Monica's story: Thursday evening
I was trying to stay awake and finish reading this incredibly boring chapter on Reconstruction after the Civil War, when the phone rang. Maybe it was Jennifer, I thought, since I was wondering why she was out so late. But it wasn't Jennifer; it was Jennifer's
mother!
"Hello, Monica, may I speak to Jennifer."
"Uhhh, Mrs Matthews, Jennifer isn't here right now."
"Oh." There was a moment's silence while Mrs Matthews processed the fact that her good Christian daughter wasn't in her dorm room after nine o'clock at night. "Is she out with that Mark Stewart fellow?"
"I don't know, ma'am. She did have a lot of homework to get done, and she sometimes goes to the King Library when stuff gets really piled up, to avoid all of the distractions in the dorm." I was lying through my teeth; I knew that she was going to do a home cooked meal for Mark at his place tonight.
"Alright, then, when she gets back, tell her that I'll be picking her up tomorrow, not her father. I was wanting to ask her if she was going to bring Mr Stewart home with her this weekend, so I could prepare my husband for the shock, but since she's not there, I'll pick her up tomorrow instead of her father."
"OK, I'll tell her that you called. Goodbye, Mrs Matthews."
"Bye, now."
I ran over to Rachel's room, and burst in: "Jennifer's busted! Her mom just called, and guessed that she was out with Mark."
"Oh, don't worry, Jennifer will be back soon enough, and can call her mom back and have her story straight."
"Uhhh, I'm not so sure that she's going to be back that soon. Remember how she messed up when Mark told her that he loved her, and she couldn't say it back? She had told me that she was planning on telling him tonight."
"Monica, that doesn't mean she's going to screw him tonight. I know that she hasn't been able to start those birth control pills yet; I think she said that she'll get her period this weekend."
"Oh, crap, I know where to find the answer," and I ran back to my room. I opened up Jennifer's desk drawer, rummaged around, and didn't find what I expected not to find. I ran back to Rachel's room. "Rache, the rubbers that Planned Parenthood gave her, in case they get going before her pills can take effect, they're gone."
Alice had to jump in at that one. "Looks like my $50 for her new clothes was money well spent!" She had a huge grin on her face.
Mark's story: Thursday evening
Jen and I had had a wonderful, southern dinner that she had cooked for me in my apartment, and we'd just been cuddling and kissing and whispering sweet nothings to each other, when she said it: "Make love to me, Mark."
Oh, my God, I was so stunned, and so elated, but so concerned. "Jen, are you sure?"
Jennifer was actually crying. "Oh, Mark, I was so flustered after you told me that you loved me, and I was too scared to say it back to you. I've been planning on this moment, when I was going to tell you that I love you, I knew I was going to tell you tonight, and I was getting ready to tell you, and, when I did, I guess that my heart changed the words from what I was planning to say to what I really wanted to say. Oh, yes, please, please, please, make love to me. Make love to me. Make love to me."
Jen, my beautiful Jen, was kissing me with abandon, and she was crying, tears of absolute joy, and no man could ever have resisted her, a gay guy couldn't have resisted her, a freaking statue couldn't have resisted her. I certainly couldn't, and didn't want to. All of my fantasies about sex-crazed women wanting to screw me ragged were just blown away into the dust, shattered, destroyed, by this one soft, loving, tender woman who wanted to make love with me.
A million thoughts went through my head, in just a second. Jennifer Matthews, the girl I had only slightly known a week ago, but still the woman of my dreams, the good Christian girl who always seemed so dowdy a week ago, was the beautiful, passionate, love-filled woman who wanted to be with me! I was worried, wishing that I had the kind of experience to make this great for her, but ever so glad that she would be my first. I'd talked with other guys, sure, but I really didn't know what to do.
But my love, my lover, and I, we'd figure it out together.
"Oh, yes, Jen, yes!" I wanted to rip off her clothes, but I didn't. I was so unsure of myself, but I unbuttoned just one more button on her blouse, and she kept smiling, and kept kissing me, and started pulling up on my t-shirt. I undid another button, and then just plain fumbled on a third.
"You don't know what you're doing any more than I do, do you, Mark?" Jen pulled back a little ways.
"No, sweetheart, I don't. You'll be my first." Jennifer responded with a wonderful smile, and started unbuttoning her shirt for me, and then threw it on the couch. She reached around her back, unhooked her bra, and dropped it on the floor, while I pulled my t-shirt over my head and threw it off to the side. She stepped closer, and pressed her breasts against my chest, her arms up over and around my neck, kissing me again. Then she reached down, and pulled something out of her purse; she had brought a pack of condoms! My sweet Jennifer had known that this was going to happen, all along. She kicked off her sandals, and unbuttoned those button-fly Levi's 501 jeans that looked so good on her, took my hand, and led me into my own (tiny) bedroom.
We were in bed, kissing and hugging, when I had to stop to open up and roll on the condom. The last barrier fell then, when Jennifer pulled off a cute pair of cotton bikini panties, the kind I had never expected to see her wear. She got up on her knees and pushed me down on the bed, and said, "Let me." Jennifer got on top of me, took my manhood in her hand, and lowered herself down slowly onto me. I could feel the resistance for a moment, and then she pushed herself down on me harder; a wince of pain crossed her face for a moment, but a second later it was replaced by her wonderful, sweet, and still innocent smile.
Oh, Lord, I was in heaven! The condom helped, slightly insulating the feeling. I wished that it hadn't been there, so that I could be feeling all of Jennifer, but it was just enough help to keep me from shooting off too soon. It seemed like the pain passed away quickly, as Jen was slowly rocking away, slowly making love to me. I knew that a lot of women couldn't have an orgasm the first time they made love, due to the pain of the torn hymen, but with her smile and soft coos of pleasure, I knew that my sweet Jennifer was feeling wonderful, was loving this feeling and she made love to me. I was doing everything I could to hold off, when her cry of pleasure sent me over the edge. I had never seen a girl, no, seen a
woman,
have an orgasm, but I knew that Jen just did, and that was it, I could hold back no longer, and had my own fantastic release.
Mark's story: 2:10 AM
I'm usually a very sound sleeper, but I woke up in the middle of the night, with Jennifer asleep beside me, with her head on my right shoulder, and her hand on my chest. A sudden rush of emotion ran through me. I've heard of it once before, the sense of elation that a man feels the first time he wakes up with a woman in his arms. I remember the first time Jen and I made love, but almost as remembering a dream, but I will never, ever forget that first time I woke up with her in my arms. I was able to lightly kiss her forehead without awakening her. I wanted to go to the bathroom, but I wasn't willing to move, wasn't willing to leave Jennifer's side for even a moment. I just laid there, loving the feeling of my wonderful girlfriend, laying in my arms. I guess that I must have shifted a little bit, because she then whispered, "I love you, Mark," looked up at me in the slight light coming through the transom, and kissed me.
It's not very romantic, but when a man's got to go, a man's got to go. I got out of bed, walked into the bathroom and took a long, hard piss. Then, just as I was finishing, Jen walked in. "Women have to pee, too, you know!" She took care of her business, and then we climbed back in bed together.
Jennifer's story: 6:14 AM
I felt Mark stirring again. His waking up awakened me, and the sunlight in the next room illuminated Mark's tiny bedroom. I could see his chest rising and falling, I could feel his breathing, and I could hear his heart beating in his chest. My right hand was on his chest, and my hair was spread out everywhere, on the pillow, over my body and onto his chest. Mark's left hand was idly playing with my hair, when he detected that I was awake, too, and he took my hand. "I love you, Jen," he whispered to me. "I love you, Mark," I answered back. "Would you make love to me again?"
We knew more what we were doing this time, as Mark got another condom and put it on; he was already ready to go! I could feel myself getting wetter, as the heat within me grew. Somehow, this was different from last night, more intense, not as soft, more urgent. Mark got on top of me this time, and entered me with a firm, steady motion. Good Lord, I was in heaven the first second! I could feel the heat building up inside me quickly, and there was no pain in the background, like there was last night. I was getting hotter and hotter by the second, and quickly erupted in a tremendous climax. I expected Mark to go off soon, but he didn't. Instead, he started making love to me harder, and I could feel a second wave building up in me. When that washed over me, Mark gave a roar, and had his own climax.
It was almost as though we were long time lovers. There was a casualness as I watched Mark get up and head back to the bathroom, while I laid in his bed, naked, not even thinking of covering up. I heard him start his bathwater, and then step into the tub, and I just had to go look at my boyfriend, at my lover.
It's not like he was in any great position when I walked in: there's no shower in his bathroom, so he was laid all the way down in the tub, getting his hair wet for shampooing, and it looked kind of awkward, but I still had to smile. I wasn't a girl anymore, I was a woman, and it was all due to this wonderful, wonderful man with his knees up in the air and his head down in the bathwater. He came back up with a splash, and opened his eyes and saw me. "Good morning, sweetheart," he said to me, as I sat down, still glowingly naked, on the edge of the bathtub. We talked about nothing at all for a bit, just sweet endearments until he was done. He stood up in the draining bathtub, and was drying himself off with a coarse-looking plain blue towel, and I marveled at the sight of this glorious man who was now my lover. He was trim, not heavily muscled but still very fit looking, like an almost nineteen year old man should look. He had dark hair, on his arms and legs, around his manhood, and some on his chest. I remembered playing with his chest hair a bit ago, and that was fun. It was like I was a completely different person from who I was two weeks ago.