greatest ally was working against me.
The only thought going through my mind at this point was that Zack had a very likely chance of cumming from my intended actions and I wasn't too sure that I was ready for that. This dare was something I realised might happen when I agreed to continue playing this game, but now that the time had come, I wasn't too sure whether I was ready to go through with it.
Liv sensed that something was off and gripped my hand tightly in an attempt to comfort and encourage me. If I chickened out again from a dare, this may be what stops Liv from wanting to go out with me. She seemed so eager and willing to do all of the dares that she was given and enjoyed them to their max.
After taking a big breath I nervously responded, "Okay, sure I'll do the dare."
With that Zack stood up, and moved his way over to my couch. Liv stood as well, parting ways from me for the first time in a while. Sitting next to me, Zack leant back against the couch, giving me as much access to his dick as possible.
Knowing I had committed to the dare and there was no backing back out now, my hand slowly extended downwards until it was enveloping the smooth cock next to me. Being the first time feeling another guy's penis, I was amazed at the differences and similarities to mine. We were both uncut, so we still had our foreskin, but his was much shorter. It was short enough that when you brought the skin back, his head would become exposed all the way. Zack was also pretty much hairless down there, so it was weird to feel a dick that had nothing impeding it.
I started to slowly move my hand up and down his dick like I would do on my own. It was a weird sensation because it kind of felt like I was jerking myself off except I couldn't feel any of the pleasure.
After all of the continual jerking that he had received throughout the afternoon, it wasn't a surprise that Zack had his orgasm so early on. It hadn't even been a minute when I started to feel his warm rod start to pulsate between my fingers. Liv threw the towel that Sean had used to clean up his spunk, at me from the opposite side of the room. I caught it and managed to get it into position just as the first string of cum flew out of Zack.
I continued to slowly stroke him through his orgasm. Spurt after spurt came out and landed on the towel, which I had laid across his lap. A little drizzle had landed on my hand towards the end of his orgasm, which caused me to pull back in slight disgust and wipe it on the towel. Zack let out a slight whimper when my hand left his cock.
"Aah, that felt so good. I really needed that release," he exclaimed, as he started to stand and move back to his original seat.
"I bet it did, his fingers feel amazing, " teased Liv. "There's only one more of you guys left to finish until it's my turn, and I know who I want to get me there."
Liv was looking directly at me when she said this, giving me a wink when finishing. My erection bounced with the thought of what she wanted me to do.
Eventually, Liv started to saunter back over from where she was leaning and sat back down. Rather than sitting down like she had before, she chose to rest entirely on top of me. Sitting sideways on my lap, she extended her legs down the couch and brought her arms up around my neck, to stabilise herself. As she moved to sit down, I felt the warmth and wetness of her pussy swipe across my dick a couple of times. This got me super hard and I was now ready to cum again.
"Seeing as Nathan is the last guy to finish, I think it's fair that he be the one to get jerked off next," I started to nervously explain to the others. "To whom I am giving this dare, is none other than Sean. Since Nathan managed to get you off, it is only fair that you return the favour."
I had had such a great experience with this game, I thought it only fair that Nathan gets to feel the immense pleasure that I had received from Liv and what I had also just given to Zack. So, a similar scene to what had just happened between me and Zack occurred between Sean and Nathan.
Sean spat into his hands and got them all lubed up, before plunging them into Nathan's crotch. He stroked the circumcised cock for a few minutes, keeping a consistent speed, until the inevitable climax began. Using the same towel as previously, Sean tried to catch as much cum as he could.
It felt different for me to see Nathan cum, than it had for the others. I don't know whether it was due to the differences between a circumcised and uncircumcised dick during orgasm, or whether it was because Nathan was the only person here that I truly knew and I was getting to see him in his most vulnerable. It was probably the latter.
"Thanks, Sean, that felt great," complimented Nathan. "And thank you Josh for caring enough about my needs."
"You guys are weird. I like that you've been helping each other out," said Liv.
"Oh, you noticed," I responded sheepishly.
I had hoped that what Nathan was doing for me was a little subtle, but oh well.
"It wasn't that subtle. Besides, I think it's hot that you guys were willing to help each other," she said.
"Speaking of helping others, my next dare is for Zack," said Sean, jumping in. "Although Zack seems confident when it comes to anything sexual, he's never done anything with a girl before. So, in the spirit, I dare you Zack to finger Liv."
This was actually a surprise to me. Zack seemed to be the most confident, out of the group, when it came to doing any of the dares, which made me think he had done many things, but this was clearly not the case.
At this moment I realised Zack was pretty much just like me, nervous and inexperienced. Upon reflection, it seemed that pretty much everyone had been pretty hesitant when playing with each other. They were all just like me.
I was brought out of my thoughts when Liv started to shift around on top of me. It had become clear that Zack had moved next to me and was sitting on the couch with a very recognisable grin on his face, one that showed his enjoyment whilst trying to mask the nervousness he felt.
Liv slipped into Zack's lap, very similar to the way she had been when I had to complete a similar dare. Her head back against his chest, she spread herself wide, leaving the opening ready for him to explore. Zack didn't move, however. Now that the time had come, he was frozen in fear.
Calmingly, Liv grabbed Zack's hand and guided it to her glistening opening. Slickening his fingers in her juices, she let go leaving him to his own devices. Slowly but steadily he started to explore, rubbing his fingers up and down her meaty folds. Finding the hidden location of her hooded clit. Before ultimately, entering the not-so-forbidden cave.
